C9++ Mini Mafia - Page 6

On March 22 2012 08:19 Probulous wrote:
VE I don't understand your case. I am scum because I didn't think you were mafia after you voted for Jackal?

What is wrong with my reasoning because it still makes sense to me?Votes > words in my opinion. Explain this to me because I am completely at a loss as to why this makes me scum. I am town and have followed the same logic I use every game so if there is something fundamentally wrong in my thinking, point it out. Otherwise I am going to get mis-lynched again.

Does everyone else understand what VE is saying?

On March 22 2012 10:11 Probulous wrote:


You

"Jackal is clearly town"

TIPD

"Jackal always lurks Day 1 and this is scummy"

Big difference in my mind.

On March 22 2012 10:30 Probulous wrote:
Ok let me explain that quote nice and simply because obviously I am not making myself clear.

here (Klicky) they say this



Which says what exactly? That Jackal typically looks scummy? How is that not a soft-defense? They are saying he looks scummy most of the time. His lurking is "typically" scummy so why should they vote for him.

If they thought he was scummy they would have said "Jackal looks scummy", not that he typically looks scummy. That word changes the whole meaning of the sentence.

Then four people vote for him and suddenly it becomes this (Klicky)


Which can be summed up as "Jackal has been useless". How is this not his "typically" scummy play? I'll tell you how, four other people have started a wagon that's how.

On March 22 2012 09:52 Probulous wrote:
The only thing going for TIPD right now is their vote on Jackal. It was pretty early (5th vote) and most people who voted for him seemed to bandwagon sandroba. I could easily see them being bussing Jackal to avoid suspicion today. I am more comfortable with a slOosh lynch because of his unvote, but if he is getting let off (why?) than TIPD is our lynch target today.