EPTOn April 06 2013 11:04 austinmcc wrote:
I'll point it out postgame if you'd like. For now I'm not going to.
I'll point it out postgame if you'd like. For now I'm not going to.
rayn, you asked me this and I didn't respond. Also I sort of ended up 100% wrong.
BM got active at some point D1 just flinging around scum accusations based on associations and how people were acting towards each other in thread. X defended Y, Z noted that A was scum if something particular happened, blah blah blah - + Show Spoiler +
On April 06 2013 08:29 Bill Murray wrote:
Artanis is scum with Keirathi
GG
Artanis is scum with Keirathi
GG
On April 06 2013 08:36 Bill Murray wrote:
VE and Geript look bad over an associative tell
that actually changes my FoS
VE and Geript look bad over an associative tell
that actually changes my FoS
On April 06 2013 10:24 Bill Murray wrote:
FoS Restraining Order
VE is town and scum are trying to get a D1 lynch on him
FoS Restraining Order
VE is town and scum are trying to get a D1 lynch on him
On April 06 2013 10:36 Bill Murray wrote:
this looks like restraining order is chastising his mafia partner here
if RO is scum, so is OO
this looks like restraining order is chastising his mafia partner here
if RO is scum, so is OO
He also did it a couple other times, calling out snb as mafia if someone else were mafia, etc.
I read those posts as very townie because the thread wasn't super scumhunty when he was posting, it was before Gonzaw's case and a lot of the actual discussion and voting on D1. I really liked that someone was coming in and accusing a bunch of people in this weird associative manner, because I was thinking that if he ever actually hit on scum, or anything true, maybe there would be an odd reaction that we could pick out later. Like, if he actually finds an odd interaction between two scumbuddies partway through D1, maybe they overreact or something.
I think I overvalued what might fall out of his accusations, but I also made the same error that I did with my read on Artanis. BM was throwing around all these scumreads, making all these associations, but didn't actually do anything with any of them. Over time, as he didn't attempt to draw any conclusions from what he shook out of his posts, I should have been less and less townie on him, because it was that whole lack of conviction/pushing thing that mocsta was riding me on over artanis. But in general, I felt that I had seen BM post like this before when he was town, and I thought that the overall effect of those posts was townie - stir things up, maybe make scum nervous, maybe create associations to mine later on in the game.
