Personality Mafia 2 - Page 2

On March 10 2013 23:55 Vivax wrote:


Well yeah i think personality claiming doesn't matter at all it's just for fun except for the powers and we should probably just play like we're supposed to and focus on getting everyone to post. I think that putting the thought out there that people can't just lurk is a good start for that and anyway, waiting for people to post is pretty much normal during day 1 :p

On March 11 2013 01:01 Acrofales wrote:

This is 100% a Chezinu claim. Points 2 and 3 are mutually exclusive

On March 11 2013 01:08 marvellosity wrote:
I'm pretty much with risk on this one. I have no idea what Acro thinks he's doing with this Ver stuff. Ver pretty explicitly said he wouldn't have much time for the game until Monday as well. And yet Acro actually has his vote on him; he wants to kill potentially one of town's strongest assets. I can't really tell if this makes Acro mafia or just very silly.

On March 11 2013 01:21 prplhz wrote:
I have a one shot ability to become immune to the lynch next day at the expense of my own vote. Any votes on me, and by me, will simply not count.

On March 11 2013 01:28 Acrofales wrote:

In a game where your role is another mafia player, acting like one in particular is a claim in my book.

On March 11 2013 01:28 yamato77 wrote:
So Marv, out of Kurumi/Bugs, which one do you feel is more likely to be mafia, if either?

On March 11 2013 01:29 marvellosity wrote:
bugs is more likely, but that's not saying much at this stage.

On March 11 2013 01:32 yamato77 wrote:
My question wasn't stupid.

I feel like one of them is probably mafia, given the nature of their posting. One is almost assuredly hiding with the other in the "Chezinu" category of unreadable players.

It's a valid mafia strategy if we, as town, allow it.

On March 11 2013 01:36 yamato77 wrote:

I never said both can't be mafia.

But right now, we can only pick one to lynch, and I want it to be the one we're more confident with.

On March 11 2013 01:50 prplhz wrote:

sigh

There's a reason none of the good players really reacted at all, use your brain and you might realize it too.

On March 11 2013 02:40 risk.nuke wrote:

What? Do you need glasses.
his low post-count wasn't the argument. And that he never brought it up again would only make it scummier however he might have just not gotten around to comment further on it.

On March 11 2013 10:52 austinmcc wrote:


Hello everyone! I think you should vote austinmcc for Mayor. Or any other elected office. But mainly mayor.

As mayor, I'll aim to keep a healthy thread environment. We have a lot of heavily-themed roles it seems, and a couple posting restrictions or flavor-lovers. Limericks and rats are nice, but there are a lot of other things that get lost when there is too much creativity and not enough scumhunting. So please be judicious with your silly posts.

But the real benefit to electing me mayor is that I will lynch scum. For now, that means lynching slOosh or crossfire. I like those better than oats, although I agree that oats doesn't look very green here. But iirc I'm not particularly good at putting oats's actions together with his alignment.

slOosh is a good townie, and generally active. scumslOosh is inactive. slOosh this game is...

But the stronger lynch today is crossfire. I like the idea that some scum will attempt to hide within personalities, allowing them to play the game from a less-than-town angle and pass it off as part of the game. crossfire has done just that. He has talked his nonsense, and I enjoyed reading his posts. But the posts contain little/nothing. bugs's post had some logic in them. Others are roleplaying within the context of scumhunting. crossfire is just posting nonsense. At best he called hiro out for voting for "non-alignment reasons," but he hasn't called out any other bad votes and he didn't go anywhere with hiro. Call out his vote, blink away.

On March 11 2013 11:12 austinmcc wrote:
snb, three things

what are those BHs in the Foolishness pic holding?

wbg's posts may ramble, but they rambled while making townie points (at times). Read his post about how rats work. It's not the most insightful thing ever, but it gave me a strong townie vibe on him, because he was still playing mafia while filling the thread with nonsense (unlike crossfire).

oats does look bad. I like the point on reads more than the point on not following his own advice, especially within a game where everyone is playing as someone else. For starts, you look at the iamperfection/mocsta pushes from oats, but you miss this:Oats still pushing iamp, before you post, in response to iamp finding hiro scummy based on hiro's wanting claims. Specifically, iamp made a case, and oats immediately jumps all over iamp. I dislike that, because he's not actually seeking discussion on those questions, he starts off with the all caps LYNCH IAMP, which makes it feel like the questions don't matter. He just wants to lynch iamp, for...making a case and scumhunting.

There's also his posts on ver. Check these out:Ver's entrance is "unimpressive" and he has no posts after. Reads like Oats finds this scummy
But now acro finds Ver scummy for the same post, and Oats thinks it's a horrible reason for a vote.
Acro responds, and Oats downplays Ver's post. Ver has a whopping one post. And yet Oats still manages to have 3 different thoughts about it. Weird interaction, and weirdly inconsistent.

Ver's entrance is "unimpressive" and he has no posts after.

But now acro finds Ver scummy for the same post, and Oats thinks it's a horrible reason for a vote.

Or he was kidding, and roleplaying.

Its one fucking post. Is he really the scummiest person so far?

On March 11 2013 12:11 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
This just in, Oats softclaimed scum.

On March 10 2013 16:55 HiroPro wrote:
btw I think everyone should just say who they are. since there apparently aren't any risks to doing so and I don't fancy having to determine whether or not people are acting fake because of their personality or because they're mafia.

On March 11 2013 03:01 HiroPro wrote:
yo, unless one of them admits they were lying right now, we should be lynching between kurumi and bugs today. both of them have claimed chezinu - bugs's anagram is a an anagram for brown brotherhood.

at the moment, i'm leaning towards kurumi. in particular notice what kurumi says after he has gotten his role (but before his alignment), "this sucks". kurumi is a player who likes to play around and troll frequently. it's very unlikely that he would be unhappy about receiving chezinu as a role. the logical conclusion is that kurumi is a faker.

##Vote Kurumi

also to the people who don't understand why i would ask everyone to just flat out say who they are. this is in part because my personality dislikes shennanies like what's going on right now. it's not something that i care about personally much.

On March 11 2013 08:52 HiroPro wrote:
##Unvote
##Vote Stutters695

Forget about kurumi. if he's confirmed town then there is no point in talking about him.

lynch the commentator. his filter is short so i will not bother even quoting. all he can do is ask meaningless questions and complain about how people treat him. he has no opinions on anything of value.

On March 11 2013 11:18 HiroPro wrote:


man what does this even mean. you thought kurumi was suspicious also right? so why does kurumi flipping a bastard town role make you more suspicious of bugs?

On March 11 2013 12:41 Promethelax wrote:
bugs call K-room a scum
but when he is killed and confirmed a-1
bugs disappears
he says nothing here
his mislynch has been undone

when I show my cat a playerlist
it is at bugs which she begins to hiss
her reads are astute
my kitty is cute
she says that bugs is a bish

WBG has hidden in his role
he pretends to search for the mole
but when his chosen townie is shot
his contributions are less than not
now WBG's sharp wit has gone null

On March 11 2013 13:04 slOosh wrote:
u kids so bad

a) yamato uses mod-confirm check day one on kurumi
b) yamato then day vigs mod-confirmed town kurumi
c) people complain and call yamato bad but don't vote him
d) yamato is getting away with shooting mod-confirmed town
e) yamato is getting away with shooting mod-confirmed town
f) yamato is getting away with shooting mod-confirmed town

srsly if anybody doen't realize this and considers themselves good, well, maybe you need to bend over to see just how low you really are.

##Vote: yamato