Again, I see nothing in that post that specifically prevents someone on the board right now from being an angel. All it says is that once someone is illuminated they will show up as human/puppet or angel. If we are expected to assume that everyone shown on the board was either human or puppet, then we would have been given a proper answer to this question:

On May 16 2013 02:07 Crossfire99 wrote:

Show nested quote +

*shrugs*

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 21 2013 00:46 GMT

#853

On May 21 2013 09:27 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
A weeping angel will be recognizable when a flashlight is shone on it.

Implies that when a flashlight is not shone on it, an angel will not be recognizable.

Also, with angels visible this game would be broken as fuck. If you thought Oats' player piece was an angel I don't see why you would sacrifice yourself, an alleged blue, just so Oats can get lynched the next day.

Note that greymist answered the question whereas crossfire was the one that didn't. Maybe cross was mad because people weren't reading the thread and asked a question that the hosts already answered.

'A number' of puppets. Not '1 puppet per player'. This means you could have the following scenario. X is a player. Y is an angel disguised as a player. Z is a puppet controlled by a hidden angel W.

X, Y and Z all appear to be normal players. W only shows up on the board when illuminated. Y shows up as an angel when illuminated.

X - Y -
- Z - -
- - - W

This has been the assumption I've been working off of since crossfire's post. However to clarify it:

Is it possible for one of the labelled players on the board to be an angel?

Also yes I damn well was willing to trade 1 for 1 with oats, as that would leave only one scum remaining, I had already claimed, so I didn't expect to live long anyway.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 21 2013 00:51 GMT

#854

On May 21 2013 09:28 mkfuba07 wrote:
Deconduo, what do you think of phagga's suggestion to check both him and oats at the same time?

Seems like a pretty good idea as I get to check more people at the same time? I mean its theoretically possible he's the scum and oats is town, but I highly doubt that's the case. I did a quick read of phagga's filter after the check and he's a lot more townlike than oats. Coupled with the scumslip by oats, I'm not worried about my vote.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 21 2013 20:22 GMT

#874

On May 21 2013 15:09 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

AFAIK, you play way more passively and 'quiet'
This feels like nomination, where you posted good shit that helped you to not get lynched? yeah. I think you didnt get lynched

This is hilarious. Phagga isn't scum because his scum meta is different. Except that he's never rolled scum. Clutching at straws much?

On May 21 2013 22:19 phagga wrote:
Any reason?

He needs to accuse one of us. Sent is voting for me, mkfuba is voting for you. He figures its easier to convince mkfuba to switch rather than sent.

@mkfuba Look over oats' and phagga's filters. Then tell me again you think phagga is scum between the two of them.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 21 2013 20:32 GMT

#875

On May 22 2013 05:08 phagga wrote:
Deconduo, what is your opinion on mkfubas post and vote on me?

Why would you volunteer to be checked as scum? If you were scum and oats town, why not kill me 2 nights ago? I'd be dead night 2 and oats would get lynched the next day.

I mean the only thing that was confusing me somewhat is why oats was willing to be checked. But the answer to that is he had no choice. If he refused to be checked he'd get lynched. If I died during the night he'd get lynched. So his plan (as we can see now) was to get checked, show up red and then call me scum and try and get me lynched first.

If I died before I checked him he gets instalynched the next day. So instead he takes out the big town players, BH and Zeph. In the meantime, he just throws suspicion on me so that when the check finally goes through he cries 'scum'.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 21 2013 21:08 GMT

#877

Well initially I didn't believe I was going to get lynched. I thought the votes on me were because I was afk for most of the day, and once I got back and started posting people would unvote. I really didn't think I was in anyway scummy so I didn't understand why people were voting me. After this post:

On May 17 2013 04:49 Blazinghand wrote:
i see that there are 3 votes on vivax, for on deconduo. I will not let a no-lynch happen. there are 10 minutes remaining. everyone get onto deconduo. now.

##unvote
##vote deconduo

I actually started writing out my claim post. I was also pretty pissed off that I would have to claim so soon. However just before I posted it I refreshed the page and saw this:

On May 17 2013 04:53 Blazinghand wrote:
sentinel with you me dec and ghost phagga oats we could have 6 on Vivax

one more to lynch

ANYONE WANT TO GO TO VIVAX?

And so I stayed my hand a bit, and it worked out. Day 2, I realised how quickly things could turn, so I was a bit more prepared to claim. I also figured out my role wasn't particularly useful without co-operation. I would have to guess where people would end their turn in order to use it. By claiming, I could get people to come to me to get checked, like with oats.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 22 2013 14:24 GMT

#922

Hey, I'm in the middle of moving house so today is a really bad day for me and I probably won't be around at the deadline. I had a quick read over the thread and it seems like people are throwing votes everywhere. This is lylo, we can't afford a mislynch. Keep your votes on oats.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 23 2013 14:03 GMT

#949

Finished moving, but no internet yet so I'm stuck on my phone and I can't view the board. I'm working on getting something rigged up though.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 24 2013 19:33 GMT

#962

It took me about 30 min just to post yesterday, and the technician won't be installing the connection until tomorrow. Gonna throw a token vote on sentinel, but I assume it won't matter. Sorry I've failed so badly, RL sucks sometimes

##Vote Sentinel

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

May 25 2013 13:29 GMT

#1055

Yeah, I got screwed over a bit by RL, though it was pretty much over at that stage anyway. Mkfuba switching his vote to oats with 2 minutes left pretty much ended the game for us. Had he not switched, I would have changed my vote to sentinel at the last minute, and gotten him lynched which would have won the game for us.

I think that the board was too big for us, and we started too far away from anyone to get any reasonable kills in. We were only able to feed once as a result of that. Once we had used up our normal KP we had very little chance of doing anything.

Overall a very fun game, and well played by town. Phagga and mkfuba for MVP.