|
On January 28 2013 10:10 Mocsta wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2013 10:07 FiveTouch wrote:On January 28 2013 10:07 Mocsta wrote:
So mafia have framer and roleblocker left
and have lost 2 masons.. what are the chances they would have >2 masons on a 5 man team? What on earth are you basing this on? The original post It says they have to distribute jack, GF, framer, roleblocker between themselves "you also must choose the Godfather, Roleblocker, Jack, and/or Framer from among yourselves. These [potentially] four Mafia power roles must be separately distributed, meaning one Mafia member can only possess one of these powers." There can only be one of each role... why chose goon over framer?
Ohh ok I interpret that as.. 5 players, choose the roles you want out of this pool.
Remember gonzaqw "prince of bel air jack rhyme"
he goes he PM host to take jack...
|
hmm no one has been claiming anything ni general
maybe there is no medic.. but im just saying how i interpret the OP
|
Im saying I didnt like Annul due to his reactions to my mason PM.
i.e. as soon as I called him scum.. he instantly cut off communication. he didtn even ask why i thought he was scum or tried to argue being town
he didnt post the PM logs UNTIL I asked Adam for his take on the situation, then he freaks out and posts everything; putting out that I was a mason (something FT went out of his way not to release)
So yes I was suspicious of him, ande made that point about him bullshitting being mad hatter
|
Yam.. lol. i was trying so hard not to tell vivax yesterday u was mason
|
Actually I think Vivax is being intentional
I read this like 20min ago in Normal Mini mafia (Was bored so started reading that)
On January 26 2013 09:46 Vivax wrote:
[If you are town, my attacks aren't just a bit odd, they should be stupid.
Somes up his game to a tee atm in my opinino.
|
bke was mad hatter.. wonder why i bomb didnt go off; maybe it was on bugs for whatever reason and he lost it
|
Oats.. can you seriously consider 2 mad hatters in this game?
|
On January 28 2013 10:24 FiveTouch wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2013 10:23 Mocsta wrote:
Oats.. can you seriously consider 2 mad hatters in this game? Why not??
I thought the way the roles went was that the letter for mad hatter had to come up multiple times, to get multiple characters.
therefore, the chances of 1 mad hatter >>> chances of 2 mad hatter (Statistically)
same reason its unlikely to have 3 detectives
|
Nope.. let me find the source. I am quoting from memory. apologies
its from the wiki mafia site
|
oo. well i shut up now and listen, sorry for confusion
|
On January 28 2013 10:36 FiveTouch wrote:
like, you seem to be accepting the existence of 2 detectives...
Do i?
Didnt think I was following Vivax around blindly
And the 3 Dets vs 2 mad haters, was due to me thinking it was letter rolling. (as all the games i played have been like that)
austin/adam already cleared that up.
i said i apologised for confusion. I obviously shoudl have shut up when im not familiar with how all this stuff works. I realise that now and am avoiding any setup talk, its clear i dont know it.
|
On January 28 2013 10:39 Adam4167 wrote:
If you are the detective you claim to be, you can prove it tonight by providing a non-bullshit check on someone that doesn't die.
How do you prove this? (non-bullshit check)
He can choose any number of players to say "is town"
and to make it easier.. can just say a mason is town, as he knows who is mason, and he knows who is town..
if he misses scum its convenient.. theres what 12-14 players left, 2 scum? 1/6 chance to hit scum by lottery.
|
On January 28 2013 10:40 FiveTouch wrote:Show nested quote +On January 28 2013 10:38 Mocsta wrote:On January 28 2013 10:36 FiveTouch wrote:
like, you seem to be accepting the existence of 2 detectives... Do i? Didnt think I was following Vivax around blindly And the 3 Dets vs 2 mad haters, was due to me thinking it was letter rolling. (as all the games i played have been like that) austin/adam already cleared that up. i said i apologised for confusion. I obviously shoudl have shut up when im not familiar with how all this stuff works. I realise that now and am avoiding any setup talk, its clear i dont know it. but you said 3 DTs was unlikely, which implies that 2 is likely, whereas 2 mad hatters was extremely unlikely. This is kinda curious.
Nope your over reading it
im saying I thought the probablities are
1 same role >>> 2 same role >>> 3 same role
I used DT as a quick counter example, but applies to any role.
|
OK, well for me the outcome of this discussion since BKE was lynched is
(1) we have no idea the # of mafia power roles - stop guessing
(2) we have no idea the # of mafia masons - so all masons need to be scrutinised (yes including me)
QUESTION.
If medic was on bugs... and mafia used 2KP to shoot bugs.. would he have died (i.e. first bullet saved by medic, 2nd bullet kill shot?)
|
should add in.. now we know BKE wasnt mafia.. scum had 2KP last night
hence the question.
|
On January 28 2013 10:51 Oatsmaster wrote:
Why does it matter whether there was a medic on Bugs? Do you want him to out himself?
Nope.. not @ all
i want to know if a medic can save 2KP
BKE wasnt mafia.. so Night 2.. scum had 2KP..
|
Oats, your turning into an idiot with reading comprehension issues
the question is clear..
@austin. yes i know we discussed double stack.. ohh wait.. night 2 there was 4 scum players, so 2KP.. if BKE was jailed as scum, the KP would still be 2.
kk so musing is pointless.. got it.. sorry im feeling slow today.. gonna take a break
|
On January 28 2013 11:01 Oatsmaster wrote:
No Mocsta, I dont have reading comprehension issues, you have explanation issues.
Why do you want to know if a medic saves 2kp?
On January 28 2013 10:52 Mocsta wrote:
BKE wasnt mafia.. so Night 2.. scum had 2KP..
QUESTION.
If medic was on bugs... and mafia used 2KP to shoot bugs.. would he have died (i.e. first bullet saved by medic, 2nd bullet kill shot?)[/QUOTE]
The answer was yes.. 2KP on bugs with 1 medic = dead bugs.. thats all i wanted to know
i havent asked if medic was on bugs, nor do I care. get over yourself, you are constantly trying to inflate a direct question.
there is no hidden agenda with that question.
|
On January 28 2013 11:08 Oatsmaster wrote:
No Mocsta, that question makes no sense cause bugs is already dead.
It is an absolutely useless question, which makes me wonder why you are defending it so hard.
it might be useless to u
that doesnt make it useless
we all have our own heuristics
and i havent defended it
u have asked for continual clarification without directing what u want clarified.
u ask shit questions, u get shit answers
its not my problem u dont like what im saying.. but that certainly does not make it useless
|
fuba i would think is bumped to the top of the list.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
