|
On May 20 2013 07:26 marvellosity wrote:
the good news from this tete a tete is that it makes you look townie, as you're arguing it very genuinely.
Don't worry, i'm probably gonna get killed if you are not.
But after all, i do not think BH would claim when he did if he was mafia and you were town.
Do you still think iamp is town?
Do you still think GK is town?
Dandel?
Those guys are really scummy for me.
|
EBWOP:
But after all, i do not think BH would claim when he did if he was mafia and you were town.
..because he would at least have discussed with his team how to handle the situation if it seemed like a situation where there is no outs other than a claim.
|
On May 20 2013 07:32 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On May 20 2013 07:32 raynpelikoneet wrote:EBWOP: But after all, i do not think BH would claim when he did if he was mafia and you were town. ..because he would at least have discussed with his team how to handle the situation if it seemed like a situation where there is no outs other than a claim. not if he was panicking. see how circular this is? 
I understand what you mean. :D
I don't understand though how anyone would panic before discussing the matter in scumchat as scum if there is still ~24h left in the day and other viable candidates.
|
Actually no, i don't think you can both be mafia.
|
i agree with your list, i would change iamp to BH.
DP i'd downgrade to secondary. he had a strong early game but now he is being less and less helpful.
|
On May 20 2013 07:50 Spicydinosaur wrote:Dandel if you thought that sputnik should be vig shot and not lynched then why vote at the last second for the lynch? Show nested quote +On May 19 2013 21:00 Dandel Ion wrote:On May 19 2013 05:45 marvellosity wrote:
The weirdest thing about Dandel that I noticed is when he gave a bunch of names he could lynch, sputnik wasn't one of them, when it seemed he would fit on the list he made. Becaue 1) I find him mildly amusing 2) he's hyper-lurking which should be dealt with by vigshootings/host KP
Do you think GK is scum?
|
Why the fuck was anyone voting for spicy before his WoS/Jarjar stuff?
|
On May 20 2013 08:21 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Why the fuck was anyone voting for spicy before his WoS/Jarjar stuff?
Actually nobody was, but the lynch is 100% scum driven. rofl. and for what reasons.
|
because noone was here telling what to do other than me. where were you?
|
Why do everyone seem to assume they have to mason a townread of theirs? If i was a mason i would definitely mason a scumread or null.
|
I'm all in for lynching BH. His post about 3 scum seems like a slip and i can't see his follow up after that coming from a townie. Also this is a post that raised red flags on him earlier:
On May 18 2013 06:57 Blazinghand wrote:
So, new rule: Vayne is a VI. Ignore him, check him if you are a DT or vig him if you are a vigi, policy lynch him before lylo if he's still alive. There's a possibility he also rolled scum but judging by his last game and this one there's no real way to tell. Not a worthwhile D1 lynch.
So he did not want to lynch Vayne, but said he should be lynched before LYLO. D1 is the easiest phase for mafia to mislynch. This post screams "keep this guy alive, so we can lynch him later". That's also not a townie thing to say. If you believe someone is scum, you vote for them, if you believe they are town, you don't. But you don't just ignore people and say "let's lynch him later".
|
i still don't see why iamp is town, no matter how hard i try.. can someone explain it to me?
|
I don't think he has done much overall.. A lot of one liners and chatting which is not game relevant (or at least finding scum -relevant). The only thing he has is his list, where he calls solstice town and me null when we have same scumreads. I still fail to see how my/his activity has anything to do with that? The point of the game is telling who is mafia and lyncihng them. You don't need a 10 page filter to do so as iamp seems to assume you do.
|
On May 20 2013 20:44 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On May 20 2013 20:41 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I don't think he has done much overall.. A lot of one liners and chatting which is not game relevant (or at least finding scum -relevant). The only thing he has is his list, where he calls solstice town and me null when we have same scumreads. I still fail to see how my/his activity has anything to do with that? The point of the game is telling who is mafia and lyncihng them. You don't need a 10 page filter to do so as iamp seems to assume you do. iamp plays mafia very simply. Are they trying? Are they scumhunting? In his opinion s0lstice had been trying harder than you, which is a tick in the town box that you didn't have. There's a reason only you seem to give a shit about this point.
Well he seems to be playing against his own rules as he seems to be not trying/scumhunting much. Most of his posts are either agreeing/disagreeing with someone, or some questions for random people. I'm not seeing what he is trying to achieve with those questions.
I know you don't need to post every singe thought of yours in thread and sometimes it's beneficial not to reveal you think someone is scum and try to ask them about something that might give you a better read on them (as they could feel "safe" that way). But if iamps "guidelines for optimal scumhunting" are what they are, he is playing against them.
|
Fair enough. After all he is not my #1 candidate for lynch tomorrow. I'm looking forward to see what BH comes up with readwise. Besides his slip he looks much like he was in Carnival D1. I don't know if he usually is useless as town aswell, but that makes me want to lynch him even more. Now looking more into Dander and GK.
|
|
|
Yeah at that time i thought that theory was stupid. Now, given his posts after that and what DP has pointed out, i'm not so sure about it.
On a sidenote, i think GK is more likely to be scum than Dandel and i do not think they are both scum. Maybe i am wrong about WoS or Jarjar, i need to see what they will do on D2.
|
I suggest the possible medic should consider protecting yamato.
|
The problem is if marv is scum nobody has balls to lynch him other than me & yamato.
|
On May 21 2013 03:57 iamperfection wrote:
if there's anyone who wouldn't take more pleasure in lynching a scum marv it would be me. Dandel would love doing bh would love doing it.
Signs point to a town marv at this moment he should be protected.
There is noone in thread that can't possibly be scum other than yamato for me. And i remember Dandel's retarded comments from Red where he stated that marv can't be lynched on D1 so it's not worth looking into him. So no, i don't think Dandel would lynch marv. Dunno about you and BH.
You however have a point in marv/BH mason thing (i guess you are referring to that?). Assuming BH is scum marv would be valuable as town, but still.. yamato is the towniest guy in thread.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
