On May 23 2013 08:36 kushm4sta wrote:
Listen if I die today NO BODY better deviate from the list.
I don't care how convincing some of these scummy fucks are. These are 100% the scumteam and you better vote them all and never be convinced otherwise. I will quit mafia forever if I'm wrong. And to the two people they decide not to nk, I swear to jesus if you don't lynch through this list I will hate you literally forever.

shirukami
snb
prplz

I will quit mafia forever if I'm wrong

lol how do you compete with that level of being sure

There are two tabs on that sheet btw, the second tab is the magic.

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 11:59 GMT

#2308

Artanis does not. Invalidates BH's argument.

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 12:02 GMT

#2310

That's why I wanted SNB today =[ it's okay you just gotta commit yourself to revaluation of the game every day and you will grow!

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 12:07 GMT

#2313

On May 25 2013 21:06 kushm4sta wrote:
also WTF we only got 1 mislynch then it was permenant lylo... wtf is that.. so imbalanced. all town modkills fucked us also.

also I honestly didn't read his filter for some reason. I saw VE's case on him and I was like well that sucked but w/e . But shirokami was playing like such an asshole. Normally someone who cares that little would get modkilled, but all he did was come in the thread whenever his name was mentioned to say "lol im not scum"

That's what sucked the most, TBH. The modkills were neither here nor there, as BM/Sinani are wildcards when they ARE in a game. Not sure about Chaoser though. That did suck a bit more than the other two.

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 12:17 GMT

#2314

Like look at my sheet, there are some subtle things that show that Shiro was just being bad town and not scummy.

WoS vote - blatantly sheeping BH. No other reasons given. Reasonable enough from a town perspective, right? Sheep your town read and/or the loudest voice in the thread. It makes less sense from a scum perspective because scum will try to justify their vote, at least.
-WoS - expressed suspicions of BH, but still voting for BH's previous target, found this to be weird and potentially scummy.
-VE - thread sentiment matching - getting a lynch to happen.
-HiroPro - "lack of opinions" mostly I just found this hypocritical of his own play, but it's valid enough on its own.
-BH - "goodnight sweet prince" this line threw me for a loop and it was Kush who also ended up saying it later. Not sure why but this sent me reeling when I realized it and I had to back up a bit to think on it. Still can't place the feeling it gave me because I took on the "dunked" from BH this game and it's possible Kush stole it in the same way? Or both really like princes or something. NTTAWTT.
-Prome - sheeping sloosh - at least he was honest about it. Again none of his own reasons.
-Sloosh - he had to, either way.

He barely justified any of his own votes. No guilt expressed, not even regrets either, really.

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 12:23 GMT

#2315

Like I can say this now because I've had time to analyze it this morning, I literally put the sheet together and wrote the SNB vote analysis right before bed. If I had the time, I might have been able to do something with it but ITS IN THE PAST NOW WOOT

Have some? Have some!

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 12:41 GMT

#2317

On May 25 2013 21:40 Vivax wrote:
Shoulda sticked to my early prplhz read, but fooled myself into thinking that BH was detective.

gg

<3

Thanks to/for Ace, Dandel, Kurumi I guess for letting me spam his inbox too, the players, the end-game analysis, the righteous indignation of butthurt dead townies, and most of all, to Google Docs.

/shoutoutz

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 15:58 GMT

#2321

Not sure if SK shots could be protected or not, I never really read anyone who died's PM very closely LOL hence my original confusion after the Sloosh claim.

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 25 2013 23:12 GMT

#2330

Vote for mafia and let the SK do the math for who he should kill!! That is like 10 extra people scum hunting instead of laying out theoretical scenarios and wasting days.

ObviousOne

United States3704 Posts

May 31 2013 00:08 GMT

#2350

On May 31 2013 07:00 Promethelax wrote:
So I finally got around to reading the scum qt.

VE is one smart cookie, he new I was setting a trap and wasn't reading him as town. He was just wrong about the target of my trap. I'd had VE as scum from d1 and wanted to confirm bh as scum to myself, when VE pushed him the way he did it became very clear that VE had no desire to see him die. If it had been up to me VE would have been the d2 lynch since he was the most obvious of the scum. I was deeply confused how Kush and OO had him as town in the endgame.
It was sad finally being the guy who caught all of the scums and not being town so no one went to look at my posts and kill the scum. I will however find eternal joy from this game since Marv and I disagreed on shiro's alignment when we were talking after my lynch and I was right.

Oats didn't help at all with his VE gleaming green thing before he flipped cop lol