|
On October 02 2012 09:51 annul wrote:
KJ
tell me what your interpretation is of why everyone is voting you? what reason do you think these people have?
It's early in the game and the Town needs something to generate discussion. Accusations fly at the slightest provocation and scum always needs a reason to cast their vote. I don't mind being the focus of the discussion but the rationale for lynching me has been extremely shallow.
At the moment, Shady Sands, myself and austinmcc are the vote leaders with 7, 4 and 3, respectively. I don't like how quiet the game has become now that Shady Sands is the leader. He isn't around to defend himself and he seems like an easy target to waste votes on.
|
What if we switch targets and Shady Sands casts a last minute vote to avoid the modkill?
|
Okay, I didn't like Shady Sand's lynch anyway.
By my count it's 7 votes for Node and 6 for Shady Sands at the moment. I'll put myself out there and add extra weight to the Node lynch.
|
On October 02 2012 11:15 kingjames01 wrote:
Okay, I didn't like Shady Sand's lynch anyway.
By my count it's 7 votes for Node and 6 for Shady Sands at the moment. I'll put myself out there and add extra weight to the Node lynch.
NOTE: I was wrong. It was 7 to 5 at that time.
|
I don't know. annul and Sharrant have got me second-guessing this.
I wish it wasn't Node who was the lynch target because it was just too easy and there isn't very much to connect him to anybody else.
|
On October 02 2012 11:53 Sharrant wrote:
You're right, sorry. That was an amazing misreading from me. For some reason I thought someone had brought up him being modkilled, not replaced. So... yeah, if a replacement is more likely, that makes this whole thing seem a little scummier because there's now stronger motivation for red players (supposing of course that Shady is red).
I mentioned modkill earlier so you might be thinking about that post. He hasn't voted so I thought that's why he was going to be removed from the game.
On October 02 2012 11:00 kingjames01 wrote:
What if we switch targets and Shady Sands casts a last minute vote to avoid the modkill?
|
On October 02 2012 12:03 annul wrote:Show nested quote +On October 02 2012 12:01 iamperfection wrote:On October 02 2012 11:56 annul wrote:
and read node's filter
this was very easy. two posts. first post defends shady and calls out kush; second post retreats from this defense slightly and continues to argue against kush.
considering node's only two posts match what i have been arguing all along............. i like this guy.
the big question now is what it is about these two posts that caused 8 people to drop their pants and go all in on this guy. like, i read the posts... what is there exactly that people are seeing? this doesnt make sense. 8 votes on him so i have to assume with a normal mafia count that there are at least some towns on him.... why? when did shady push anything? How could a town player reading the thread think shady is town because he pushed something after his trolling. what did shady push? ....nowhere did i mention shady pushing anything?
I think he means Node.
|
On October 02 2012 12:12 Node wrote:This is beyond ridiculous. I misinterpreted austin's post as being more about finding Shady town-ish at all. Shady's pushing had been weak, but it was certainly a shift from his earlier play -- that's what I was getting at. He was backing up his claims by contributing instead of simply running away. I just don't think that's something mafia would be willing to do. At the time I was also under the assumption that he was, you know, still playing. Which is why the second post said what it did -- I was backing off of those claims specifically because Shady was no longer contributing. And what scares me the most about this switch is how little justification everyone that's not austin is giving. Kush's is literally the definition of an OMGUS, VE just "likes a Node lynch" (yet is pestering annul for his thoughts on me)... Show nested quote +On October 02 2012 11:02 BroodKingEXE wrote:On October 02 2012 11:00 kingjames01 wrote:
What if we switch targets and Shady Sands casts a last minute vote to avoid the modkill?
That never happens. Can someone give me a quick node reason, AFAIK hes a lurker It happens. I've done it. Look at Death Note Mini, the last game I played in. On a few days players placed votes on me, then switched off as it got closer to the deadline and I hadn't posted -- and used the exact justification that they expected me to be modkilled. Of course, it never happened. Anyways, switching my vote to Shady because apparently that might be what it takes to me from getting lynched.
Well, we've got Node here now. If you guys have a real case then direct it to him and see how he responds.
As far as I can tell there are no real solid candidates for a good lynch.
I'll move my vote to Shady Sands to give Node some breathing room.
|
On October 02 2012 12:19 BroodKingEXE wrote:
@Node look at the cirumstances of that lynch though. If Shady were to sneak vote he would be insta killed the next day/night. Day one votes usually end up with little to no info due to a town lynch anyway so why would he risk killing a townie for one mafia?
You'd be surprised how long some of these players can hang on even when they should be insta-killed.
|
On October 02 2012 12:41 kushm4sta wrote:
Why would you vote for a lurker who is getting replaced? It makes no sense to me.
Most of shadys scuminess comes from his lurking. His troll act did not seem scummy we can agree on this.
Why is he lurking and how can you be so sure that he will get replaced?
|
On October 02 2012 12:50 kushm4sta wrote:
I urge some people to move off shady and onto node.
If he is playing scum he probably wouldn't just allow himself to be replaced like this.
What if we get someone super active and awesome instead of him?
He's definitely going to be PROBABLY replaced, possibly modkilled.
Kill node instead.
Node has been after me indiscriminately. As the weakest, scummiest meta, active player I am very good scumbait..low hanging fruit.
He has contributed nothing helpful in his filter.
See other people's arguments.
So you want us to lynch someone because he's been pushing you? That doesn't prove that he's mafia.
|
On October 02 2012 12:53 kushm4sta wrote:Show nested quote +On October 02 2012 12:52 kingjames01 wrote:On October 02 2012 12:50 kushm4sta wrote:
I urge some people to move off shady and onto node.
If he is playing scum he probably wouldn't just allow himself to be replaced like this.
What if we get someone super active and awesome instead of him?
He's definitely going to be PROBABLY replaced, possibly modkilled.
Kill node instead.
Node has been after me indiscriminately. As the weakest, scummiest meta, active player I am very good scumbait..low hanging fruit.
He has contributed nothing helpful in his filter.
See other people's arguments. So you want us to lynch someone because he's been pushing you? That doesn't prove that he's mafia. It's not about proving anyone is mafia. It's about choosing the best option.
I might buy that if your main reason for targetting him is that he that he targetted you.
|
EBWOP:
On October 02 2012 12:53 kushm4sta wrote:Show nested quote +On October 02 2012 12:52 kingjames01 wrote:On October 02 2012 12:50 kushm4sta wrote:
I urge some people to move off shady and onto node.
If he is playing scum he probably wouldn't just allow himself to be replaced like this.
What if we get someone super active and awesome instead of him?
He's definitely going to be PROBABLY replaced, possibly modkilled.
Kill node instead.
Node has been after me indiscriminately. As the weakest, scummiest meta, active player I am very good scumbait..low hanging fruit.
He has contributed nothing helpful in his filter.
See other people's arguments. So you want us to lynch someone because he's been pushing you? That doesn't prove that he's mafia. It's not about proving anyone is mafia. It's about choosing the best option.
I might buy that if your main reason for targetting him wasn't that he targetted you first.
|
I'll go on the record and say that annul is my top choice for mafia right now.
Mattchew, so after everything Day 1, your choices for scum are slOosh, BC and annul? If he survives the night, would you support a lynch of annul?
|
On October 03 2012 11:31 kushm4sta wrote:Show nested quote +On October 03 2012 11:22 kingjames01 wrote:
I'll go on the record and say that annul is my top choice for mafia right now.
Mattchew, so after everything Day 1, your choices for scum are slOosh, BC and annul? If he survives the night, would you support a lynch of annul?
Are you that disconnected from this thread? IF he survives the night? How dumb would scum have to be to nk a town annul...
What happens if he's vigi'd so we don't have to waste a whole day discussing his lynch?
|
On October 03 2012 11:42 slOosh wrote:Umm, ok. Risen can I follow you up on this post? Show nested quote +On October 02 2012 01:26 Risen wrote:
To sum: I want to see how Shady flips because...
1) He's my top scum read (we'll see how kj responds, and a red Shady doesn't make him green at all)
2) It will tell me more about Z-Boson and ShiaoPi. More so the second part since it seems like you think kj is town.
I don't think he's ever said that he thinks I'm Town only that he thought saying 'spy' instead of 'scum' was a lousy reason to get lynched.
|
That's not exactly a worthwhile discussion. Let's not clutter the thread up with this unless you feel that it will lead somewhere.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
