Newbie Mini Mafia XXXVIII - Page 6

On March 12 2013 11:00 geript wrote:
Hmmmmm. For the night is dark and full of evil.

On March 12 2013 21:14 MLuneth wrote:
I don't even

On March 12 2013 23:05 WaveofShadow wrote:
But did you really ruin it?
Thinking about it , is it worth checking your filter again Geript knowing what I know now? I'm thinking so.

On March 13 2013 11:23 Frorgon wrote:
So I wanted to discuss others who might be scum for future reference, even though right now I think MLuneth is definite scum that needs to be disposed of.

Omni

Not a good voting record here. Looking back at his entire filter, he's only voted on 3 people ever: myself, Arctic, and Meatless. 2 are confirmed to be wrong (maybe not in everyone's eyes but certainly in mine). He did change to Meatless before joining the AD bandwagon, but keep in mind that at this point Nobodywonder had a lot of votes, and if he was scum maybe he was hoping NW would get lynched without looking responsible. Then he cleverly set up another town for lynch day 2.

Now consider his thought process. Omni himself admits that his vote on me was done without much to go on besides lurking. That's fine; this can be a pressure vote and get the person to come out and contribute more. The thing is, he hasn't been consistent doing this. A lot of people in this game have cast several pressure votes early on and changed them. Not Omni. He decided to attack me before figuring that Meatless might be an easier and more convincing target. He then proceeded to tunnel Meatless for 2 days. No real talk about AD other than "yeah I agree he's looking scummy", and not much on Luneth at all.

Now the bickering with geript has been interesting. A distraction, perhaps? People started getting uneasy at the seemingly meaningless argument between them, which distracts from the real task at hand. And in the end Omni got his wish and got Taco lynched. This could still be nothing though because if its' Luneth and Omni as the 2 other scum, that's game right there. I'm just looking for connections and people working together. All I know is I want more actual contribution from geript and less stupid jokes. Easy for you to claim you've been onto Omni all along when a mislynch was happening anyway.

Rainbows

Looked quickly through his filter and he still comes up pro-town for me. For some reason when I was thinking about this earlier away from my computer I wondered if there was a connection between him and Omni, but there doesn't appear to be. Rainbows did vote for NW and myself on day 1 before lurking, but then he spent day 2 pushing for a MLuneth lynch relentlessly and given that Wave was killed for doing the same thing I tend to think that is pro-town behavior.

In Conclusion

I want MLuneth lynched today because he is scum and we will learn a lot from it. But I'm really starting to question Omni's bad reads. He posts a lot and people tend to listen because it looks like he put a lot of time into his cases. But just because a case is long doesn't mean it isn't filled with misinformation and inaccuracies. In fact, the chance of this increases. Also, I'm concerned about those who replaced the lurkers. You guys really have to prove yourselves because the lurkers were looking pretty bad before you came in. It makes it really hard to proceed with the constant change so if you guys aren't helpful I'm going to assume that you have something to hide. I look forward to hearing from everyone.

On March 13 2013 12:33 geript wrote:
Raven, where do you think Rainbows and OE are? I don't see a real reason for two people who have been active at points to go into lurk mode this hard.

On March 13 2013 12:44 geript wrote:
So are you buying my previous case on OE?

On March 13 2013 15:25 bduddy wrote:
Really? So the mafia blocked you without even knowing if you still had a shot or not? I'm not buying it. Who did you target and why? Did you breadcrumb, and why did you not night-post like last night?

Considering that we supposedly are supposed to know all the possible roles, is it really necessary that you hide important mechanics about how they work?

On March 13 2013 21:15 Krafla wrote:


Interesting thoughts on Omni here TRN.

Assuming it was a JK that saved you and WoS and a mafia RB that blocked me presumably now I am going to be perpetually RB'd or just outright shot at night?

On March 14 2013 01:57 Frorgon wrote:
I don't see how Rainbows looks suspicious right now Raven. There is no connection between him and Omni. Now if Luneth somehow flips town, as I've said Omni starts to look innocent and then Rainbows would have the same problem as Omni has right now, tunneling votes on innocent people. If Luneth is town then Geript and Rainbows are scum. Otherwise the two scum are Luneth and Omni. You seem to agree about Omni, but I don't think we learn as much if we vote him today, and a mislynch on Omni hurts us a lot more than a mislynch on Luneth.