Rockband Mini Mafia - Page 5

On September 22 2012 05:23 Zephirdd wrote:


they were both town and it was day 1 IIRC

we are at day 2 and palmar has done jack shit

On September 22 2012 06:02 marvellosity wrote:


if you ever want to win a town game, you might wanna listen to people who know what they're talking about

On September 22 2012 06:06 marvellosity wrote:


no, say stupid, retarded crap like "only mafia consider Palmar a threat" is bad.

On September 22 2012 09:01 Ange777 wrote:


Read on you before was null/town. Now it's town.

Current read on Mementoss is scummy. He accuses me of only making a case on a player who was already under suspicion from a lot of players. Same can be said for him. And I don't think his case has any merit, it seems more like his quote



can be applied to him as well. Especially the Smiley part of his case is just ridiculous. I can't get the thought out of my head that he is simply looking for things in my filter that he can turn scummy like the smiley.

To be honest, I have not read through the latest pages that closely (it really is late) and I would like to re-read them before making my choice. But if I can't pick Palmar (I wouldn't lynch marv, I still have a nullish read on him) it would be one of Mementoss or iamperfection. Mementoss for this absolutely weird case and iamperfection for not contributing at all until being called out by me.

Tallest mountain? iamperfection. Most wildlife? Zeph



I don't know if you want to hear about my real life issues ... if it helps I was excessively inactive in Newbie Mafia XV and I was town.

On September 22 2012 08:12 Ange777 wrote:
Snip*
Come one ... scum meta? I have played one single game as scum which also was my first game of Forum mafia ever. Please don't make the mistake and call me scum for typing a smiley. I am a smiley person. I just love putting smileys into my sentences but having seen that people always seem to take smiley suspicious I have already tried to cut down my smiley usage in mafia games.
Snip*
Come one ... really? The smiley rule?

On September 23 2012 03:25 marvellosity wrote:
No.

Everyone who isn't weird austin, VOTE PALMAR

On September 23 2012 04:46 austinmcc wrote:

Because I'm more sure on ange. Afaik, basically everyone on either of the two thinks that both are scum.

On September 23 2012 04:47 Hapahauli wrote:
Kinda liking the HiroPro lynch now tbh.

Palmar's putting in :effort: and I actually agree with him quite a bit on Hiro not pushing his lynches. Hiro wanted to lynch me at one point, but gave it up way too easily without pushing it at all. I'll be mulling things over. #1, I don't want to lynch Palmar. Still not sure about Ange.

On September 23 2012 04:55 austinmcc wrote:

I think...at the end of N1 I noted that his interactions with hiro and with ange looked funky D1. I have not gone back to fully look through him today, because I liked where we were and throwing marv into the mix for serious discussion was best saved for another day. I think that either ange or palmar, when flipped, tells us SOMETHING about marv, ange a little more (marv and palmar could very easily both be scumbuddies and just spamming thread/distancing themselves).

Right now I'm still...hmmm. I guess I'm scummy on him, yeah. He just continuously rails against Palmar, lets Palmar get his goat, tries to shift the lynch of Ange. Palmar is right that his play changed enormously pre-accusations from Palmar and post-accusations. My play has changed as well though, so I can't do too much with that. However, what marv has actually done once getting active hasn't felt pro-town. I'd hope that town marv would see what's going on, quit spamming so much, quit getting so inflamed, because he's destroyed town atmospheres in past games when doing that as town. So I read his constant sniping at Palmar as scummy.

I'd rather see ange flip. Probably rather see Palmar flip. Rather have legitimate discussion on marv, and rather give him a solid look again, especially if we flip someone non-marv and can draw any connections there.

But I'm generally paranoid, and so I'm always going to be worried about marv/Palmar both being scum, or marv and basically ANY of my other main scum candidates, because his interactions haven't felt townie this game at points. Best I can do is give an approximation of my thoughts at this point, and then do some digging during N2 to figure out how I really feel.