If we had Dirkzor claim first, if he wasn't actually corrupted and cleansed, claiming it would be betting on nobody else claiming it, which would be very risky indeed, so had he claimed it and nobody counter-claimed, we could reasonably assume he was telling the truth. Now if he claims it, it won't tell us much of anything.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 19 2012 18:00 GMT

#2443

So here's what I'm going to do. I'm going to flip a coin. If it is heads, I illuminate Blazinghand, if it is tails I illuminate Bluelightz. I will not call my shot. After night ends, Bluelightz will say whether or not he was cleansed. If his call doesn't match up with my action, we lynch him. This means if he is an angel, this plan has a 50% chance to reveal him as scum, if he is actually corrupted town, he will call it correctly every time.

Sound good?

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 19 2012 18:10 GMT

#2445

@All
Don't forget to PM Zona if you would like to end the night early rather than waiting the extra 24 hours.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 19 2012 18:28 GMT

#2446

On January 19 2012 23:23 Zephirdd wrote:
HOWEVER, HoD. I want you to illuminate Bluelightz tonight. Reason is simple: my mind if wifoming hard over you, and if you illuminate him and he confirms that he was illuminated, we confirmed you both. Yes I know I should be trusting you by now, but my mind is a whirlpool over you atm. And it's not like you have any other use for your move either; Refallen is confirmed DH anyway. Simple workaround over you two.

I'm sticking to my plan.

But consider this to help ease your mind, the angel of death can only detect a twisting if their kill fails. The observer can obviously detect a twisting if observing fails, and the acolyte can only detect it if they knew their kill should work but it failed. At the end of night 3, I called that layabout was twisted within 2 minutes of the day post, and the angel of death kill went through. We already know 100% that the observer is dead. So for me to be an angel, I would either need to be the acolyte and somehow been sure he was a demon at that time, or another angel would have to read their PM from the night, inform me in some way, and then I would have to post the twisted claim, all within 2 minutes. Or I would have had to guess and hope for the best, along with correctly guessing that dirkzor and grackaroni were not demons.

Or I'm just the goddamn sage.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 19 2012 18:52 GMT

#2448

Possibly something of note here?

On January 08 2012 14:26 Zephirdd wrote:
Why care about lynch during night

Palmar seems fairly scummy to me since his last post(or few posts fdunno) so he shoul be shot or lynched. also Jackal seesm bad, but i always think that be is sum no matter what game and alignment so meh. dunno im too bdrubnk to think about that.

Do we think he'd have the presence of mind to soft-bus a teammate while drunk?

Not terribly relevant, but just thought I would highlight this:

On January 06 2012 11:14 Refallen wrote:
Furthermore, if Palmar flips red I think we should definitely go after Tyrran next.

Refallen too good~

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 19 2012 19:11 GMT

#2450

Yes...and Jackal was an angel. "also Jackal seesm bad"

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 19 2012 22:55 GMT

#2453

On January 20 2012 07:46 Refallen wrote:

Show nested quote +

Didn't trust my read and still went with hitting cwave and spaackle though =(

It's ok. With so few people listening to my case combined with the craziness Tyrran was spewing I backed off my read on him too :-(

You're stabbing Dirkzor, yes? And everyone is ending night early I hope? I'm impatient.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 20 2012 01:09 GMT

#2462

...so how's everyone doing? -_-

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 20 2012 01:33 GMT

#2465

On January 20 2012 10:18 Blazinghand wrote:
oh, not bad. I'm vaguely considering the possibility that the acolyte is alive and has been holding fire. would that be possible?

Possible, yes, but I think it is unlikely. If they were I don't know why they wouldn't have targetted you last night with the acolyte, and then anyone else with the angel of death...then somebody should have woken up dead besides layabout. On the off chance the acolyte is still alive, we'll need dirkzor to be an angel, and then to lynch correctly twice in a row.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 20 2012 07:33 GMT

#2471

+ Show Spoiler +

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 20 2012 07:42 GMT

#2473

Aww, you ruined the fun.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 20 2012 20:08 GMT

#2476

Posting because the game was yellow. Active games shouldn't be yellow.

(And nights shouldn't be 47.5 hours T_T)

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 20 2012 21:50 GMT

#2478

I know why it happened, I just want to get on with it.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 21 2012 03:05 GMT

#2549

Bluelightz is correct, I illuminated him last night. (The result was "not demon", if anyone was curious :-P)

Lynching Grack today? Lynching Grack today.

##Vote: Grackaroni

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 21 2012 03:08 GMT

#2550

My reasoning on Bluelightz being town:
Layabout was arguing with me before he died that Bluelightz was town, Bluelightz was also not likely to be night killed by the angel of death, nor was he the main focus of Refallen. Therefore, I find it likely that the demons would have picked him to corrupt. Nobody else counter-claimed the corruption, and he correctly answered whether he was cleansed or not.

If Grackaroni isn't it, I have no issues lynching Zephirdd tomorrow.

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 21 2012 03:24 GMT

#2554

Hooray!

HarbingerOfDoom

United States508 Posts

January 21 2012 03:42 GMT

#2565

I tried to investigate scum the first three nights in a row, but only 2 of the three were demons, and only one investigation returned a result (the non-demon T_T)

@Zephirdd
Had we not lynched Jackal that day, it wouldn't have really mattered as long as we got some form of scum lynched. He wasn't the acolyte or the angel of death. We thought we needed to hit an angel since we weren't sure if the acolyte was still alive as well, but since it was only 1 kp for the angels, any scum would have sufficed. And I was definitely willing to push a jackal case before too much longer. (And I even wrote up and posted a basic case for him that day)