• Log InLog In
• Register

Nomination Mafia - Page 8

Post a Reply Prev 1 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next All

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 18 2013 16:12 GMT #1739 you know... i have no idea anymore. Jay/phagga/debears? i still hate the idea of VE scum cus that would mean i directed a scum lynch into another scum lynch, heh. SlOosh i really think is town else hes playing a great game here. Prp started to piss me off cus he wouldnt even give us a slightest indication of reads before he died.... jesus christ. Dead guy said Jay scum that means he scum right? T.T

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 18 2013 16:53 GMT #1740 whatever, scum too busy discussing in the qt who to nominate. Afk rest of day

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 19 2013 03:28 GMT #1752 okay so rly tired and stuff. Ill do a little writeup tomorrow, right now i think its reasonable to assume sthis is yet another 3 town lynch. We need to concentrate our efforts on the upcoming lynch, because its the last chance we have to catch us some scummers. I have a few more ideas other than 'Lol jay / phagga scum'.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 19 2013 19:31 GMT #1769 Jay might not be scum! Okay, some of you are about to go WTF LOL NO WAI JAY SCUM BRAH!!! But hear me out. Jay has been taking so much flak from every single person in the game. Ever since his shit D1 plays to his hardcore attempt to get VE lynched --- everyone has been hounding him and yelling scum at him, including myself. I ask myself these questions; who are his scumbuddies? With the exception of Phagga, I can't really pin him with anyone else. Oats, dibbers, VE, all seem very unlikely candidates. Tomorrow's proposed Jay lynch seems as if it would come much too easily; everyone wants to lynch him. Well done busses throughout the entire game, or a misguided townie. Common likeliness would suggest the latter. I've got my gripes with scummyJay over this game, but at some point I have to let it go. He pushed VE, who is likely not scum atm -- so what. He's just my antithesis but that doesn't indicate scum every single time -- it just means he read actions differently and was confirmation biased on VE being red. I hate to think this, I really do. Jay I fucking hate you so much and I want to lynch you. My heart says JAYSCUMBRO, but my brain states otherwise. I've pinned two scummers right here Phagga and Debears Phagga is scum. This is nearly undebatable. His actions throughout the thread have pushed a mafia agenda and defend himself throughout. Almost nowhere in his filter did he wish to lynch Snarfs. At best, Snarfs was his "alternate" lynch (read: bus) throughout the game. Now Debears has been the so-called coinflip in this matter. Not here during the entirety of day 2-3, we are unable to observe Debear's actions. Since Debear's replacement he has: - Tunneled Jay - Not wanted to lynch Phagga - Said Phagga was moderately scummy but has to lynch Jay Now, what was so startling about Debears to me is his read on Phagga's vote. He said that it was a townish vote, and his overall read on Phagga was slight town. I'm thinking to myself: "How did Debears come to this conclusion?" Unless he has some sort of extra information, there is no conceivable way that Debears can find Phagga's vote NOT scummy. I know town Dibbers, and he would have been all over that vote shit. Debears was trying to keep Phagga off the ballot yesterday by soft-defending him. Nor did he push Prplhz, just tunneled Jay the entire day. A town replacement at this stage of the game has ZERO information. Did Debears read the thread and come to his own conclusions? I think so, yes. But why is he tunneling Jay? He is the EASIEST mislynch target for him and scum Phagga. Debears actions thus far have shown nothing but soft-defending Phagga and hard-tunneling Jay. He has hardly ever mentioned Oats, VE, or other targets of interest besides giving them town reads. Who is the third scum? 50% Oats, 50% VE. Straight up. Neither of the above scum have pushed VE other than Snarfs, but as well all like to assume this game is a huge bus fest. Oats is just Oats and he could be anything. I'm not sold on VE scum right yet, so I say we lynch Phagga tomorrow. When he flips red, we lynch Debears. Then we deal with Oats and VE. Who to lynch today? Tbh I've got a bigger hard on for SlOosh than Yamato. Both are probably town, so it doesn't matter we won't catch scum today. Sorry brother, you still have the highest chance to flip scum ##Vote: Yamato Everyone just take a minute. Look at Phagga real good in relation to Snarfs and Debears. Look at Debear's posts about Phagga. Hell, just look at Phagga by himself. Jay not best lynch tomorrow, Phagga best lynch. Wagon of justice, confirmed. More to come later, extrapolating on some quotes and examples. Until then, work.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 19 2013 23:40 GMT #1775 wow thats a sheep if i have ever seen one jay. good for you its on the wagon of justice. but dont interpret this as a free pass.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 20 2013 01:31 GMT #1780 Jay, you're prolly town. that last post just seemed kinda weirdly timed. still, its a wagon of justice. and i like that you're on it. There still lingers a possibility that you both are scum, so any buddying of me will get you nowhere. im paranoid of you jay, to say the least. i really hope you are town and im not fucking it up

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 20 2013 01:39 GMT #1783 phagga and you, jay. but i think you being town ties up so many loose ends. its just in the back of my mind, is all.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 20 2013 01:41 GMT #1784 regardless, phagga is scum. i cant put a team together without him involved in some way. debears almost certainly with him

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 20 2013 01:50 GMT #1787 Yeah. Seriously if you're scum jay fuck you.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 20 2013 03:08 GMT #1790 Debears, i dont think he is scum right now. what say you to phagga scum? Jay isnt caught. hes just... in a bind. lol.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 20 2013 03:50 GMT #1793 cus phagga is 100% scum. so dibbers why shouldnt we lynch phagga?

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 21 2013 02:38 GMT #1873 Town have to consolidate onto one target. Therefore, we must think about this as clearly as possible without any confirmation bias. I will take into consideration nobodies opinion but my own in this lynch; so many possible mafia (yes, that includes you Jay, Oats). I will need all 3 of towns votes to assist me in going about this wagon of justice. For me, shouting VE scum all day is not productive. Nor is shouting Jay scum, Phagga scum, or anyone scum. I've been working all day and haven't gotten the chance to update my reads. A final report will be incoming tomorrow, and we will have ~ 24 hours to mull it over and decide. I want to get this right and not fuck it up. I want my target to be 100% certain to flip scum. As such, I will reconsider my reads on Phagga / Jay (one of them is scum, this is a certainty. The recent loljayistown sheep on me is bothersome, but not entirely wrong) as well as VE. The phagga / VE / Debears theory seems pretty good. But something is off here. It can't be this easy, nor should it be. Is Jay truly scum, or am I still just fucking paranoid? Is Phagga some mafia dude lurking in the shadows? Is VE just a retard? STAY TUNED TO FIND OUT! GG SlOosh, the wagon of justice will go on in your name.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 21 2013 06:35 GMT #1904 Hey guys im lurking on phone cus cant sleep. I think your, jay and yamato, confirmation bias is blinding you guys. firstly, association cases are boss riht now. debears is actually right on that point. its the entire reason i think Jay is town. so if you think association cases are bullshit, then that means i should vote Jay cus he scummy yo.... double bussing is unlikely, but its happened before and ive seen it in action. Could be the case here.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 21 2013 06:48 GMT #1907 I really hate to admit it, but debears making more sense than either of you guys. And he prolly scum, lol.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 21 2013 06:52 GMT #1910 Oh c'mon dibbers, i first suggested the phagga/ve/you scumteam. dont get all sour about it. what irks me is that everyone instantly sheeped it haha. i must be good or something.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 21 2013 07:01 GMT #1920 le wifom up in here. could be double bus could not be double bus. what do.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 21 2013 07:15 GMT #1936 Nomination wifom best wifom. I see your point, though. As I said, I want to be 100% sure of this lynch. There are other possibilities to consider. screaming VE scum over and over at lylo doesnt achieve much. It just makes you bad, even if you are right. Yamato, characteristically you are a very confirmation biased and clouded townie. Im nkt saying you arent right in this case, but there are better ways to go about things. I'll do a full write up tomorrow on who we should lymch. If it's VE, cool. wagon of justice.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 21 2013 07:21 GMT #1944 Yamato you're either scum or an idiot if you dont want to take things slowly today. unfortunately you're probably the latter.

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 22 2013 02:57 GMT #2025 Sup dudes, this looks interesting

Mr. Cheesecake United States3756 Posts February 22 2013 03:13 GMT #2026 All I gotta say is that Phagga and Debears are obv scumbuddies. I want to lynch either of them today. VE is like 50% chance scum, imo. The fact that this lynch is going off rather uncontested at lylo is disturbing to say the least. Seems like everyone took my scumteam prediction and ran with it (which, I'm flattered to say that least :D) However, lynches like this usually never end up well for town. VE you're being retarded calling Yamato scum. Just because he's pushing you doesn't make him scum -- it just makes him an idiot. Debears I won't listen to any cases by you cus you're scum. I will, however, laugh in your face if you're trying to call Yamato scum. I'd say the scumteam is Phagga / Debears / VE. If not VE, then Oats in substitution. The only other thing I can think of is something weird as shit like Phagga / Jay / Oats. Actually, Oats being involved really makes sense because he hard defended Phagga when everyone thinks he is scum. Phagga/dibber/Oats? Hmm. idk. In any case, Phagga is always scum lol. He's the best lynch target for today, because in every possible theory I can muster up he is scum.

Prev 1 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next All

Please log in or register to reply.