|
On April 12 2013 05:37 austinmcc wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 05:35 Keirathi wrote:On April 12 2013 05:32 strongandbig wrote:On April 12 2013 05:25 Sn0_Man wrote:I'd kinda like to hear Mocsta's full roleclaim not "I'm one of BC/Vig/Capitalist" (and I don't think he is BC because he claimed the KP before the roleclaim  ) However, with the amount of time left in teh day (6.5 hours I think) I'd be happy if sinani and OO just stepped up and claimed now. I'm not sure they are here though. actually you're kind of right - claiming "i'm one of these roles" is pretty scummy since it gives him outs if people claim some of those roles later. He also said he breadcrumbed it. I mean, maybe he breadcrumbed all 3, but it at least gives some credence to the fact that he was thinking about it before the mass-claim plan started. We'll see. It's possible that the crumbs are him noting he's gonna shoot someone. If he just crumbed the shot/KP, then it's still a scummy announcement, especially as one reason he seems to not want to claim is that BC could be lurking, when he wants to pretend he might be BC despite the fact that he almost certainly could not have known deconduo's role at that point in the game.
Yes, but I found a post that I think is his crumb.
I hope he comes to clear it up soon, though.
|
On April 12 2013 07:25 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 07:12 austinmcc wrote:On April 12 2013 07:08 geript wrote:
Claim already Sno. I do not understand your play today at all if you are town 1. Because I'm sure he's scum 2. Because no one else believes me 3. Because you've been treating him like confirmed town when he's anything but completely differently from me who you also consider to be confirmed town despite the fact that his only actual townie points are a green check 4. He's scum bro 5. He'd actually see I'm town if he were
The green check isn't the only thing that makes him town.
I argued that he was town hours and hours before the green check was public. Why didn't you fight me about it then?
|
On April 12 2013 07:39 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 07:30 Keirathi wrote:On April 12 2013 07:25 geript wrote:On April 12 2013 07:12 austinmcc wrote:On April 12 2013 07:08 geript wrote:
Claim already Sno. I do not understand your play today at all if you are town 1. Because I'm sure he's scum 2. Because no one else believes me 3. Because you've been treating him like confirmed town when he's anything but completely differently from me who you also consider to be confirmed town despite the fact that his only actual townie points are a green check 4. He's scum bro 5. He'd actually see I'm town if he were The green check isn't the only thing that makes him town. I argued that he was town hours and hours before the green check was public. Why didn't you fight me about it then? Why do I need to argue your points? Most vets I've seen have completely misread newbs actions. It's ok Kei, you can win with me once people actually sheep me.
No one is going to sheep you.
1) You're (almost certainly) wrong. I would bet my left nut on it.
2) Your attitude is detrimental to town.
|
On April 12 2013 08:14 Sn0_Man wrote:
Interesting thought.
I was thinking of suggesting an item to clear up some of the flips (or at least one), as well. Just depends on what BC will allow.
(PS: your hint to me was good )
|
I would have called it an Autopsy Table or something similar, but the idea is the same!
|
On April 12 2013 08:50 Sharrant wrote:
Hey, guys, so I finally got to read the last few pages. I think StrongAndBig is the last member of the mafia.
Apparently he is the detective, which is what the mafia would have wanted as their fifth slot, in my opinion.
If Caller was mafia showtime, VE the mafia NRA, Deconduo the mafia janitor, and Artanis was the Mafia Assassin then where was their ability to determine a players role? Their last slot would either have to either be a role thief (who stole Decon's role just before he died and used it in his stead, perhaps having a mafia bonus to be able to use it twice) or a role that detects other players roles. I don't believe CPR doctor was chosen by mafia, so this seems to be the likely solution to me.
I completely believe his claim of being Detective, but I am sure he is the mafia detective.
Why would mafia take Detective instead of the safer Role Cop (or even better, Capitalist) picks?
|
Also: Today is a double lynch. Who else do you want to lynch? Why?
How do you feel about Vivax?
|
On April 12 2013 08:54 Sharrant wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 08:52 Keirathi wrote:On April 12 2013 08:50 Sharrant wrote:
Hey, guys, so I finally got to read the last few pages. I think StrongAndBig is the last member of the mafia.
Apparently he is the detective, which is what the mafia would have wanted as their fifth slot, in my opinion.
If Caller was mafia showtime, VE the mafia NRA, Deconduo the mafia janitor, and Artanis was the Mafia Assassin then where was their ability to determine a players role? Their last slot would either have to either be a role thief (who stole Decon's role just before he died and used it in his stead, perhaps having a mafia bonus to be able to use it twice) or a role that detects other players roles. I don't believe CPR doctor was chosen by mafia, so this seems to be the likely solution to me.
I completely believe his claim of being Detective, but I am sure he is the mafia detective. Why would mafia take Detective instead of the safer Role Cop (or even better, Capitalist) picks? He was in 7th draft pick, and there was another mafia member above him so essentially he was in 6th slot. He was quite high up the list, I think it was a safe bet AND it denies town both a role check and an alignment check.
Still doesn't answer why not Capitalist. Capitalist is like, an awesome middle ground. One extra vig KP, and some role checks. Is denying town the DT worth it?
|
Sharrant: What about Meapak?
|
You're not in second Vivax. OO+Sharrant are the lynches right now.
|
Also one more question for Sharrant: On day 1, you wrote up a big case about why OO was scum. What made you change your mind today, and why aren't you voting for him anymore?
|
On April 12 2013 09:24 Sharrant wrote:I don't mind him too much right now. I think that his shot on Austin was very bad play, but I liked his reaction to it when he saw your claim about Austin. Sure, he could've faked it, I wouldn't put it past him. But I'd rather keep as many people alive as possible. I don't know how to take him not coming back to the thread for so long though. That could've been an embarassed townie being glad he didn't have to stick around after his mistake or a mafia looking to clam up and not reveal anything before he was "officially" dead.
So this isn't your position anymore?
On April 04 2013 12:23 Sharrant wrote:
1. America should not be picked by any town member. I don't think it very strongly benefits town. The only way I think it benefits town is if it is used by a town player to essentially act as a second lynch. I believe that America must announce its nuke in the thread (someone please correct me if I'm wrong). This is my proposal. Either A) we all agree to avoid the role. No town member takes it, thus if it is ever used we will know that a mafia member took it. or B) If someone does pick it they announce themselves right away and we use it as a second lynch. Announcing it after day 1, or using the power to kill someone that the town does not agree on should be seen as that person claiming scum.
I personally prefer option A, but I can't control anyone.
|
On April 12 2013 09:23 Vivax wrote:
Well I don't want him to get lynched before OO that's for sure. If someone plans to switches to me and Sharrant he might hinder OO's lynch.
There are 9 votes on OO, 8 on Sharrant (including yours), and 7 on you. I doubt 2 people are going to unvote OO to put both you and Sharrant over him.
|
On April 12 2013 09:39 Sharrant wrote:
@Vivax
You can always put a vote on Austin, he's set to die today, so it's like voting for a single lynch.
I encourage everyone to think about what I've said about StrongAndBig. If you lynch me today, that's fine, but please shoot or lynch StrongAndBig afterwards.
What Vivax is saying is that if we start moving votes off of you, then he's next in line to get lynched and will lose his ability to parity check someone tonight.
|
Maybe austin should just shoot S&B too. We kill all 3 of you and settle it (hopefully) for good.
|
On April 12 2013 10:50 Sharrant wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 10:48 Sn0_Man wrote:On April 12 2013 10:31 Mocsta wrote:
And then there is this stupid bickering with Sn0, who is prob CPR Medic based on claims thus far. Things that I am NOT: CPR Medic Just claim already. I actually can't even understand why you're not claiming at this point.
He has claimed. Well, he didn't directly say the words, but he's the inventor.
|
On April 12 2013 10:57 Mocsta wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 10:54 Sn0_Man wrote:On April 12 2013 10:50 Sharrant wrote:On April 12 2013 10:48 Sn0_Man wrote:On April 12 2013 10:31 Mocsta wrote:
And then there is this stupid bickering with Sn0, who is prob CPR Medic based on claims thus far. Things that I am NOT: CPR Medic Just claim already. I actually can't even understand why you're not claiming at this point. I think there is a bloodycobbler. My role is strong and I'm confirmed town. I'm in no rush to allow that particular KP to hit me, though I admit that it is quite likely I die tonight. I could get dayvigged by BloodyCobbler role if I claim now and therefore not be able to... use my role. My soft claim: I happen to know some things about the invention last night that the thread at large doesn't know. Pls tell me Keirathi hasnt been lying?
lol what?
He said earlier that he targetted me last night. Whether I am town or scum, I'm not going to lie about the invention. That would just be beyond dumb.
|
Also @mocta: what about Vivax? Why did you leave him out?
|
On April 12 2013 11:16 Mocsta wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2013 11:14 austinmcc wrote:On April 12 2013 11:11 Mocsta wrote:
What was the point of claiming
if the intention wasnt to lynch. It pulls some people off the table. It possibly catches scum. It forces scum to commit to a story now, rather than later, if they want to fakeclaim. Maybe geript had terminally low blood pressure, and dangling sn0 claiming in front of him all day helped to raise his blood pressure and save his life. EVEN IF THE POINT WAS TO LYNCH PEOPLE WHY WOULD WE JUST GO "LET'S LYNCH PEOPLE WHO CLAIMED DETECTIVE ROLES"? That doesn't make sense to me why, if we were lynching on only claims, we'd lynch ... a specific role that was claimed? Because we came to the conclusion there was too many dt roles we asked for hard dt claims & didnt get them I forgot to add Vivax as a dt claimer.
What do you mean "we came to the conclusion that there are too many of them"?
We never came to any such conclusion. I'm actually happy that we have so many (claimed) investigation roles.
|
Bleh. I don't really think Sharrant is scum anymore. If he's acting out this whole townie paranoia thing, then he's doing a really good job of it.
But why did he wait until 2 hours before his head was on the line to get active?
Fuck me this game is a mindfuck.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
