Newbie Mini Mafia XXXI - Page 8

On November 30 2012 06:38 HeloKnight wrote:

Looking at XXVI, I do see a lot of this "wishy-washy" style of posting that he was doing and a lot of conclusion-less posts. It feels scummy to me, but I guess it's just something that he does. What game was he scum in? I need to see if he does this as scum too.
As for the voting, Jacob didn't say that he felt confused, he said that he "had doubts about my yamato case". I don't see it as similar to what Cheesecake claims (and your vote was the result of confusion). The votes were pretty close between Munk, yamato, and Kickstart when Jacob switched, so I can see scum motivation in that.
Anyway, this is rather irrelevant for now since I'm not considering Jacob as a lynch possibility today anymore. I will keep an eye on him for later though.

On Oats, I... am still skeptical of the lynch. There's still a chance he'll flip blue and put us in a really bad position. I doubt that anything will stop the lynch at this point, but I want to look at yamato closely before I vote.

On November 30 2012 09:51 HeloKnight wrote:
After going through yamato's filter, I'm seeing some things that just don't fit. Early on, I was feeling newbie town from him, and the cases made on him didn't really address that possibility. Recently, he's been very aggressive, especially on the Oats lynch, not something I'd expect from a player who's felt new the whole game. It's rather jarring going from his early game posting to his recent ones. I'm feeling one of Oats or yamato has to be red, but not both.. although I guess a bus wouldn't be a bad decision for a scum Oats.
That brings me to the vote. For reasons already stated by others, including general scuminess and lack of breadcrumb, I am skeptical of his claim. I've held off of voting because I was uncomfortable lynching a claimed blue, so I tried to see if yamato would be a better lynch for today. If yamato flipped red, we could somewhat clear Oats due to the aggressive tunneling yamato has been doing. But I can't fathom dealing with Oats in a LYLO situation. We'd practically be forced to lynch him anyway. So:

##Vote: Oatsmaster

On November 30 2012 12:06 HeloKnight wrote:
asdfg k