This is exactly what I was talking about earlier. If I post my thoughts, people tell me its useless and I shouldn't post it, if I don't people tell me I'm playing "scared" and I should be pressing my null reads.

90% of that post was about his recent posting. Does that not demonstrate to you the weight I'm placing on the scum slip?

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 03 2013 19:14 GMT

#3118

Also, the way you paraphased that conversation entirely removes part of the meaning in your post. You clearly asked me a question about the use of my time. I already told you I'm in a bad mood, are you just trying to start a fight with me? I don't get it.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 03 2013 20:02 GMT

#3123

On March 04 2013 04:30 layabout wrote:
Because in the past 3 days you have called Toad scum* try to shed doubt on jj and forget about grush after calling him scum and give up on aqua/oo without saying why and instead of giving your read on me when questioned you have just hinted that you think i might be scum.

Also because i am getting annoyed at the thread in general. It's as if half of the thread is trying to confuse themselves and the other half isn't here.

+ Show Spoiler [*] +

Shame on everyone that did this but this is more of a postgame topic

You're clearly referencing something specific I said, but I don't know what and its causing me to have trouble interpreting your post. Can you be more clear on what is "because" of these things?

On March 04 2013 04:58 The Macho Man wrote:
i have a question for everyone why did chezinu not just shoot hasy. He would have been under a lot less suspicion and it would have been seen as much more justified.

now before you go wifom wifom wifom it really isnt it would ahve been much more advantageous to kill a "town" hasy from chez's pov. When you add the whole "cheating thing with toad i think it a strong likelihood that hasy is mafia.

Hassy is going to get modkilled. It would have been a waste of his bullet.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 03 2013 20:06 GMT

#3125

What I'm saying is your premise is false. Where you go after "Why didn't he shoot Hassy?" is irrelevant, because you're assuming the Hassy was an obvious target.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 03 2013 20:13 GMT

#3127

Well, now that I think about it, maybe I'm off about the timing of this. Its may be possible to make an arguement that Hassy was a good target.

So how about this instead. Even if we're 100% sure Hassy is mafia, what are we going to do about it? He's gonna get modkilled anyway, so we just get to kill him for free. What discussion is there to have?

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 03 2013 20:14 GMT

#3128

On March 04 2013 05:12 JungleJorge wrote:
Don't lynch geript tomorrow, lynch RO.

Ok, why?

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 03 2013 20:37 GMT

#3132

JJ, it is possible that they in fact both are mafia. Is there a reason you think we get more out lynching RO compared to the more unanimously scummy geript?

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 04 2013 00:52 GMT

#3219

I was about ready to jump all over layabout, if JJ had jailed him he'd be looking pretty bad right now.

Seriously though, how do so many people not read the rules/thread? Maybe this is why it seems like everyone else has unreal amounts of time to spend on this game. I just spend too much time actually reading the thread.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 04 2013 01:23 GMT

#3234

On March 04 2013 10:15 layabout wrote:
No sane scum would roleblock aquanim.

agree/disagree?

Even if this is true, what do we gain by concluding it?

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 04 2013 01:23 GMT

#3235

I guess, you think it means aqua is scum and lying?

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 04 2013 01:34 GMT

#3239

On March 04 2013 10:24 MilkSuckler wrote:

Show nested quote +

So Vivax CLEARLY says a good 15min before deadline, he will shoot Restraining Order (now confirmed scum)

and they decide to RB you > Vivax.... something not adding up here

Looks to me like he says it 1 minute before, but I'm not sure that matters. They know vivax is vigilante, so it makes sense to RB him even if they don't know he's gonna shoot one of them.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 04 2013 03:18 GMT

#3263

I think the idea is that if he were SK he wouldn't be telling us it was him.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 04 2013 03:55 GMT

#3275

I feel like geript isn't giving us much choice here. I'm gonna go ahead and place my vote in his direction.

##Vote:geript

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 04 2013 21:38 GMT

#3418

I'd support shortening the day too. I feel like its going to be hard for us to get much of anything done discussion-wise for the rest of D3.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 05 2013 16:21 GMT

#3517

On March 06 2013 00:35 layabout wrote:

Show nested quote +

then where is the nk?

it wouldn't be smart to assume that scum roleblocked but didn't nk, an sk is unlikely our medic is dead and our jailer messed up his action.

WIFOM or not aqua needs to die.

JOAT could have saved someone. Or they could have targeted someone other than JJ or Vivax and hit the veteran? The latter seems pretty unlikely though.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 05 2013 16:28 GMT

#3519

On March 06 2013 01:26 layabout wrote:
joat seems unfair on scum and a vet should have claimed a shot if they were hit.

if there is a joat and they sent a save in then they should claim it tomorrow, otherwise we lynch aqua, i would have suggested they claim today but since geript is doomed claiming now would be counter-productive

Ok, that seems like a good assessment.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 05 2013 17:38 GMT

#3534

But his kill can't be prevented, so he'd die. Killing himself would in fact be against his wincon.

TestSubject893

United States774 Posts

March 06 2013 01:35 GMT

#3580

Jeez, I don't understand what was going through geript's head to act the way he did. I guess its not worth while to dwell on it right now though.

I feel like things got a lot more wide open with neither Hassy or geript flipping scum. (We've had relatively easy decisions on the lynches up until now.)

I think looking more closely at randombum could be a good move from here. I'll reexamine him.