So to summarize the case against inig:
1 Lack of strong scumreads (especially early)
2 Multitude of half assed, inconclusive suspicions
3 Reliance on town reads
I can see a first timer easily doing any of these things.

Daoud:
1 Doesn't share his opinions or thoughts
2 Just enough activity to not be a lurker
3 Posts that have nothing to do with scumhunting
4 Nonsensical in his treatment of djodref's "scumslip

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 26 2012 23:59 GMT

#678

@debears He said he might be sk or vig. Just wild speculation..not especially scum like.

Also his whole thing about not trusting me because I seem like I know what I'm doing, that reeks of paranoid townie to me.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 00:10 GMT

#686

sighhh he should have claimed.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 00:22 GMT

#695

Nacktjogger is from another forum mafia site called mafia scum. So he's probably pretty good hopefully.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 01:31 GMT

#698

Is debears like this every game? It's not how I remember him. And yeah debears you basically buttfucked us during the first half of day 1 when you had your little dickmeasuring contest with Rad, which NOTHING came out of. Nothing except spamming the thread to hell and making it unreadable.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 11:50 GMT

#713

@djo america was still sleeping. chill out.

I stand by the lynch. I still don't think Ini was scum. We had a bunch of afks. We had no other good lynch candidate.

So debears went onto the pony mafia thread after the flip and said

On October 27 2012 09:50 debears wrote:
LOL. I really need a breathe of fresh pony mafia air :D

To me this an indirect but clear reference to this game, how he is upset over lynching a blue. I think there is the possibility for it to be genuine or a scum trick. So it leaves me with a null read.

Then he pms me saying it's not related.
@debears While this game is going on don't PM me or anyone in the game ever about anything.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 12:52 GMT

#717

I know he's playing in the game and so am I... the game hasn't started yet though. He needed a fresh breath of pony mafia air because of the depressing shit that happened in this thread.

Djo I have not really put a lot of time into reading the thread and looking at filters, but my primary suspect just from preliminary observations is you.
I think your indecision at lynch time is a huge scumtell. It seems like you know that both of them were going to be town and wanted to gain town points by opposing both lynches. If you were town, and you really thought that none of them were scum, you would have tried to push someone who you actually thought was scum. But you did nothing except ask sylver endless questions with really no point to them.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 13:06 GMT

#718

Someone give me a meta read on debears. Is he usually this angry and rambunctious? I don't know his meta but it seems kind of fake to me.

And also his little stunt in the pony thread could be something to try to convince people following that thread that he is town.
(I actually did this when I got mafia several games ago)

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 13:54 GMT

#724

I was out of that newbie game so quickly that I have no idea what your meta is.. That other game you seemed totally different.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 13:55 GMT

#725

haha @ all the people theorizing scumteams.

you're being dumb

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 14:57 GMT

#742

I knew the daoud case wasn't that great. But i thought it was better than any other so that's why I voted for it... I said this a million times.

People theorizing scumteams are being dumb. There I said it again. And that makes me scum ?? lol

It's a well known tenant of forum mafia that you don't theorize scumteams before one of them flips (unless you are at the very end of the game)

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 14:59 GMT

#745

Everyone jumping all over me it's pretty funny.

If you want me to address all these questions you need to put them in one post. I will respond to anything.

@Debears.. I don't know your meta at all. The one game I played with you I was lynched d1 and I have no idea what you played like. I did not follow that game.
The other game you were like an insignificant little bug, much like you are now, except now you are louder.
So I also don't remember your play except that it wasn't memorable.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 15:00 GMT

#746

^sorry ignore the omgus

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 15:02 GMT

#747

I am kind of busy today jacking off and I don't feel liek making cases ATM. I will present my cases before the day post in case I get killed.

Also thanks for all your shitty suspicion. I hope it keeps me from getting nk.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 15:05 GMT

#751

On October 28 2012 00:03 Dandel Ion wrote:
So you're saying, his meta is actually the same to you? After you tried to make it out as if there was some huge meta divergence?

Right. I call Bullshit, Kushyboy.

I'm trying to say I am totally unfamiliar with his meta because I don't remember it from the one game I played with him.
And the other I was out so quick.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 15:07 GMT

#753

On October 28 2012 00:04 debears wrote:

Show nested quote +

Wowwowowowowo. Kush mentioning not getting nked again. Did it his last two newbies as scum.

I mention NK in town games too. It's a null tell IMO.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 16:13 GMT

#774

@nk mention
I didn't mention it in looney. I did mention it in LC.

djo is scum btw guys

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

October 27 2012 17:28 GMT

#784

Hey nacht you're here. Wanna give scumreads since you weren't here at all d1?

Also I want scumreads from all the people who were not able to participate d1.