|
On September 01 2012 07:25 BlackMamba24 wrote:
...
Anyway can anyone familiar with strongandbigs meta tell me if it is normal for him, as town, to make huge fucking posts immediately and add a ton of bravado like that into anything he says cause if not I'm saying we should lynch him.
Pardon my skepticism, but is this really a scumtell? Even if he historically makes smaller posts as town, I can't imagine why making larger posts would make him mafia, even on a meta-basis.
|
|
|
On September 01 2012 08:10 BlackMamba24 wrote:
Things must have really changed in TL Mafia if I'm getting bandwagoned for saying I don't like lynch all lurkers and no one responds to the scumtell that when I used to play was typically the one that myself and most veteran players jumped all over on day 1??
Stop it. You don't have a "bandwagon" on you. Second of all, you're pretending like that case of yours never existed.
|
what the one against you? how am i pretending it doesnt exist
You said that you're getting voted because you're criticizing the lurker-policy lynch. Oh whoops wait no ppl are voting for you 'cause of your shitty case.
Misrespresentation at its finest. Can we invoke lynch all liars here?
|
On September 01 2012 08:25 Shady Sands wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2012 08:23 Hapahauli wrote:what the one against you? how am i pretending it doesnt exist You said that you're getting voted because you're criticizing the lurker-policy lynch. Oh whoops wait no ppl are voting for you 'cause of your shitty case. Misrespresentation at its finest. Can we invoke lynch all liars here? Hapa can you read my ghost case? Please?
Oh sure - will get to that now. Got caught up a bit in other things in the thread.
|
And can we cut out the shit about Palmar? Exactly what does this do to catch scum? Grow a pair and vote him or don't.
|
@BM24 - At what point in the last 5 pages did I attack you for the policy junk? I didn't. I've made it clear what I'm attacking you for and you're failure to read is mindblowing.
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=363625¤tpage=15#297
If you think this counts as "jumping on you for lurking" - I don't even know what to say. Either you're just not reading, or you're mafia, or both.
@ShadySands - Read your case on ghost, and tbh I still read him as null. Him being inconsistent and whatever isn't necessarily scummy. His sudden switch from indecisiveness to voting for mementoss actually reads as slightly townie to me. It would be really easy for him to avoid that contradiction (as mafia) and yet he didn't.
|
##Unvote BlackMamba24
I think I've seen enough. Responses/emotional-defense seem townie to me. Attitudes to his previous case also seem townie enough.
TBH, I'm tempted to lynch Palmar on the basis that he actually gave a shit as town in Normal Mini III.
|
Hmm... where's our friend SolarSail?
|
##Vote SolarSail
For being useless.
|
That's actually true. So we have Hopeless, Solar, and Node all on pace for modkill-land?
|
##Unvote SolarSail (for now)
|
##Vote Palmar
He's the only guy who's been useless and isn't heading for a modkill.
|
Well I've been thinking about it for the last 15 minutes or so. Again, he actually gave a shit in his last town game.
|
On September 01 2012 08:58 MrZentor wrote:
Mhmmm....suuureee.........
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=363625¤tpage=19#379
On September 01 2012 08:45 Hapahauli wrote:
##Unvote BlackMamba24
I think I've seen enough. Responses/emotional-defense seem townie to me. Attitudes to his previous case also seem townie enough.
TBH, I'm tempted to lynch Palmar on the basis that he actually gave a shit as town in Normal Mini III.
|
I'm going to keep my vote on Palmar for a bit. As it stands, there are a couple of people I want to hear more from before I decide what to do with my vote - namely those that haven't voted yet. I'll give em an hour.
Relooking at some filters, I'm growing a bit wary of HiroPro, and his actions seem to follow a scum thought-process.
- He enters the thread and builds a "case" on MMtoss. This "case" is a re-hash of most of what I pointed out earlier in the post.
- What seems scummy to me is how quickly he dropped his case. You'd think that a townie would have a bit more confirmation bias? But he drops it the second MMtoss posts his defense to HiroPro for his MrZentor/Hapa scumteam. That seems like a really weak reason to drop your main scumread.
- He spends the next few hours making one-liners and trying to contribute, when really not. Take a look at his filter.
Thoughts?
|
Oh, in case you were wondering, I still think MMToss is town. Admittedly partly due to my new suspicions against HiroPro
|
On September 01 2012 09:16 BlackMamba24 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2012 09:13 Hapahauli wrote:I'm going to keep my vote on Palmar for a bit. As it stands, there are a couple of people I want to hear more from before I decide what to do with my vote - namely those that haven't voted yet. I'll give em an hour. Relooking at some filters, I'm growing a bit wary of HiroPro, and his actions seem to follow a scum thought-process. - He enters the thread and builds a "case" on MMtoss. This "case" is a re-hash of most of what I pointed out earlier in the post.
- What seems scummy to me is how quickly he dropped his case. You'd think that a townie would have a bit more confirmation bias? But he drops it the second MMtoss posts his defense to HiroPro for his MrZentor/Hapa scumteam. That seems like a really weak reason to drop your main scumread.
- He spends the next few hours making one-liners and trying to contribute, when really not. Take a look at his filter.
Thoughts? That's a bit misleading. He was not convinced at all by MMtoss' first defense and only unvoted after MMtoss cleared it up further. If he was looking for a reason to drop his case, he would have done it sooner than that. MMtoss later addresses HiroPro's main suspicion and the answer satisfied him.
That's the interesting part - he tunnels MMtoss until I explicitly point out his "first defense" (the longer post I take it?) to HiroPro. Then HiroPro posts that he's waiting for MMtoss to respond to him. Then he immediately drops his read after MMtoss responds.
|
Interesting... I post suspicions against Hiro, then two posters throw down two votes against two different players. Coincidence?
|
Up for swinging a vote against HP Shady?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
