Whether you want to lynch Harry, or you lynch me, at least now it'll give us good information against you if and when one of us flips town.

- I say if because I'm not totally sure if Harry is Mafia or not. If he is, you're town in my books. If he's not, you COULD be scum. And if he's not scum AND you live to D3 without a hit placed on you, than I'll think you are probably scum and I'll make a case on you D3.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 20:59 GMT

#908

I didn't say we should lynch him. I said I'll be making a case on him D3 (should he live till then).

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:05 GMT

#910

Any other comments? Last game I was in I was lynched for saying something supposedly scummy, and I wasn't there to defend myself before the deadline. I'm glad I'm here this time to try to settle this so if any one has anything else to say or whatever please say it.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:06 GMT

#911

Well yes I said I'm fine lynching either me or Harry. But I said I'd rather we go with Harry who I know may or may not be actual scum, than myself who I know is town.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:14 GMT

#914

Now you're just throwing WIFOM around. I made it clear why I said what I said and I responded to your criticisms about all my posts this game (seems like you always know how to pull those scum reads out of thin air).

I'd like to hear if anyone else has something to say.

I will use myself if necessary but I'm sure if I'm not there you will blow off me being lynched as something along the lines of.. "oh come on guys, it was an obvious scum slip. If you were in my shoes you would have called him on it to."

In the scenario where you ARE jailer and die at night tonight, I'd at least have us try to lynch actual mafia scum and not just settle for myself being lynched as a townie to prove a point. For all I know mafia already have you marked for hit tonight and if I die and you die then by D3 not only is Harry still alive but we have no good information.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:20 GMT

#916

I am not throwing ANY WIFOM at you Jingle. I was stating my thoughts and why I did what I did. I haven't even made a case against you at this point as I said I wouldn't until we see what happens past the night.

The only theoretical content I mentioned was this

In the scenario where you ARE jailer and die at night tonight, I'd at least have us try to lynch actual mafia scum and not just settle for myself being lynched as a townie to prove a point. For all I know mafia already have you marked for hit tonight and if I die and you die then by D3 not only is Harry still alive but we have no good information.

"Lynch for info"? did you not say you were 95% sure that Harry is scum? I want to kill scum. Self lynching myself would just be purely for information that you may or may not dissuade the town into ignoring.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:28 GMT

#918

When a bandwagon is launched and landed, and the town is silent.. mafia are sitting back laughing as another town is lynched.

Can anyone say something else? I don't think arguing with the person who I've told I may be pushing for D3 makes sense.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:35 GMT

#922

Yes that would be a good plan but your suggesting that there's nothing Jingle can do at night (as jailer) to confirm himself. Couldn't he role block someone we consider to be town and if they vouch than we know he's actually jailer.

Can anyone else say something as well. I don't want to only talk to Jingle and Fulla who said

On July 21 2012 04:43 Fulla wrote:
As far as I know jingle is confirmed town? So I will just vote whatever he says. He's a much better player than me anyways.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:39 GMT

#924

On July 21 2012 06:32 JingleHell wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is heavy WIFOM.

Show nested quote +

At least, considering that you were apparently very convinced I could be right about Harry. And again, if you weren't, you should be presenting evidence on his behalf. Not trying to change how someone looks after the lynch.

Show nested quote +

Talking about lynching for info like it should be a priority over lynching for red.

Show nested quote +

No matter how you dress it up, this is suggesting lynching for info...

And, of course, I'm pretty sure that each time you respond, more chunks of my original case against you disappear from what you're responding to. Without me or anyone else sounding even slightly convinced.

That isn't full of WIFOM.
I was never very convinced you were right about Harry. I said he could be scum, and that I settled on him.
I always said lynching for scum is priority, but knowing I'm town, I don't want to just die to give you information.
I never wanted to lynch Calgar. Did you not see me not vote on him? I was trying to draw a response from possible mafia lurkers (if he himself was mafia). Since no one suspicious came out I shifted my suspicions away from Calgar.
Don't accuse me of nit picking your case. I've responded to it fully. You just don't agree with anything I say. Even despite being supposedly so sure of your case on Harry you are perfectly happy lynching me.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:40 GMT

#925

On July 21 2012 06:36 JingleHell wrote:

Show nested quote +

Oh? What happened to this attitude?

Show nested quote +

Uhm it's fairly obvious that there's no reasoning with you. I responded to your case fully and your still sitting on me.

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:45 GMT

#928

What did I ignore? You said the case on Harry is a dark shade of grey did you not? All this says to me is you were giving yourself some wiggle room should he flip green. You even mentioned how maybe he is honestly scum hunting with his case on you... seems like you were just giving yourself room to negotiate should he flip green and the town ask you wtf?

drwiggl3s

Canada167 Posts

July 20 2012 21:52 GMT

#931

Alright I'm done here. Tried my best to explain myself but it went no where.

Goodluck town! Sorry but you're going to need it apparently.

After today it'll be 3 Mafia to 6 Town.