Looney Lynching Mini Mafia - Page 7

On October 18 2012 20:52 thrawn2112 wrote:
I was going through filters and this post caught my eye:



This post, regardless of his alignment, tells us that mementoss was of the opinion that ON is not going to be replaced. In other words, mementoss thought that ON was going to be modkilled. Why as town, would you want to vote for somebody who is going to be modkilled? It serves no purpose, unless you think the opposing candidate is town... which mementoss didn't. So it makes absolutely no sense for town mementoss to vote for ON, if he thinks that Sand is scummy (which he did) and if he thinks ON will be modkilled. Why would scum mementoss want to vote for ON, who he thinks is going to be modkilled? To gain towncred after the flip.

Mementoss actually gives a close description of what I'm talking about here:



Here's a recap of what I'm trying to say:

Mementoss though sandroba was scummy. Mementoss thought ON was a null read. Mementoss thought ON was going to be modkilled. Mementoss votes for the null read who he thinks will be modkilled, instead of using his vote on the guy he thought was scummy?

On October 18 2012 21:01 thrawn2112 wrote:
that's just my read of your thoughts behind that post. and I don't see how "not replaced" doesn't equal "modkilled"

so wtf else would have been possible

On October 18 2012 22:07 Djodref wrote:


@Mementoss

I don't understand how the following is a case about kurking...



Could have have some honest comments on these points ?

On October 18 2012 22:19 thrawn2112 wrote:
time for an austin question

mementoss, pretend that you are an outside observer of this game. pretend that you think mementoss is confirmed scum. who do you think his scum buddy would be?

On October 18 2012 21:58 thrawn2112 wrote:
kush talk about your #1 austin pick plz

On October 18 2012 23:40 thrawn2112 wrote:
sigh.... I am having doubts about my kush town read. Go read his D1 filter paying special attention to when he talks about hopeless, ON, and sand. His biggest reaction to anything that happened was when people started voting for ON... like he just completely freaks out about it. basically everything he says about ON during d1 is some kind of defense. Also, he layed down those 6 votes for hopeless in the ON vs hopeless MU. I know everyone is giving him lots of town points for being the person who basically hammered (not correct use of the word but you know what I mean) ON...... but scum kush LOVES to buss. It is literally his favorite fucking thing to do as scum. Go look at newbie xxvii where he spent basically the entire last half of the game bussing jacob.

Kush also didn't do jack shit during D2. He just made a post every now and then letting us know the game was won and we should lynch prplhz/da0.

My read of him in D3 is that he is being dumber than what I expect from him and he's being more of an asshole which are both qualities of scum kush.

I know it's a shitty time to bring up a kush case but I have the feeling that a lot of people (including me) haven't actually read kush's filter because they've just written him off as town because of meta reasons.

On October 18 2012 23:43 austinmcc wrote:
I'm kind of confused about this here. These are two names that jump out at you?

There are legitimate reasons you could connect them.

VE defends mementoss hard when popping into thread
VE likes mementoss's case on djoref

And probably other things you could find if you went deeper, that's just the last couple pages.

But you're proposing them as a scumteam because they jump out at you? What exactly does that mean?

On October 18 2012 16:31 thrawn2112 wrote:

Austin's case against mementoss is quite good. However recently mementoss has been townie as hell. I'd like to see more discussion about djo because recently there's been several things pointed out about him, and we've basically been ignoring him all game.

On October 18 2012 23:59 thrawn2112 wrote:
I like flopping, I don't care if it makes me look bad, I'll point out anything that looks suspicious regardless of how many people I end up talking about and I'll take a hard stance once I'm convinced I'm right. Is it the most townie way to play? No but I care less about how townie I look and more about figuring out who's scum.

D1 was pretty stupid because all we learned was that ON is scum and hopeless is prob town, and D2 was spent going "lolz prp/da0 are last two scum." So we haven't exactly had the most pro-town atmosphere in which to make solid reads.

On October 17 2012 05:33 austinmcc wrote:
Spammin' it up since nobody else is posting. I'll be around for the next 40 minutes or so, partially checking this while finishing up work. Then I'm gone for most of the evening.

ET. I would like to hear some updated...general thoughts on the game. D1 you had some nice comments about how un-theme-ing themed games generally helped town, some praise for sandroba's comments on how to scumhunt, some other generic thoughts like:

We now know that scum let ON get into the final round, and let him get lynched. Therefore, they were NOT running good interference really, although they got sandroba close to being lynched. What does that tell you, in general, about the rest of the scumteam this game? Are they inexperienced? Do they just not like VE, so they wanted to get ON killed in order to not deal with VE replacing in? Did they run so much interference and influence so many lynches in the first 2 rounds that they simply ran out of gas and couldn't influence R3 and R4 enough?


I'd like you to comment on mementoss a little. Yes, you have posted on him. And linked back to those comments. prplhz flipped town, so according to your post yesterday mementoss was then one of top scumreads. Is this still the case? What was the towniest thing mementoss did D2? Do you agree with mementoss's case on me?


Also, I'd like your thoughts on the N1 kill. Sandroba made it to R4. He wasn't considered the towniest townie on townie town. Yet he was the first townie to be offed. Why? Does the choice of the N1 kill tell you anything about the scum team?

On October 18 2012 03:35 austinmcc wrote:

Mostly agree. I even deleted a post calling everyone out because of your post.

I could not understand this morning why everyone acted like this was some new thing that had just been discovered. It was why ET was probably town. I asked Hiro a question about it earlier, because he said something that made me think he didn't udnerstand what had happened last second with hopeless/ON/ET. It felt as if that bit was common knowledge already, and I, of course thinking you're scum, couldn't understand why this was neat that you'd gone and found this information.

Either it hadn't been discussed as much as I thought it had, or people need to read the thread harder.

Right now, because of the hopeless1der/ON vote, I do not think hopeless1der is scum. I've already said that, and I also noted some bits of his D1 filter that I found townie.

On October 19 2012 02:02 kushm4sta wrote:
What the fuck is this shit I'm reading?? I have a lot of things to address.
First: Thrawn you were scum in LC right? It's over now.