TL Mafia LVI - Page 31

On July 01 2012 22:44 austinmcc wrote:
However, I'd love for him to clarify his first post, given all this discussion. Broodking, you say that you don't consider those with 4 or 5 games newbies. The rest of the players seem to disagree, and I know that I do (no more newbie games allowed =/= not a newbie in my mind). IF you accept a much more broad definition of noob, like the thread seems to want, would you alter your first post? Should people with something like 4-8 games be treated like the noobs in your post, or treated like more seasoned players?

On July 01 2012 22:44 austinmcc wrote:
I'm not comfortable with a Broodking lynch right at this point, although it looks like that wagon has passed somewhat. For one thing, from what I remember, he's been mislynched a few times (out of a small sample size).

• Newbie XIII, D1 mislynch
  
• Student Mafia, D3 mislynch
  
• "Area" LIII, modkilled after D3, so no mislynch. Anyone in that game remember him looking scummy?

I'll admit that I don't find "BKE often looks scummy as town" to be strong reasoning, but for D1 it's enough that I don't want lynch him. I also thought BKE had played in another game or two, but didn't see more in his profile.

However, I'd love for him to clarify his first post, given all this discussion. Broodking, you say that you don't consider those with 4 or 5 games newbies. The rest of the players seem to disagree, and I know that I do (no more newbie games allowed =/= not a newbie in my mind). IF you accept a much more broad definition of noob, like the thread seems to want, would you alter your first post? Should people with something like 4-8 games be treated like the noobs in your post, or treated like more seasoned players?

---

I'm alright with adding my vote to mK right now. The whole "role name" thing is actually what I thought Mattchew was referring to earlier when he said a previous poster looked super townie to him, and that was my dumb "don't think you should be trusting that" post. It's in VT pms, it's in the OP, if scum received the VT pm then they had it too, etc. Worried that mK's reaction is a blue who didn't read vs. scum who didn't read (those are the obvious options, so don't get on my junk about possibly revealing blues), but if so, he can defend himself if he ever returns to the thread. The absence in the face of votes doesn't look good to me from that standpoint.

---

NoSmurf, initially I read you as one of the more sensible and townie folks in the thread. However, this caught my eye somewhat:





Care to explain your train of thought? Over the course of 2 hours, you went from "probably town" to "completely fine with Mandalor lynch/scumread on Mandalor." Would like for you to articulate why you changed your read there.

On July 02 2012 08:19 marvellosity wrote:
Vivax, you clearly don't understand where I'm coming from them. It's a mindset thing. It's not the fact he's lurking, it's the tone of his post and how he puts it across.

On July 02 2012 05:51 grush57 wrote:
Alright
##Vote: Mkmkmknmkmkmkmk

On July 02 2012 04:05 grush57 wrote:

Y u so scum bro

On July 02 2012 08:34 s0Lstice wrote:
I was feeling pretty good about mKmKmK until I saw how the votes fell on him. Maybe it's paranoia, but like Katina said, it felt pretty easy to get him a majority.

On July 02 2012 08:37 EchelonTee wrote:

You were one of the last voters ...............
..........

Ahhhhhhhhhh