On April 20 2012 07:59 johnnywup wrote:
how hilarious would it be if they have a bastard mafia closed setup but its standard mafia with no bastard in it and the paranoia kills people :p

lol. Instead everyone knew this wasn´t a normal game, but still hunted for scum and SKs

Hassybaby

United Kingdom10823 Posts

April 19 2012 23:23 GMT

#922

Yeah, about that

I really like the concept of having neutral survivors as basically Vanilla. Plus the choices of wincons was awesome (seemed there were a fair few people who had me alive as an option, but the chances of me dying were higher than most people)

Small note: I think I maybe needed more people as my wincon. Then I would have protected more people and possibly had a higher chance of dying. But with only two, I basically only protected phagga :D

But the game was awesome. Really liked the overall concept, and was nice to live past N2 in a game :3

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

April 20 2012 00:30 GMT

#923

On April 20 2012 07:59 johnnywup wrote:
how hilarious would it be if they have a bastard mafia closed setup but its standard mafia with no bastard in it and the paranoia kills people :p

This kinda happened in Aperture. I think someone was lynched because he claimed to be vanilla town, and the consensus was that there was no way VT's were in the game.

phagga

Switzerland2194 Posts

April 20 2012 05:34 GMT

#924

Yay, my second win

GG all, it was fun. I was kinda scared last night when I went to bed and saw the sniper kitties, but as it seems today Forumite was just messing with us. Also nice to see that the lynch-plan worked out.

Thanks a lot to Forumite and Dirkzor for hosting!

Oh, and Hassybaby, there was no need to protect me, noone kills me in mafia games anway

4/5 endgames reached!

Drazerk

United Kingdom31255 Posts

April 20 2012 07:17 GMT

#925

I believe I called them ignoring the dead peoples win cons

phagga

Switzerland2194 Posts

April 20 2012 08:14 GMT

#926

Drazerk, I think it would have been impossible to incorporate your Wincon into the situation. And I think noone wanted to ignore one of the living to fullfill the wincon of a dead player.

Forumite, was BagManager actually a smurf? and if so, who was it?

Hassybaby

United Kingdom10823 Posts

April 20 2012 09:41 GMT

#927

On April 20 2012 14:34 phagga wrote:
Yay, my second win

Oh, and Hassybaby, there was no need to protect me, noone kills me in mafia games anway

4/5 endgames reached!

Maybe, but with BagManager dead really early, it was basically you

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

April 20 2012 10:06 GMT

#928

Dirkzor

Denmark1944 Posts

April 20 2012 10:50 GMT

#929

Was a pleassure hosting for you. A shame the SK's sucked

i Think free pm and hidden voting would work great forthe players... But would be boring for the hosts

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

April 20 2012 10:52 GMT

#930

Didn't really enjoy this setup from an observer point of view but looks like all the players had a lot of fun

Bluelightz

Indonesia2463 Posts

April 20 2012 11:08 GMT

#931

if there was a real scum and town this game i wouldnt of got shot. EVER.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

April 20 2012 13:11 GMT

#932

On April 20 2012 19:52 Barundar wrote:
Didn't really enjoy this setup from an observer point of view but looks like all the players had a lot of fun

That´s what I felt playing Cosmic Horror Mafia, so much was going on with my play, and the Horror-Mafia interaction, that was never shown in the thread.

Full PMs would have worked well, but then I and Dirkzor wouldn´t have anything fun to read. Masons might have worked, I guess.

strongandbig

United States4858 Posts

April 20 2012 15:53 GMT

#933

I just want to point out how ridiculous my position was when I got shot.

My wincon was for myself, Macheji, Cyber_Cheese, or Sbrubbles to survive until endgame.

After the second day, CC had probably killed Macheji; Macheji had called CC out on being an SK, for which he got lynched; and Sbrubbles shot me. Worst teamwork ever.

And yet through my immense amount of skill and perseverance, I managed to win this game

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

April 20 2012 16:35 GMT

#934

Well, at that point we weren't sure of the setup and in most setups survivor is anti-town. You practically claimed survivor (with a chance of being scum).

Sbrubbles

Brazil5776 Posts

April 20 2012 19:49 GMT

#935

Oh, and who was smurfing as Bagmanager?

Cyber_Cheese

Australia3615 Posts

April 20 2012 23:35 GMT

#936

On April 20 2012 20:08 Bluelightz wrote:
if there was a real scum and town this game i wouldnt of got shot. EVER.

Basically this.
Drazerk wouldn't have checked me night one (I hope he wouldnt anyway)

I had a kill on every second night, nightly if VE died. I only had to be one of the final 3.
With real scum/town, I was basically the worst lynch candidate day 2.