Still making a post with some analysis and finger pointing as promised, but just a quick question first.

I'm going to be traveling and whatnot all over the place on thanksgiving...so after this next post and maybe another small post or two at some point tonight, I'm not really going to be able to post again till Friday morning CST. (I mean, I will have enough access to make posts during the day tomorrow, but I will not have the time necessary to do enough reading to make them useful in any way.) So yeah, just giving fair notice that I am probably only going to make one post tomorrow to avoid being replaced, and it probably won't be of much value. But on Friday I'll be back to regular posting.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 23 2011 23:58 GMT

#1947

Ok, so it wasn't a question so much as a statement.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 24 2011 00:41 GMT

#1952

Coagulation - Cute stunt earlier...not sure if it means he is scum, but he is definitely acting weird and has yet to be useful in my eyes. Candidate for lurker lynch should we still use them.
Cyber_Cheese - Could go either way on him, but any lynch movement on him would need some really solid reasoning to gain my support.
DCLXVI - I'm willing to believe he is town for now, but I'm not entirely done observing his actions.
Forumite - His voting alone is suspect, and with his actions in the thread, I'm leaning more and more scum on him every day. Possible lynch candidate.
GreYMisT - His voting isn't great, but I've had town feelings on him since early. Not ready to consider lynch on him just yet though.
RebirthOfLeGenD - Probably town, not particularly useful though so far. My opinion on him is incomplete as of right now.
Kibibit - Lurking, could support him as lurker lynch candidate, but I doubt he is scum, so I'd rather hold off for now.
Lanaia - Bad voting but I think town.
Lemonwalrus - I'm town.
Nisani201 - Probably scum. Willing to allow more time before voting for him, but currently plan to at end of day. Doubt anything more than a claim with something to back it up would stop me at this point.
Palmar - I've followed him most closely of all other players since the beginning of the game, and although at the beginning I thought he might be scum I am now certain he is not. His actions and votes have been in line with his reasoning and his reasoning has been some of the best in the thread.
Sabin010 - Lurker that feels scummy.
Tyrran - Very confident he is town at this point in time.
Zephirdd - Voting record bad, but not confident enough about it to lynch him.
bumatlarge - Feels scummy, but every argument I form for it falls apart to my own counterarguments. Idk.
MrZentor - So damn confused about this one.
hyshes - I find it so ridiculously unlikely that he is anything but town after Drazerk's flip that I'm willing to take it as an unquestionable truth at this point in time.
wherebugsgo - Parrots palmar a bit much, but I don't feel he is scummy, at least not right now.
xsksc - Post more? No good read on him atm.

Only put colors on ones that I was particularly confident of. Done for now.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 24 2011 00:44 GMT

#1954

Yeah, I had more to say on you but left it off. You parroted Palmar (if felt that way to me) on several things throughout the game, but as you can see I am confident Palmar is town so supporting him isn't necessarily bad in my eyes. Anyways, as I said, I don't see you as scummy, and someone would need a damn good case against you to get my vote on day 3.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 24 2011 16:52 GMT

#1990

Happy Thanksgiving! Probably won't post until tomorrow morning.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 25 2011 18:58 GMT

#2171

Town Rolecop

I can target one person a night and I receive a PM in the morning that tells me what their role is.

Night 1 I targeted Palmar and he is indeed the DT that can only check people he voted on like he said he is.
Night 2 I targeted Nisani201 and he returned no role. So he is either vanilla townie or vanilla scum, but you all killed him before I could weigh in so w/e.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 25 2011 19:19 GMT

#2177

Ok so at this point, it seems that everyone has gone mad in this thread. I'm just going to throw out a bunch of votes. If these all go through I think we would get more scum than town.

Forumite, I don't believe your claim, and assuming the voting thread is correct, I'm going to be the vote that lynches you. Sorry if I'm wrong.

##Vote: Forumite

As for other votes...pretty much just the people that haven't claimed with modifications for who I really really think is town.
##Vote: Coagulation
##Vote: Kibibit
##Vote: MrZentor
##Vote: bumatlarge

I'm going to go ahead and put a prediction out that bum is the GF.
##Vote: Sabin010

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 25 2011 19:19 GMT

#2178

lol bum should have been under the prediction, not sabin

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 25 2011 19:22 GMT

#2179

The coag/kibibit vote was just because I don't want replacements.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 26 2011 20:57 GMT

#2319

This mass-claim was probably a bad idea, but I'm willing to be hopeful that we might still win somehow. I probably won't survive till morning.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 27 2011 06:49 GMT

#2364

So I definitely should have checked DCL last night but in an act of stupidity I put my check on WBG as a place holder then promptly fell asleep.

Good news....my results on WBG are confirmed by his flip...so at least we know my ability is calibrated correctly. :|

I'm actually shocked that I survived the night.

##Vote DCLXVI
##Vote Cyber_Cheese
##Vote Sabin010

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 27 2011 07:07 GMT

#2367

Seriously, if he flips town and his role pm confirms that he knew he was a miller I honestly think Palmar might come to my house and hurt me.

That being said I'm almost sure the three I voted for are scum. Can't really think of who the final one is though. I wanted to say bum, but his last vote doesn't fit with that. I think I'm going to take a long look at Zephirdd.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 28 2011 15:12 GMT

#2413

##Unvote: Sabin010

Two scum ought to be enough for us to survive the night and win tomorrow.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 29 2011 02:36 GMT

#2422

2 vs 5, we win as long as we can vote correctly tomorrow.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 29 2011 02:38 GMT

#2423

(unless the 2 of them can somehow make 3 kills tonight which I'm pretty sure isn't possible)

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 29 2011 04:07 GMT

#2427

A lynched scum grasping at straws last minute to force town to lynch their own. Nothing odd about that.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 29 2011 21:28 GMT

#2439

On November 30 2011 00:25 Palmar wrote:
lemon claimed a rolecop who checked me night one

I need to bullshit check that at some point.

I didn't breadcrumb (newbie mistake) but you can clearly see that day 1 I wanted you dead and then all of a sudden day 2 I was your biggest supporter (besides possibly WBG). When I saw you throwing votes every which way on top of your case on chaoser I thought you were scum, but once I knew how your role worked I #1, knew your role would be useless as scum, and #2, knew that you voting for more people just made your role that much better at night.

I have some plans that may help us tomorrow but I don't want to spill them till after the night kills because I don't want to give the mafia direction on who would be best to kill. Besides I'm sure everyone has some idea of what we need to do tomorrow at this point. Anyways, assuming I survive the night, I'm fine with being lynched tomorrow as long as we also lynch the remaining scum.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 29 2011 21:51 GMT

#2442

On November 30 2011 06:47 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

explain please, you knew this had nothing to do with me or my role at this point.

a joke?

Not a good one...but there you have it.

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 29 2011 21:53 GMT

#2443

To clarify, I had just talked to one of my friends about how playing mafia always made me super paranoid and had me doubting what people said even outside of the game. Like my gf makes me dinner and a voice in the back of my head is like "did this scum bitch just poison me?"

Lemonwalrus

United States5465 Posts

November 30 2011 03:16 GMT

#2468