Man, we still should have lynched Hiro.

He claimed that a night action on him got redirected. The only night action that we *KNEW* targetted him on night 2 was ghost. Hiro and ghost changed places in the list.

That should have been enough to lynch him, but I let myself get convinced that Hiro wasn't scum early, and couldn't change my mind even after his super safe claim that made more sense from a mafia alignment than a town one

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 04:42 GMT

#1800

Also I think I let you slide because I was convinced that austin was RS because of his play this game, and that Jingle was scum too. And I really only expected 2/2

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 04:53 GMT

#1806

Hahahaha

@Crossfire:

I agree. I got pretty bored/lazy when we started trying to solve the game rather than play it. I feel like if we just kept scumhunting, we were actually on a pretty good track. I was pushing austin until the gonzaw claim and then everything just blew up

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 04:55 GMT

#1808

On October 12 2012 13:54 gonzaw wrote:
Ehm....there were only 2 active townies in the thread, me and Kei and I did most of the talking so I guess you should say "I'm upset that gonzaw decided to speculate on the setup and not scumhunt"

I tried to scumhunt on D3 but meh everybody was off parking a vote on Draz and leaving so I couldn't really do much since I wasn't too convinced.

Holy shit, how do you have a 20 page filter in a 90 page game.

Rofl.

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 04:57 GMT

#1811

On October 12 2012 13:55 Keirathi wrote:

Show nested quote +

Holy shit, how do you have a 20 page filter in a 90 page game.

Rofl.

Oh, I guess I have 15 pages.

I probably wrote up another 40 posts worth of stuff that I didn't actually post too, though

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 05:06 GMT

#1819

On October 12 2012 14:03 Crossfire99 wrote:
well we sorta had to play like town. I lumped us in there because our #1 threat was RS. I mean we had the only DT but no KP, except for my very conditional KP.

You guys should have killed someone day2 btw. Should have had ghost position swap you night 1 to trigger your vig ability.

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 05:08 GMT

#1822

Ohhhh, I didn't catch that in the spreadsheet.

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 05:17 GMT

#1836

On October 12 2012 14:13 gonzaw wrote:

Show nested quote +

I would have thought he would have gotten protection on N1 though.
I mean, he was like "confirmed town" by that point, wasn't him? Why didn't any of the 4 "medics" (Nisani, Kei, S&B, Mementos) protect him? lol

I didn't know what S&B's role was. All I knew on night 1 was that whoever I targetted, ATLAS targetted too. And all I had was an anti-roleblock. I basically just picked a random name out of the hat for my night 1 action

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 05:19 GMT

#1838

On October 12 2012 14:19 Crossfire99 wrote:
Anyway, I had a lot of fun, GreY. Thanks for hosting. I definitely want to play in the next one if there's one.

Agreed.

Host a new one soon <3

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 05:23 GMT

#1842

On October 12 2012 14:20 GreYMisT wrote:
I totaly should have made ATLAS and P-Body on opposite teams with those same abiliites except P-Body's would roleblock someone unless they were already being roleblocked, in which case it unroleblocks them. Basically end up with scum jailer and a town jailer that way, however town would have atlas and scum would have P-Body. That way if scum get a medic kill they are rewarded with a RBer, and if town get a RB kill they are rewarded with a medic.

what do you guys think?

As long as you specify in the Role PM that they could be (or ARE) different alignments. I spent the entire game 99.999% trusting that S&B was town because your Role PM didn't really leave room for ambiguity, while the House Chezinu PM's in Aperture 1 specifically did allow of different factions :D

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 05:29 GMT

#1852

On October 12 2012 14:25 strongandbig wrote:
my role pm didnt say you were town, it didn't say anything about your alignment.

Welcome to Aperture Mafia 2: Portal Edition! You are P-Body, the Roleblocker Roleblocker. You and your buddy A.T.L.A.S. (who is also in the game) are great test takers! You are much more cunning than your partner, and can help others solve tests. Each night you may target a player, and remove all roleblock effects on them for that night. Because you and A.T.L.A.S. are so in sync, whoever he targets with his ability you will also affect as well. you win with the town

If it said that, and a "Test Giver" flipped, and you were somehow scum, I would have been pretty pissed.

Why would scum P-Body and town ATLAS (or vice-versa) be buddies at all? Much less specifically say we are both test takers.

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 05:34 GMT

#1854

On October 12 2012 14:33 gonzaw wrote:
Did S&B/Kei target me or one of them that night?

I don't really get how that's being invincible. If let's say S&B was shot that night...I'd get shot instead and die, right?

No, S&B and I targetted each other.

If S&B was shot, it would have been bussed to you. But since you were also bussed with me, it would have been bussed to me instead.

So basically, with the double bus on you, S&B and I were bussed with each other.

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

October 12 2012 06:04 GMT

#1859

On October 12 2012 14:57 GreYMisT wrote:

Show nested quote +

Really want the flavor I would use?

Hello, Cave Johnson here! Welcome to cooperative antagonist robotic testing! Today is a great leap forward in science, so you should be proud! Or rather your computer brains should be simulating proudness. Anyway after watching robots try to work together but then get each other killed, we decided to see how well robots trying to kill each other work together. Makes sense right? RIGHT?!?! Anyway, get out there and try to work towards your common goal of beating the other. You'll do fine.

We're done here.

That would be much, much more ambiguous and would have left room for one or the other to be scum. I totally don't think the PMs in this game left wiggle room for the other one of us to be scum, so if they were opposite alignments it would have been bastard modding

I do like that role concept for the next one though <3