No, what adam did was basically saying,
'I voted for that dude cause I wanted a mislynch'
He pretty much 'claimed' 3P right there. Except nobody does that.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 27 2013 17:33 GMT

#1088

So is Adam 3P or not?
Im confused, you say he isnt stupid, which means he wouldnt have openly claimed 3P if he was actually 3P right?
And he isnt scum, so THEREFORE HE IS TOWN. Now go lynch Keirathi.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 01:55 GMT

#1198

And all the scumbuddies bussed the hell out of keirathi.

Alderan, why were you so concerned that a double lynch was happening? There was still like 8-10 hours to go or more.
Plenty of time to see a switch.

Also, you pushed it so hard then when keirathi flipped town you were suprised? Like what? Then why did you push keirathi over adam SO HARD when you thought that they were both town?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 02:17 GMT

#1203

I already switched off it and it was gaining no traction.

The thing is, double lynch is basically no lynch, and you have to wait until the end of the cycle to see it happen. So therefore it looks really weird that you were pushing it so early.
Not aware of the time being left is not much of an excuse. Its not that hard to check.

Alderan, the problem I have with the way you pushed Keirathi, was that you wanted to see Keirathi die above all else, and if both of them are town, and you dont want a no lynch, shouldnt you just prefer keirathi to die, but if adam gets lynched too thats ok?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 02:23 GMT

#1205

I meant that either one of you dying would be ok cause then both of you dont die.
Sorry if that was misunderstood.

Adam, why did he push SO HARD. and so early?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 02:44 GMT

#1209

Ok.
My problem is that you pushed Keir like a scum read, instead of a town read that was useless

On the other hand he has offered absolutely nothing in the way of analysis, which is exactly why I said I would rather Adam live. It's not a complicated situation, I have townish reads on both, thus don't want both to die, if I had to chose it'd be Keirathi. The fact that we can't even choose who we want to kill because you've muddied up the waters so much with the fucking double lynch talk is absolutely asinine.

Again here you dont sound really convinced that either one is scum, but prefer keirathi just a little bit.
Your play later belays that sentiment, it reads to me like you really really want keirathi dead, when instead, you say you DIDNT want a double lynch.

I would imagine that if you were going for damage control, you wont be so worried about it because you would find out when the lynch ended, and chill the fuck out till then .

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 02:50 GMT

#1213

What do you mean by this?

b) I don't trust Syl to make the pick. I think Dieno should be the one to initiate the duel.

Do you have a stronger scumread on Syl? Or something else entirely.
Also

On February 28 2013 06:38 Alderan wrote:
BTW Thrawn I like your list. A lot.

So why am I scum?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 03:03 GMT

#1221

Nah.

Hey Iamp I also think hapa has been really fucking passive this game,

However, was it a bus on Keirathi?
His reasoning was suspect and I dont really know :/

Again, however, his posts leading up to the lynch where he blasted Acro for saying Adam was 3P were pretty townie.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 03:12 GMT

#1229

Yeah but look at his play Adam, it doesnt look like the Hapa Im used to.

Hapa said keir was scum right at the start of the duel.
But if keir showed up, it wouldnt take much for hapa to switch to adam I dont think.

Anyway, if hapa steps it up, good.
If he doesnt bad, and we can deal with him later.

Acro, is double lynch scum favoured or town favoured?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 08:54 GMT

#1269

Yeah Dieno has been really careful with his play, not really ruffling anyones feathers, he seems WAY MORE serious than his CT game with the nice poster. Also basically fucked off in the last day.
Im not so sure that Syl is scum though :/

And hapa is null cause lately he seems like town hapa, not useless lurky scum hapa.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 11:06 GMT

#1271

Actually never mind, just read(past tense) his filter.
He doesnt do anything with his read on me, no questions no nothing.

Most of his posting is saying how bad adam is but still a town read? Whats the point then? Like his precious time could be spent actually finding scum instead of throwing shit on adam. He tries very hard to justify his vote on adam when it was clearly a policy vote. So in essence, I dont know his reads, I dont know who he suspects and I dont know if he cares.

His 'oats is scum' read on me is basically a summary of my filter, and it doesnt look like he really wants to find out who is scum.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 14:52 GMT

#1277

Wall of text :D

So is Cora your only scum read?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 15:08 GMT

#1280

+ Show Spoiler +

On February 28 2013 05:44 gonzaw wrote:
Night 1

Soundtrack

Keirathi the Mafia Goon has suffered defeat at the hands of Adam4167
+ Show Spoiler +

Mafia Goon
As a Gang Member, you’ve come to Liquid ready to take part in one last big holdup. Do this job right and you’ll never have to work again. Unfortunately, before you can carry out the heist, you’ll need to get rid of anyone who may cause trouble.[REDACTED]

As a reminder, you may not claim or refer to any of the flavor in this PM. You may claim/fake-claim your role name, any powers, and win condition.

Votecount:
+ Show Spoiler +

Duel 1 Vote Count

Adam (2): Sylencia, Dienosore
Keirathi(7): Oatmasters, Alderan, zarepath, cDgCorazon, yamato77, Hapahauli, Snarfs

You have 24 hours to send your actions.

now answer my question please :D

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 15:37 GMT

#1286

Stop tooting your own horn Cora, it doesnt serve any purpose.

What are your scum reads actually?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 15:39 GMT

#1288

On March 01 2013 00:38 Alderan wrote:

Show nested quote +

So you did what any self respecting townie would do and try to get him lynched too....

You're making yourself look worse and worse bro.

Do you understand the difference between not scum and town? Apparently not.
Not scum = not scum.
Could be 3P or town.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 15:44 GMT

#1292

On March 01 2013 00:40 cDgCorazon wrote:
Right now, Syl and you.

However, I need to have another look at your filter to see if my read on you has changed since the last time. I will do that after school.

No one needs a long post of my town and null reads. I just make scum reads unless asked for a town/null read.

Um I didnt ask for a list. Lol.

You do that Cora :D

You seem to have something stuck up your ass, you need to chill out :D

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 28 2013 15:47 GMT

#1296

And you also seem to be butthurt. Why may I ask?

On March 01 2013 00:45 Alderan wrote:
Acrofails then urges everyone to kill them both, when all he would have to do to see if his 3p theory is right is wait until the selection period.

TLDR: Acrofails tried to kill someone he knew was not scum, someone who had initiated a duel with Kier who he believed to be scum.

Also the only way to see the alignment and role of someone is for them to FLIP. And for them to flip, they have to DIE.

Also what is wrong with the final statement?