You need me here because I'm up for lynch and I'm a big part of the opposition to that. I think that if I weren't here, then there would be a bigger chance of me getting lynched which is not in town's best interest.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 18:49 GMT

#602

Off the top of my head, BloodyC0bbler is the one who looks most scummy to me. sylllogism, DoctorHelvetica and myself have made posts on him and I like those posts. Since we have dropped the BloodyC0bbler lynch I think that Blazinghand is a good lynch for town, especially if I'm the alternative.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 18:52 GMT

#606

I also think that Jackal58 is being weird with his insistence on the possibility of several scum factions (ludicrous), his flip flopping on redFF (town redFF wouldn't think Jackal58 is a good scum hunter is a terrible argument, saying that we shouldn't lynch redFF anyway because Palmar will take care of him. What the fuck, you lynch scummy bastards you don't just expect them to get modkilled because they didn't talk for a day). Also, his Toadesstern tunneling looked very weird since I think we were beyond the more randomy initial phase when he started that. I don't care that he was drunk.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 18:54 GMT

#608

If BloodyC0bbler is a possiblity then I'm more up for that than anything else. I'm a little unsure of him but he's a ton better than lynching me. You can say that I am flip flopping, trying frantically to stay alive and that's true. When you're up for lynch then you would lynch anybody else (maybe besides syllogism who I think should be medic/jailed tonight).

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 18:56 GMT

#610

Like, I think BloodyC0bbler is scummy but I'm always kinda unsure about my reads (because, allegedly, I'm bad). Sometimes I just fake it but I'm not doing that in this game because that wouldn't help on this crowd anyway.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 19:01 GMT

#614

On February 23 2012 03:58 Blazinghand wrote:

Show nested quote +

Ah yes waffle more

Be an asshole who is terrible at this game some more. Which is better?

I'm not waffling, I'm saying that I want to lynch BloodyC0bbler over anybody else. Being insecure about your read when you're accusing BloodyC0bbler is just common sense more than anything else. I heard that BloodyC0bbler is good at scum and this seems a bit easy, but then again he is good at town too. I have no idea why he's acting like this but bottom line is that it's scummy.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 19:34 GMT

#617

Actually, Jackal58 looks terrible. Those points I just mentioned, his weird defense of me (it was a meta-y defense and I don't think I looked anything like I usually do), saying that syllogism is a better lynch than me which is just crazy considering the information he had available. This post which is guilty of the same thing we're accusing BloodyC0bbler of, complaining about thread without providing an alternative direction.

The only thing that speaks in Jackal58's defense is that it's usually hard to distinguish his scum from his town play. I'm easily more willing to lynch Jackal58 today than redFF.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 19:39 GMT

#618

redFF didn't ragequit, he said yesterday that he wouldn't have a lot of time to post today and said that he would claim early because of this. He was obviously quite pissed at the situation but that's somewhat understandable. That doesn't change the fact that you lynch scummy people and don't just count on them being modkilled. He could be replaced and stuff. You lynch people you think are likely to be scum, right?

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 20:24 GMT

#625

syllogism, you said you'd look at other people, was I the only one you would consider? I really doubt that BloodyC0bbler is going to attract enough votes don't you think there are other alternatives that are more likely to flip scum than redFF and more likely to pick up enough votes than BloodyC0bbler?

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 20:28 GMT

#631

wherebugsgo was actually flip floppy on me. He called be bad and then he said "So far your reactions haven't made you look that great.", I assume he was talking about my alignment. So he doesn't really know if I'm bad or scum I think.

wherebugsgo kitaman27 chaoser BloodyC0bbler DoctorHelvetica are missing from this thread very close to deadline which isn't all too great.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 21:00 GMT

#649

He claimed vigilante in Reponsibility Mafia! too, and he was a vigilante in that game.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 21:25 GMT

#678

I agree with Toadesstern and Jackal58 on Blazinghand.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 21:58 GMT

#738

Rofl wherebugsgo.

Are you trying to say something about my alignment based on another player's alignment?

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 22:03 GMT

#753

Same here VisceraEyes.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 22 2012 22:04 GMT

#755

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 23 2012 15:48 GMT

#828

My first scum game? That was Surprisingly Normal Mini Mafia IV like ages ago, how the hell do you remember that?

Anyway, Jackal58, you says I sound like I do when I'm town but that's no reason to say that you would lynch syllogism over me. It would be a reason if you additionally thought that I don't sound like I do when I'm scum, or if syllogism sounds like he's scum. You also spent all Hammer Mini Mafia calling random people town for hardly any reason.

I think it's somewhat unlikely that BloodyC0bbler is scum or else the wagon would have met some serious resistance at 5 BloodyC0bbler to 7 redFF I think, and some other reasons. It didn't, instead Blazinghand decided to switch from redFF to BloodyC0bbler in a very weird post. This sudden "Wow, that's so true" is weird because the arguments that VisceraEyes presents are the exact same as have been posted in the thread a few times before. It seems like a bad excuse to change his vote. Going through his past games, I haven't seen him act like this a single time.

I think it's weird that scum didn't just pile onto a town BloodyC0bbler though, if they could hide the flip anyway.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 23 2012 17:23 GMT

#832

Dunno, 3rd party seems kind of silly in a small setup like this. Anything that hides flips is scum favored. All of that is speculation though, the setup could just hide flips on day1 or redFF could have a role that would make him survive lynch (I believe there was a "runner" role or something like that in one of the Pick Your/Their Powers). Anyway, all of this is meaningless setup speculation and we should probably do like we did in Hammer Mini Mafia, just go look for other scum as if this was day1.

Some other reasons, such as how I think he genuinely seemed angry with how he was getting pushed.

You can discard it as WIFOM, but fact is that BloodyC0bbler as town will pose a bigger threat to a scum team than redFF as town. If they have the opportunity to avoid most of the heat they would get from piling onto him then I have a hard time seeing why they wouldn't do that. But this is all setup speculation and I should probably be spending my time on something else.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 23 2012 19:11 GMT

#837

Sounds about right.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 24 2012 00:19 GMT

#931

I don't think that a team of 4 can be so inactive that they forget to send in night hits. 2KP seems reasonable and maybe they can swap 1KP for a flip concealment and the other hit into veteran/medic'd/jailer'd person. That isn't too far fetched but it's speculative.

I think you're somewhat right on how scum hasn't been very active so far. I like RebirthOfLeGenD for now.

##Vote: RebirthOfLeGenD