TL Mafia LVIII - Page 7

On January 06 2013 09:02 Kurumi wrote:

Ahoy!

So Wherebugsgo triumphed over his findings with dear uni-mates, there was some champagne, crackers and even butter. Of course, you can't party forever. Nature called wherebugsgo himself and he went to the place where even kings go on foot.
Too bad wherebugsgo isn't a toddler, because he never came back from the bathroom. He did manage to take a leak though before dying, so no wet pants. Besides blood. It was everywhere.
+ Show Spoiler +

On January 06 2013 09:24 Djodref wrote:
With wbg dead and really cop, Jackal is confirmed scum right now.
I don't see mafia framing anyone with 3 cops (now 4) already in the cemetery...

I don't understand why mafia chose the 1 for 1 solution.
I also believe iamp when he says being protected and shoot, he was confirmed town after all.

On January 06 2013 09:28 grush57 wrote:
WTF LYNCH JACKAL

On January 06 2013 09:30 Toadesstern wrote:

Jackal was already confirmed mafia before, or at least pretty much. Everyone knew it's either Bugs or Jackal mafia the moment Bugs claimed. There's no reason to vote Bugs instead of Jackal so might as well shoot the confirmed townie and make Jackal a 99% confirmed mafia instead of just being 98% confirmed.

The problem with iamP is that I agree with you, he was pretty much confirmed town and I still think he's town.
That however leaves the question why mafia didn't opt to sac that KP for a dayvig as well.
But a town-vig shooting iamP makes 0 sense... why would a townie shoot him and on top of that not even claim prior to deadline.

So I guess it was mafia for some reason I don't understand yet?

On January 06 2013 09:41 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
I don't get what mafia would stand to gain by shooting WBG today instead of shooting 3 others and taking care of him at night. He had a one-time power, and this way there would be questioning if WBG is really the cop or if he is scum.

On January 06 2013 10:15 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:


Yes but you're missing the point. Even if there is 0.0001% chance we would lynch WBG it would be better than 0% if WBG is confirmed cop by death.

On January 06 2013 13:58 Clarity_nl wrote:
I am a 100% in favor of lynching jackal next cycle, and focusing this cycle on scumhunting and lynching someone else.

If Palmar comes back and makes a case on me, I see no alternative than him being scum.
I've thought him town ever since the log/reads posts, despite the bad marv lynch, but if he follows it up by going after another townie I just can't..... rectify it in my brain, idunno.

To everyone saying "they'll dayvig two more people today" please keep in mind that iamp claimed to get shot and saved, I have a hard time seeing this shot be from town and I have an even harder time seeing iamp lying (hes totes town) so please keep in mind that scum should have only one shot left if it is in fact a dayvig.

With this in mind:


I find it hard to see mafia either making this mistake by accident, or making it on purpose to seem like town. Therefore Sentinel is town. Despite my case on him I quite liked his defense, in combination with this it clears him in my book.

MZ is an obvious target for everyone but there has been no resistance to it, much like the marv and bc lynches, so it's putting me a little on edge and I'll be spending today trying to find alternatives (although I generally do this anyway even when happy with the main lynch target)

On January 06 2013 09:52 Palmar wrote:


I'm not too worried about you worrying about mine. I don't need to prove I'm innocent for another what... 72 hours? Jackal is getting owned today. It actually kinda suits me well that some townies suspect I'm mafia, makes it less likely I will be shot before I can make sense of this mess.

And yeah day 1 is on me, I honestly thought marv was scum, but I'd like to think there is a very easy to spot difference in my approach to the marv lynch this game and in rockband.

If not, I'm better at playing scum than I thought ^^

On January 06 2013 14:07 Clarity_nl wrote:


Why, I thought you were in favor of delaying it for a cycle as well? Did I miss something?

On January 06 2013 14:17 Clarity_nl wrote:
What do you think of yamato, iamp? I'm having a hard time reaching any kind of conclusion. He seems rather carefree which would be a town trait, but other than that....

On January 07 2013 04:35 debears wrote:
Hey guys I want to point something out about Iamp that I'm not liking right now

1) He claimed mason
2) The scum know that day vigs are unblockable
3) the scum for some reason felt the need to nk iamp, even though he's a mason who already used his power with palmar. All scum would have to do is wait til right after the nightpost to shoot him with an unblockable day vig instead of risking being blocked
4) We had 2 cops flip d1, including a role cop. the mafia were at a much lesser risk of being caught with their dayvigs with those flips
5) They didn't nk anyone else, yet had day vigs for 2 others.

I'd say if Iamp makes it to lylo, you guys had better lynch the sucker. The mafia's choice to nk instead of dayvig would make no sense if true.

However, I don't want to lynch Iamp because of the case that he could possibly be the mason and use his shot sometime

On January 07 2013 04:42 debears wrote:
Hey Iamp what exactly do you mean by one shot mason real quick

On January 07 2013 04:44 debears wrote:
Like, you have one bullet or you can only mason once?

On January 07 2013 04:46 Clarity_nl wrote:
iamp how do you feel about palmar, given recent flips.