Doctor Who Mafia - Page 6

On May 17 2013 05:01 marvellosity wrote:
My case wasn't 50% meta. My case was that you made a shit case and didn't interact with anyone.

Don't misrepresent.

On May 17 2013 01:38 marvellosity wrote:
I actually have remarkably little time between now and the deadline, which is annoying. Curses early deadline!

There are two main reasons I could lynch deconduo, since I keep canvassing opinion about it.

First of all, there's the drop and run case on ghost. It's an easy case for mafia to make (yes yes, I know I agreed with some of it), and besides it there's very little interactions or comments on other players. I did a check on some of his previous games earlier, in PYP Boardwalk, decon was pretty quick to offer comments on several different players, unlike here.

On May 16 2013 09:07 marvellosity wrote:
Just popping in before bed. No, the reasons for voting you, that I agreed with certainly, are not terrible at all, they're pretty solid. Trying to dismiss them as terrible when they simply aren't smells bad.

On May 25 2013 06:47 marvellosity wrote:


Just browsed really fast the scumQT.

Crossfire, you made a big blunder providing mafia with a single fake-claim halfway through the game, a fake-claim of a role that didn't actually exist in the game.

The whole point of fakeclaiming as mafia is that it's a massive risk, and yet you randomly gave them a safe-claim of a role that wasn't in the game partway through the game. That's really bad.

On May 25 2013 06:52 marvellosity wrote:


that's not what happened.

crossfire voluntarily gave the scumteam a fakeclaim of a role not in the game.

the flavour is nothing to do with it at all.

scum are supposed to ask for what role they want to claim, and the hosts can then give scum the flavour. hosts shouldn't unilaterally give scum a safe-claim of a role not present in the game

On May 25 2013 06:55 phagga wrote:

Where you the guy who drowned in semen?

On May 25 2013 06:58 marvellosity wrote:
that was even more retarded, crossfire. don't make it right :p

in this game the roles were pretty standard with the exception of how they related to the board.

it's like in a normal game the mafia being told "this role doesn't exist, feel free to claim it". it's a massive advantage.

maybe it's just the way things are done in these games, but claiming blue in absolute safety for mafia doesn't seem right to me.

oh well. doesn't spoil the game or anything.