EPTJudging from that you asked what PR is, I don't assume that you have one.
Newbie Mini Mafia V - Page 14
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
blubbdavid
Switzerland2412 Posts
Judging from that you asked what PR is, I don't assume that you have one. | ||
|
OtoshimonoU
United States509 Posts
On March 05 2012 07:22 blubbdavid wrote: Power roles. Like DT, medic and so on. By claiming a PR it would make people hesitate to kill him, it would be a last ditch attempt to save his ass. Judging from that you asked what PR is, I don't assume that you have one. Oops. Thank you. DT=detective? | ||
|
DimmuKlok
United States225 Posts
That is correct. | ||
|
DimmuKlok
United States225 Posts
OtoshimonoU, what is your read on Sufficiency? Also, who is your top scum read right now and why? | ||
|
OtoshimonoU
United States509 Posts
On March 05 2012 08:27 DimmuKlok wrote: GG Mementoss, it's been fun. OtoshimonoU, what is your read on Sufficiency? Also, who is your top scum read right now and why? Can't understand his point of view at all. No top scum read. | ||
|
Maverick32x
United States311 Posts
| ||
|
EchelonTee
United States5244 Posts
| ||
|
Sufficiency
Canada23833 Posts
| ||
|
blubbdavid
Switzerland2412 Posts
| ||
|
Pablols
Chile517 Posts
| ||
|
Maverick32x
United States311 Posts
We have WAY too many Lurkers right now... I would love to say/think that everyone who is lurking is Mafia, but obviously that is impossile. There are people making votes with little or no explanation of why they are voting. Lets go through the list!(Just because I know how much Brubbles hates this) 1. )gunman103 Filter @I think that you're on the right track, and I follow a lot of your logic. (Suspecting Brubbles and Oto...) You've been able to post a decent amount, but I'd really like to try to get another person in here who actually is actively making reads. 3.) Rainmaker5 Filter Lurker. Barely any posts. Can't even get a good read off this guy. Was active-ish at the start, hasn't posted much since. 4.) Pablols Filter Makes me a bit nervous- he was adament that Mementoss was scum, yet he obviously isn't. I get how he got to this conclusion however, especially with the mis-qoutes and things like that... I will 100% agree that sufficiency is on my list. I'm still not sure if he is just bad town, or if he is scum... Either way, I'd really like to focus on him after Day 2.... 5.) willz22912 Filter (replaced Tiystus) @ I agree that Oto is kind of a strange situation. I defintely get that he may of "just given up", but he really has done nothing to defend himself actively. One of the reasons why I think he is scum is because the vote didn't go through on Day 1. We were 1 vote away, yet we couldn't manage to get that? I feel like if he WAS town, scum would be eager to throw their votes behind him. If he ends up being town, I think our next list of suspects would be anyone that voted for him. If he flips mafia, we have a gold mine of information and will be able to narrow down who is scum relatively easily. 6.) DimmuKlok Filter Another person who was active prior to the Mementoss kill. Its unclear where you are at in all of this. It sounds like you want the conversations to pick up, but not much else beyond that. One thing that kind of makes me feel like you're town is that you were willing to seperate yourself from Mementoss as having a unique thought- I feel like if you were scum you would want to allign yourself with him as much as possible, but you're clearly willing to state your own opinion and not bandwagon.... 7.) Sufficiency Filter Accusing people of nothing. Never explaining your position. Claiming you know roles... what a mess.... 8.) Sbrubbles Filter(replaced friedchicken) His lack of vote resulted in a no-lynch situation. If Oto turns out to be Mafia, this is your next target without a doubt in my mind. If Oto is not mafia, then Brubbles is 100% town. 10.) trackd00r Filter Seems okay. Nothing too revolutionary in the posts, but accurate in my opinion. You recognized that mafia killed off one of the more active players to slow down activity, we need to realize that, and be ACTIVE. 11.) OtoshimonoU Filter We need to vote this guy. The information will be extremely helpful regardless of if he is scum or town. He has dodged everything we've thrown at him and hasn't been active at all. Again with my other point, if he WAS town, mafia would of voted him off with the lynch. 12.) blubbdavid Filter(replaced beorn1) You were able to craft one of the detailed posts in terms of why we need to lynch Oto, and that is awesome. Keep up the good work!!! ALSO, if Blubb ends up being town, I think its interesting to see the votes that randomly got thrown at him from sufficiency.... In conclusion: We need to lynch Oto or we will not make progress. | ||
|
blubbdavid
Switzerland2412 Posts
| ||
|
Maverick32x
United States311 Posts
| ||
|
DimmuKlok
United States225 Posts
| ||
|
Sbrubbles
Brazil5776 Posts
Anyway, Maverick, here's a good way for you to make your case and try to convince me and the rest who still haven't voted: + Show Spoiler + On March 06 2012 01:54 Maverick32x wrote: 11.) OtoshimonoU Filter We need to vote this guy. The information will be extremely helpful regardless of if he is scum or town. He has dodged everything we've thrown at him and hasn't been active at all. Again with my other point, if he WAS town, mafia would of voted him off with the lynch. Explain to us how you plan to use this information. I've already given my opinion on the issue: + Show Spoiler + On March 04 2012 00:49 Sbrubbles wrote: 1) If Otoshi ends up being mafia, there may be mafia among Pablols, Tiystus and Beorn. Then again, they may just have been townies who just forgot about the voting, thought the case was weak (like me) or refused to bandwagon. 2) If Otoshi ends up being town, we can be almost 100% sure Pablols, Tiystus, and Beorn are also town. Then again, they may have been mafia who just forgot about the voting or the mafia among them decided to not vote for Otoshi in order to build trust with the town. Still, I find both these alternatives very unlikely because a) being mafia (or a town PR, for that matter) is more exiting, so if you're gonna lurk you're gonna do it on purpose and sure as hell you aren't gonna miss a mandatory vote, risking a modkill and b) the mafia avoiding a free lynching to build up town cred is a weak idea at this point of the game. which is to say there's not much gained from him being mafia. I believe that if there's a better case for lynching him, we can always do it tommorow, or can have the detective check him for us (which I had hoped he would this night, but apparently he didn't). I was honestly hoping our detective would have something to spurn the discussion today. Of course, there's an actual possibility that there is no detective in this game, but that would be a little strange. For now, as for the vote itself, I'm voting for our resident lurker Rainmaker. Beorn, who came out of the closet after transforming into blubbdavid, seems to be posting at least. | ||
|
Maverick32x
United States311 Posts
As for how I plan to use this information? If Oto turns out to be Mafia. Sufficiency and you will likely be mafia. Both of you side tracked the last vote to keep him alive.... If he turns out to be town- Sufficiency and you are likely to be town. Myself, trackd00r and rainmaker should be looked at as highly suspicious for encouraging the vote. | ||
|
blubbdavid
Switzerland2412 Posts
1) willz22912 + Show Spoiler + Defending oto, pointing finger on Suff. He has done some good analysis. his predecessor tiystius also posted somewhat decently leaning on green for me 2) gunman + Show Spoiler + pushing against Oto because of similar reasons like me, also FOS'ing pablols a bit. Also suggest lynching (useless) lurkers instead one of the more active townies. leaning on green 3) Rainmaker + Show Spoiler + I am not sure about him. Will think about him after he posted the analysis he has promised us. 4) Pablols + Show Spoiler + He has been more active than others, but is suffering on the OMGUS syndrome. Accused Mementoss. Other reads are Suff and Mav. Retracts read on mementoss because of misquoting (?). I am not really sure about it, that could just be scum tactics. Then pushes against suff, but finally votes for Oto. He's on my watchlist. 5) Maverick + Show Spoiler + Most active player till now, encouraging other players. I don't think I have to say much about him, I am pretty sure that he is town. The only downside on him is that he surely is pretty high on scums blacklist. I hope we have a medic, and if we have one, then I hope he knows what he does. 6) Dimmuklok + Show Spoiler + He's pretty fast in voting, but he wants to generate discussion with his actions. He is pretty much acting on his own, not bandwagoning. But I want to see especially see his opinion on the other players. Particularly what he thinks about Rainmaker now. 7) trackdoor + Show Spoiler + As Mav said, he has some pretty good logic. He has the same views on Suff and Oto like me. He is a useful poster, somewhat [green]greenish[/]. 8) Sbrubbles + Show Spoiler + Ha, he's pushing against Mav. But isn't consequent and votes for Rainmaker out of the blue.His alignment on depends what Oto will flip, as Mav said. | ||
|
OtoshimonoU
United States509 Posts
| ||
|
Sbrubbles
Brazil5776 Posts
On March 06 2012 04:57 blubbdavid wrote: 8) Sbrubbles + Show Spoiler + Ha, he's pushing against Mav. But isn't consequent and votes for Rainmaker out of the blue.His alignment on depends what Oto will flip, as Mav said. Don't take my vote as inconsequential. Rain hasn't posted anything since day 1 even that was meh in terms of productiveness. Lurkers are prime suspects on my book, and Rain is the quietest of them all. | ||
|
trackd00r
Chile284 Posts
I'm posting some final analysis soon. | ||
| ||
