Personality Mafia 2 - Page 6

On March 15 2013 12:07 Dandel Ion wrote:
Oh, so there's another votestealer...

On March 15 2013 12:09 Dandel Ion wrote:

No the prplhz(?) vote was locked on d1, and cora couldn't have done it.

On March 15 2013 12:13 marvellosity wrote:


no, tomorrow Foolish leads the lynch again. I can't believe it's more than a one-time thing.

That is if he hasn't been "dealt with" overnight.

On March 15 2013 23:51 marvellosity wrote:


I am your Oats man. It's kinda like I said in my Night 1 reads post. My opinion's the same.

Primary things to think about:

- Oats will ask pointless questions and contradict himself as town quite regularly
- Oats will jump all over the place as town
- Oats is suspicious of a lot of people as town

- Oats is scared as mafia
- Oats isn't suspicious of many people as mafia

On March 16 2013 04:46 austinmcc wrote:
In case that quotes bit was unclear, here's what I'm getting at.

iamp N1 has both Foolishness and Ver in his scum list
marv D2 comes back with a parity check on those two as different
iamp strongly believes marv to be town

iamp continues to push both Foolishness AND Ver. He does not explain why he does not trust the check.

That's fine, in and of itself. There were a lot of comments in the thread about how the check was telegraphed, and so there could be a frame or a rb. But we know marv wasn't roleblocked (PARANOIA PARANOIA: IF HE'S TOWN (WHICH HE PROBABLY IS)). And if the checks came back different, that means a frame doesn't explain both being scum.

If both were TOWN, you could frame one, have the parity check come back different, and lynch them BOTH. Get rid of 1 of 2 big scary players that you would not want to face as scum.

But if both were SCUM, you can't frame them to make the parity check come back different. You'd need a cover ability, or a framer that specifically can do both, which MIGHT be the case. Or a gf, which MIGHT be the case.

iamp just jumps into wanting to lynch BOTH players though. Despite the parity check, despite a roleblock not occurring, despite a regular frame + the check indicating that both are actually TOWN. So he's relying on one of them being a gf or one of them being covered, but nobody is really discussing those powers and he doesn't see fit to mention. He just carries his night scum reads over to day, without taking into account a parity check that a big town read got back.

Scum. Dude scum.

On March 14 2013 23:13 iamperfection wrote:

for someone who shot their own scum buddy you put a lot of stock in associations.

marvs dt check is useless because he had to announce it why rb when he cant put any stock in it since its a closed setup.

On March 16 2013 05:08 Promethelax wrote:
imp please don't respond
to austin's check-based red thong
who is your scum
mr. evil number one
the rest of austin's points are so blonde.