Aperture Mafia 2: Portal Edition - Page 5

On October 11 2012 03:54 Keirathi wrote:
Honestly, looking back through Jingle's filter, I'm having an extreme amount of trouble believing that he is town.

I read your reasoning austin, but I just don't find it sufficient. He kept talking about gonzaw and Matt for hours and hours, then he made a case that I mostly agreed with (because I thought iamperfection was town), although I didn't think it was enough to vote Matt, just keep an eye on him. After iamp flipped scum, no one ever even really looked at jingle again.

1) Has absolutely no opinion on iamp day 1
2) Builds cases on gonzaw and Matt, while making excuses about not being "pushy super agressive" to explain away why is wasn't pushing them so hard.
3) Has literally done nothing substantial besides tunnel gonzaw all game
4) Really "safe" claim
5) Claims hider, while S&B's role is Reverse Hider. Roleblocker flips day1, and my role is Roleblocker Roleblocker. Too much coincidence.

I can't really get behind any of those other cases. Its all based too much on things that we don't know who is lying about (and we know we have at *LEAST* 2 people who aren't being completely honest with their information).

And I still trust S&B because I literally have no reason to distrust my Role PM.

##unvote
##Vote: JingleHell

On October 11 2012 07:47 austinmcc wrote:
Ninjaed AGAIN.

I still don't see JH as scum. I don't see townghost with a green check on Drazerk doing next to nothing to stop his lynch.

On October 11 2012 08:28 gonzaw wrote:
Yeah it's the only thing that makes sense (specially since people may notice him changing positions and find it weird and put attention onto him).

Maybe after Draz checked town he backed off, but if Draz had checked RS he would have gone against him...
...another thought is: Should we trust his other reports? Basically JH being town and Kei being town as well.
Obvious answer is no....but if he was the last BS on the verge of losing he would have given correct information to town to gain more town cred perhaps?
If he's not the last BS he could have fucked with us though, and maybe he checked other people instead of those 2 (maybe he didn't check Hiro last night at all and that's why he fumbled trying to explain his action last night considering Matt's bus....if this is the case then Matt isn't BS since if he was they would have planned it and not let ghost get caught in that lie).



Okay

...Mattchew you are not confirmed town anymore sorry.

I can already picture the flavour of it:

+ Show Spoiler [Matt's role PM] +

Being serious though...if they were BS I think they would have thought about ghost's claim a little bit better and not have both of them contradict their own claims/fake-claims (as I remember ghost contradicted himself with the Hiro/Keirathi check from N3 right?)