|
On January 09 2012 12:21 bkrow wrote:Cats what convinces you about Blurry being scum? I am reading through his filter and the scummiest thing i have come across is him advocating a no lynch on day 1 - but he seemed to go back on that idea later on. He also voted for Sheth straight up (from what i can see) and with such little KP it would be hard to see him doing that without some sort of indecision. Sorry if i am rehashing old stuff i am just catching up still; i think we should be looking at: a) people who were hesitant to vote Sheth b) those who tried to offer alternate targets but once Sheth came up jumped on the "bandwagon" and c) the lurkers  who make me angry
Those are places to start, but things like that aren't bonafide 100% scum tells.
|
On January 09 2012 14:46 CatsnHats wrote:
Yeah I think Sheth new he could take me down with him I've screwed myself over so bad with my wishy-washy save myself play. Smart play on his part.
You're on the grid for a lot more reasons than bad wishy-washy save you played.
|
On January 10 2012 02:50 blubbdavid wrote:
God, reading Mafia makes me paranoid.
Why?
|
On January 10 2012 06:46 Probulous wrote:How cursed are we? It has been 20 hours since replacement and kronhjort hasn't posted and all that Paperscraps has posted is a couple of welcome lines and Show nested quote +"I seem to be leaning a bit toward scum on blurry and xeris (kronhjort). I can't stay up too late tonight due to school in the morning. I plan on providing some analysis and reads tomorrow." @Ceph, I am still waiting on your reads. @Jitsu I am assuming you are sticking with Cats and Blurry?
Definitely staying with Cats right now. I think that whole mass-shenanigans at the end of last night was to try to buy Cats some towncred. Sheth telling Cats to just vote switch to him? And Cats apologizing for doing it? Come on guys. Clearly an act. I'm definitely not buying it. After I pressured Sheth, I went back and read the interactions between them. It's just screaming at me. What was he willing to contribute? He was adamant in not voting for Sheth until the very end, when Sheth told him to vote for him in the post.
As for Blurry; I don't think so. I've read through his filter again (an astounding one page!!) just now and, while not very enlightening and helpful, hasn't really acted anti-town. I said that post last night because I was under the impression that was just bandwagon lynching, but I think it's just newbie play. That being said - he needs to post. He's still lurking, he's just also voting.
Going over filters now. I would like to hear from the new lurkers, especially Hippo's replacement (whoever he is).
|
@Probu:
Bah, fuck you're faster keyboard APM. =/
|
At this point, I think we can call Xeris/Gretorp new players - the previous lack of effort certainly wasn't able to give me enough information to determine their role, except MAYBE Gretorp.
Maybe.
That being said, I really hope that these guys stop lurking.
|
On January 10 2012 07:40 CatsnHats wrote:
@Jitsu If I had flipped to vote Sheth you all would have just called me out for bandwaggoning again, so I decided to stick to my decision, even though I was in the minority. Obviously I was wrong about Sheth, but I switched from Gretorp to CM/AKCT last time and you called me out for bandwaggoning. Really though that's a situation where I'm fucked either way. If I change my vote, I must be mafia bandwaggoning. If I don't (like I did), I must be mafia defending a scumbuddy. I don't see how you can get a read on me from that.
If you posted a reason why you voted for Sheth, other than he told you to, and that reason made sense - I don't think you would have been accused of bussing.
However, this is all conjecture. It's already history.
|
Meh, I started pressing on Hippo earlier, so there isn't any reason to start again now. Especially since, after Cats, there are many question marks.
Bkrow, i'd like to see some posts in you're name. Add to the discussion. What do you think of Cats right now? you must have read the majority of the thread by now. What are some of you're scum reads?
|
|
|
I was actually a little bit curious about Gonz's posts. Check his filter.
|
|
|
|
|
GG.
Really appreciate GreY and Risk hosting this game. Takes a lot of time of them NOT playing, so it's a bonus to have two experienced guys modding the show.
@Grey/Risk - Thanks for hosting the game! Was a lot of fun.
|
On January 15 2012 10:43 Blazinghand wrote:Show nested quote +On January 15 2012 10:37 GreYMisT wrote:
Jitsu wins the Observer betting show I feel, in very close second place in Tunkeg and Blazinghand.
Man Jitsu you win this time mr obs betting guy :/I must say that was well played by mafia and most of town. I'm particularly impressed with Probulous' game. I fear and anticipate meeting you in future games.
Too bad I couldn't actually accomplish anything in the game, other than getting suspicious of Sheth right before Probulous came out with his analysis, and saying "gonzaw" right before I died.
Again. Sigh.
|
It's usually not revealed who the coaches we're coaching, AFAIK
|
On January 15 2012 12:39 Probulous wrote:I got suspicious when you refused to actually answer anything. You just started swearing and calling stuff WIFOM. It may have been WIFOM but it was hardly a defence. I was sure but I was dead, so it didn't matter I am not the best at persuading others. Look at my case against Sheth, it makes no sense. I ended up pleading with people. The fact that all three scum voted for him to be killed just shows how bad the lurkers fucked us over. Anyway, well played. I put a lot of effort into this game and would have liked a win, but I can say that town as a whole was outplayed.
Seconded. =(
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
