|
On December 04 2012 10:05 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
1.) How many games of Mafia have you played / obs'd? Include roles if you wish.
2.) Would you lynch a lurker (I.E, few posts, little content) over a minor-moderate scumread? Explain.
3.) What is your favorite color?
On December 04 2012 10:04 yamato77 wrote:
Greetings gentlemen!
A few questions to spark ye olde town discussion:
1) How many games have you played on TL?
2) Where do you stand on lurker lynching D1?
3) Pie or Cheesecake?
These ones
|
On December 04 2012 19:26 Kickstart wrote:
I agree that if you don't have much to go on then waiting a bit and formulating your opinions more is ok, but remember that you should post when you have something because waiting until you have an iron clad case will take too long and you need to post reads sooner to establish your "townyness" and spur discussion.
Guess I will have to wait until more people are up to get more feedback on my humongous post, seems that most people called it a night a while ago.
Do you mean like, 'lol scumslip', or like off 1 post?
Because a lot of things look scummy without context, same as stuff can look townie without context but looks scummy with context.
I think that we shouldnt jump to conclusions/vote like I did last game but
Dont be afraid to vote.
|
EBWOP:
Your vote is very powerful :D
|
On December 04 2012 19:50 AxleGreaser wrote:
Now doing just that.
OatsMaster A question for you?
Is it a scum tell when one player tries to tell another player how to play?
When do scum do that and why?
When do town do that and why?
Remembering that Lynch all Liars is a thing that some people believe in.
What is your truthful answer to those two?
I think its a null tell because we all want to get better and to help people get better, especially in Newbie games.
assuming ulterior motive.
Scum tell people how to play in order to confuse them and make them less effective and more useless for town.
town will do that because they want effective players. A good, organized town will stomp on scum any day of the week so if you can do that, town has a easier time in finding scum.
|
On December 04 2012 19:45 Sylencia wrote:
<snip>
I feel that lynching lurkers has a negative impact for us, as it really gives up a day where we could be cleaning up the town, and also reduces the number of days we have to live.
<snip>
Can you explain this more?
|
Ok,
Do you want to share scum reads or keep them to yourself?
|
k cool.
What do you think about kickstarts suspicion towards yamato?
Also what do you think about yamato?
|
Why are you thinking about the game that is already over?
Why do you talk like this??
Just casually say stuff, if it doesnt sound natural please dont post it :D
|
my brain is melting reading axle's posting 
I really want to understand but I cant
so yamato, what do you think about kickstart's long post about you and Rad?
|
I still cant understand what you are talking about
Let me rephrase your last statment to what I would say.
"Oats, I believe you asked me to change what I was doing.
has my typing/explaining myself improved?
Explain.
"
However, I dont understand this.
As mentioned getting other people to do things is
a scum tell,
or helping a wounded (7/9)townie get back up of the floor
|
I could say that about you too
I agree with CC in the last game, meta over 2-3 games is not really identifiable though :/
I think we should scumhunt using more normal scumhunting methods.
|
I would probably tell you to l2play or something?
Scum want to cause confusion and make sure the town cant function as well.
I really dont know what I will do if I was scum :/
|
Im here, not going anywhere for 2 hours
|
Nope,
Well it might demoralize you and start a fight/mudslinging contest because it isnt very nice.
That will cause confusion because the focus is not on finding scum, but in seeing who can shout the loudest.
so yeah..
|
Yeah town wants to look like town so that people will believe them.
You read the last game right?
Lets say yamato went
SDM IS SCUM
You wouldnt believe him right?
even though he was town.
|
LOL I am town, what do you mean pretend?
I am getting peoples opinions of issues like policy lynch, changing of meta and that helps me to define reads on players,
If people dont talk, then I cant read them .
|
I already answered that?
On December 04 2012 23:47 Oatsmaster wrote:
LOL I am town, what do you mean pretend?
I am getting peoples opinions of issues like policy lynch, changing of meta and that helps me to define reads on players,
If people dont talk, then I cant read them .
|
What do you mean by getting other people to do things?
Like asking them to make me coffee and get my breakfast?
Or something different
|
|
|
Ah, why not we?
The game is a team game right?
It wasnt the first time the meta was brought up in this game IIRC
its not FFA.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
