|
On April 08 2012 02:53 Nova_Terra wrote:Show nested quote +On April 08 2012 01:30 era wrote:On April 08 2012 01:18 LazinCajun wrote:On April 08 2012 01:11 era wrote:On April 08 2012 00:03 BlueyD wrote:
Aye, time to put out a vote.
My case against Gossemerr hasn't gotten any better, and standards are higher on day 2 than on day 1. What I have is insufficient for me to vote for him.
---
Bocki's defense against my lastest attack is decent, though no more. What he says (didn't post his case because he thought it was a bit weak, wanted it to be stronger before he did and got rushed into it) is plausible. His vote for me feels a bit like an OMGUS, but it does seem plausible that I would have been his best read already, with the whole Gossemerr thing I seem to be the only one to be getting.
---
era's play is maddeningly unchanging. He's tunneling, short-posting and WIFOMing all over the place, even after people have pointed it out. The only question is: Horrible townie, or horrible mafia? It is my opinion that a horrible town would at least learn to be less awful after a few days, and actually help the town in some way. This guy hasn't. The one insight he got (and I have difficulty thinking it was really his), he actually dismissed.
##Vote:era
---
I want to congratulate LazinCajun for posting a very convincing connection case. I took a quick look at therapist and era's filters and in my opinion it support the case as well. I'll do a deeper analysis if era turns up scum. Really, you find a connection case that's based on me and therapist posting 3 minutes apart convincing? Lazin himself says that we posted 40 minutes before the deadline which is when everyone would usually be on and voting. Why are you trying to use Lazins "convincing" case to try to get me lynched? I think you are panicking because you are scum. Oh man. Almost none of his reasoning is based on my post, but rather your posting. You're not defending what he was accusing you of. Theres not much to defend, i do post a lot of WIFOM trying not to do that as much. Blueyd asks if im a horrible townie or a horrible mafia? I am obviously a bad townie, this is my first game, Im sure I will player better in my next game. Also it might seem like i am tunneling BlueyD but hes the most suspicious in my book, I am trying to find mafia not accuse 5 different people. Sure, in this case there might not be much to defend, but once again everything i said earlier stands. you cant get out of it with an i'm new excuse. You have not adequately defended any of that, nor have you started posting content after. Therefore, my vote on you stands. I think you are more likely to be mafia than bluey simply because he tries to defend himself adequately and does post his own non-wifom analysis. we get information either way, i guess, but still, i feel that era is the best lynch.
Your main accusation is that i use WIFOM, which is your accusation for almost everyone, it seems like thats the only analysis you ever bring to the table. WIFOM is not always bad and can be useful. I do agree that I use it too much I dont know how you want me to defend myself?
I also posted about blueyD which somewhat got ignored, which is not WIFOM.
"Gossemerr, I'm being attacked for making jokes now, really? I'll tell you, there's two reasons I'm making jokes. First... it's fun! Second... I wanted to see who jumped on them to try to make a case look better than it is. Grats, you did."
I don't think that his jokes is just flavor. He makes jokes because he wants people to accuse him? Why would he want this? Its a total waste of time and makes no sense if hes a townie. If he is scum it allows him to discredit accusations and gain town favor while doing it. Ill admit its a risky strategy for a mafia since hes putting attention on him. I still find him suspicious.
Lastly Nova is always defending blueyd, so much that sometimes blueyd doesnt even have to defend himself he can just sit back and relax. Why are you so keen on defending blueyd?
|
Why do something that will confuse people in the first place? Trying to confuse people is not a townie thing to do. You are puosefully trying to make it harder to find mafia.
|
"I wanted to see who would jump on them to try to make a case look better thank it is" you want people to accuse you, dismiss it because you were just joking. Wasting time and confusing people.
|
On April 08 2012 04:32 Gossemerr wrote:
Okay, I'm going to be honest: I don't have a solid read on anyone after reading the entire thread. BlueyD is at least posting content and is logical. I still think he is suspicious but his defense is pretty good, minus the joke defense. I feel like Blocki, therapist, lazin, and era are on the same level of content after Nova and BlueyD (imo I am somewhere in the middle of the pacts). era is still pounding the joke thing, after I felt like I had said enough on that matter. I don't want to lose the contribution of BlueyD for now until I can prove with more persuasion that he is scum.
##Unvote: BlueyD
##Vote: era
So your voting for me, even though you find Blueyd more suspicious, just because you don't want to lose his contribution. Good to known next time I play mafia all I have to do is post a lot and I wont get lynched. You guys are gonna end up lynching a townie, and further decrease your chance of winning. Gossemerr caused lyter to get lynched and now hes gonna get another townie lynched.
|
|
|
The post just before he says that he finds blueyd more suspicious, your right next post he says we are equally suspicious but blueyd contributes more so hes voting for me. I am making a helpful contribution, i am trying to find mafia. You on the other hand are busy trying to lynch townies for not contributing. This game is not about lynching people who don't contribute, this game is about finding and lynching mafia. I gotta go eat really fast, will post more when I get back, if I dont make it in time, you will see that you lynched a townie and just made it easier for mafia to win.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
