cos dp is town

I read your posts about him, but there wasn't anything in all the setup speculation that proved he was scum. And you didn't give anything outside of setup stuff so I'm not convinced

on top of that i've got my own separate town read on him if you ignore all the blue claims

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 22:59 GMT

#1724

##unvote
##vote risk.nuke

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 23:02 GMT

#1727

omg, so much stress removed with that flip

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 11 2012 23:59 GMT

#1731

On November 12 2012 08:56 mkfuba07 wrote:
Agreed.

didnt you want to lynch me if risk didn't flip red?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 00:10 GMT

#1735

yeah i dont know why either. i think has been wanting to lynch for a lot of the game but idk

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 00:13 GMT

#1736

sorry some words went missing idk whatg going on

meant to say:

i think kush has been wanting to lynch release for a lot of the game, but idk why fuba wants to all of the sudden

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 00:28 GMT

#1737

so somebody was lying when they voted for risk.. time to find out who

unfortunately i cant think about this game in a productive manner so i will return once the letters have straightened in between

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 00:51 GMT

#1742

no point in telling dp to jail someone specific because if whoever he jails isnt mafia, then mafia can just withhold the nk to trick us.. or dp could be scum. so if dp is town he should keep it a secret

i think people are playing irc mafia later tonight btw

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 01:21 GMT

#1747

dp, it all goes back to my first game where i rolled vig and didn't realize the importance of breadrumbing

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 06:11 GMT

#1752

acro roleblocked risk, so acro's death came from mafia kp. prom was roleblocked, so he's not mafia. there is no way in all of fuck that I'm going to vote for prom. I really think darthpunk is town but I'll reevaluate that read between now and the deadline. kush can only be mafia if there are 2 godfathers and a goon in a setup with a million blue roleblockers. that leaves me with...

release
fuba

hmm...

darthpunk, why did you jail prom instead of acro n3?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 07:19 GMT

#1757

release, what's your read on thrawn?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 08:27 GMT

#1764

mmm i don't think i like a release lynch. i'm having the same issues with it now as I did before.. he's way too open with his thought processes for me to think he;'s scum

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 12 2012 08:49 GMT

#1766

not sure about that scenario.. you're saying that if thrawn is town, and a scum knows he's town, they will believe his green check and therefore shoot kush because kush is confirmed green? but surely scum would know that everyone else in the game has reason to doubt both thrawn's claim and the accuracy of his check. (kush could be framed or sk)

thrawn's green check on kush did not instantly confirm kush as green from town's perspective, and mafia would know that

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 13 2012 04:43 GMT

#1851

My thoughts haven't changed much. Prom = confirmed town ofc, I also think that kush and dp are town. I was wary of fuba but release has been on my radar all game, and his new name claim stuff is hard to believe. He said he originally claimed something else in order to silence the vt flavor discussion... I don't see how claiming a name that doesn't fit with the theory would make people talk less about the theory.

##Vote: Release

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 13 2012 05:21 GMT

#1853

On November 13 2012 14:14 Release wrote:

Show nested quote +

"Look! The Theory doesn't work. Better stop talking about it"

versus

"Hmmm. That fits. Let's try to figure out whose name fits the least"

You wouldn't be confirmed vt just by claiming vt so people have no reason to accept that you were telling the truth about being proky pig. By claiming any type of flavor at all you were only adding to the discussion by presenting another point of conversation.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 13 2012 07:06 GMT

#1864

On November 13 2012 15:54 Promethelax wrote:
Thrawn: wonderful that you came back but I need a case from you on your top non-release scum read. Is that fuba?

Yes, fuba. could also be dp. If release isn't scum then I think scum is probably a roleblocker fake-claiming blue

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 14 2012 02:24 GMT

#1907

On November 14 2012 10:21 Promethelax wrote:
So, DP Kush Thrawn and Fuba how do you feel about what Release has been doing? Still going to lynch him obviously but do you read him as townier or scummier for these giant cases he is making?

I didn't like the tone of his cases. It looked like he was just going through filters pointing out anything that could be interpreted as scummy and he wasn't really clear about exactly how scummy he thought either of his subjects were. kush if you remember, it looks like the cases jacob was making at the end of that newbie when you two were scum. They aren't actual cases, just lists of things that could be interpreted as scummy.

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 14 2012 02:32 GMT

#1910

i think I want to lynch mkfuba. Every point in this game where I've thought about lynching release, I always hit a roadblock because he is extremely open with his thought process and it's be really difficult to keep that up as scum

On November 14 2012 11:01 mkfuba07 wrote:
I'm still going through thrawn's filter (sorry I'm so slow, I'm not even sure I'll be adding much to what DP said), but I'm not sure what to think from Release's big cases. He hasn't given up despite the fact that we've made it clear that we're lynching him, which initially made me inch back towards town. The problem is that scum would probably do that as well. The situation feels similar to when I switched off of drazak earlier this game. The fact that I know his entire case against me is incorrect doesn't make me sway either way, as I think it could be made by town or scum. I guess a summary would be... initially townish, but in the end null.

This is en extremely wish washy post... all I really get from it is that you think release might be a null read.

I'm really doubting the high number of blues we have, and on top of what I've already said before about fuba, his claim is the hardest to accept. He only claimed a role that makes him responsible for 1 roleblock, and there could be any number of reasons why a scum fuba would have known that it would be a safe claim to make. The breadcrumb was basically non existent.

Also, wtf kush I thought you thought I was town all game long... this is how easily you're willing to switch your vote?

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 14 2012 03:07 GMT

#1917

fuba: "I'm up for a lynch on either. The order is irrelevant to me."

that's bs

thrawn2112

United States6918 Posts

November 14 2012 03:21 GMT

#1920

because town players have opinions on who they think is scummiest and deserve being lynched first. saying "order doesn't matter" suggests that your mindset for this game doesn't include worrying about mislynches