|
On March 08 2013 18:08 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Also thrawn, your reasons for calling Mr. CC and Dandel Ion town are extremely weak and it makes me suspicious of you. Saying "it's not these guys" implies a degree of certainty for which those things are too easy to fake, especially Dandel's comment. That was just a comment to support fairness in the game which I considered making myself but decided not to. Your post makes me suspicious.
well those aren't the entirety of my reasoning for thinking their town
but whatever, i'm more interested in who you want to lynch
|
ok make your case first
[/b]##unvote[/b]
|
|
|
|
|
what I dont understand, is if you're town you'd already have a main target in mind by now. it's been like 16 ish hours since the flip which is plenty of time to brood over the events of d2; you should at least have a main suspect at this point
|
there's not much to say, this game hasn't required much analysis
step 1: lurk like scum thrawn and get everyone to call me scum
step 2: lynch the scummiest person who says I'm scum (jay)
step 3: wake up hungover and still a little high only to discover that somehow vivax got lynched... wtf was that, jeez
step 4: lynch the person who had a townread on the guy he hammered
|
On March 08 2013 02:31 Hapahauli wrote:
##Vote Artanis
this vote had no chance of affecting the lynch and hapa must have known it at the time. i think it was him telling us who to lynch after he inevitably gets nk'd
|
On March 09 2013 02:14 Promethelax wrote:
I'm pretty sure you are green Artanis. Your meta suggests it strongly. As hapa said in haunted and in LI you were lurker extraordinaire where as here you care and are trying to find scum, you are active, interested and for now I'm sticking with my green read on you.
I have some rules for today.
1) No one gets to hammer until I say so, we're not having a day without discussion again. I thought I was going to have to fight tooth and nail for the Vivax lynch yesterday but instead he got hammered while I was writing the second part of my case.
2)The lynch is between Dan and CC. Thrawn, you and I are having a long talk post game about your reads.
3) Dan and CC, you both need to make a case on the other one.
4) I will provide my case on the one I feel is scummier in 15-16 hours when I get back from work.
all hail the mighty prom who bet his love life that vivax was scum
prom how's this? we lynch artanis today, then dandel next if artanis is green? i might be persuaded to do it the other way around but it's not likely
|
prom is there anything about artanis' play other than meta that makes you think he's town? lets look at his actions thus far:
D1: doesn't talk about jay except for his last post in D1, which basically said "jay looks bad but lets give him time to imrpove"
D2: had a town read on vivax, hammered vivax
|
##Vote: Artanis
if this is a mislynch, whoever is left DO NOT lynch prom or CC. DON'T DO IT!
|
Artanis, who do you actually want to lynch? You seem to be coasting along and agreeing with other people's arguments while not putting much forth yourself? Who is your top scumread?
|
Alright, here's where I'm at right now:
Prom
My strongest town read. My late town read on him in D1 hasn't really changed over the course of the game. I still think his early game is scummy, but if I compare the reasons why I thought he was scum in this game, with the reasons I've mistakenly thought he was scum in the past, they are pretty much the same. Not scum, just angry town.
Mr CC/Dandel
I'm grouping these two together because I've thought of their play being almost identical all game. The only difference is that CC has provided reasoning for his reads and he's been more useful than Dandel overall. Dandel's fuckassery suggests that he;s town, but he's provided almost nothing other that you can use to read him. If we lynch Artanis and he flips green, having both Dandel and CC in the endgame will be troublesome. That's maybe the only part of me that doesn't want to lynch Artanis.... to avoid having unreadable people in endgame. So I'm a little nullish on both of them.... leaning slightly scummy for Dandel and mildly townie for CC. The CC read is stronger than the Dandel read
Artanis
I've already said enough about him. He's already stated that his hammer makes no sense from a scum perspective but I say that it makes as little sense from a town perspective. He doesn't seem to be actually doing much this cycle despite being fairly active... he's engaging in conversation with people but he seems like he's just biding his time, waiting for everyone to agree on a mislynch.
|
|
|
On March 09 2013 06:39 Dandel Ion wrote:
For grand emphasis
##Vote: Artanis
this vote's convinced me to lynch dandel, here are the reasons
1: much rather have to pick from artanis/prom/CC than dandel/CC/prom if this is a mislynch
2: dandel's played this phase less trolly than the others so far, but still has provided the same amount of useful posts (read: none) which suggests he's trying to appear useful without actually being useful
3: he seems way to eager to jump on the artanis bandwagon after I revoted artanis
4: so that dandel will never play like this again regardless of his alignment
##Vote: Dandel Ion
|
On March 09 2013 06:37 Dandel Ion wrote:
You can lynch me tomorrow if I'm wrong, whatever.
But today we should lynch Artanis.
Hue.
also this is complete bullshit. if we mislynch today, WE CAN'T MISLYNCH TOMORROW..... so why would a town dandel offer himself up to be lynched?
|
On March 09 2013 06:53 Dandel Ion wrote:Show nested quote +On March 09 2013 06:52 thrawn2112 wrote:On March 09 2013 06:37 Dandel Ion wrote:
You can lynch me tomorrow if I'm wrong, whatever.
But today we should lynch Artanis.
Hue. also this is complete bullshit. if we mislynch today, WE CAN'T MISLYNCH TOMORROW..... so why would a town dandel offer himself up to be lynched? Cuz I'm so convinced of course. Artanis just trying to get out on his BS wifom. You can still lynch him tomorrow too, I'm just worried you'll stop thinking and lynch CC instead.
wat?
you said "lynch artanis today, and me tomorrow if artanis is green"
when tomorrow is mylo, that's a scum claim if I ever saw one
|
On March 09 2013 06:55 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Glad to see it Thrawn. I'm happy with a Dandel lynch but I want to wait for Prome to post before hammering him in case we're wrong.
eh I'm sober now for the first time this game so my level of "care" rose about 90%
I do NOT want dandel in mylo.... plus I think he just scumclaimed
|
ok dandel. why should we lynch artanis? what are your other reads? if artanis is town, who is scum and WHY?
|
On March 09 2013 07:08 Dandel Ion wrote:
Artanis is not town, so no need to worry.
You should lynch Artanis because he's scum.
if that's all you're willing to give me then... fuck off i guess lol. to put it nicely.
|
fuuuuckkk i want dandel to be hammered right now.... but first I want prom to come in and say who he thinks is scum if dandel is green.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
