Steamship Liquidia (TL Mafia 46) - Page 2

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 21 2011 17:18 GMT

#1597

I do not think you are mafia prplhz. Though I do think Palmar wants to see you flip town so he looks better.

##Vote Palmar
##Vote Nisani201
I would like to see both die tonight, but i highly doubt palmar will get lynched. I don't believe his claim of being protected, nor do I like the way he argues. His argument on chaoser was forced imo, and he tries too hard to lead the town.
I would write about nisani, but it would just be parroting wbg. Go read wbg's case on him, I agree with most of what he says in regards to nisani except the defending chaoser bit.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 00:00 GMT

#1683

I can confirm that I did visit tyrran last night, I wish you had roleclaimed that earlier prplhz. For what its worth I did not protect Palmar last night, leading me to doubt his claim
@harbringer
lots of things change when people flip, and i've been sick the past few days, so I have not put nearly as much effort in this game-day.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 00:12 GMT

#1693

@Palmar
Why do you keep refuting the possibility that one mafia may bus another? Consider the situation where both of you are mafia, nisani looks close to a lynch, so he distances himself from a teammate with an analysis against him. That seems perfectly reasonable to me.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 00:37 GMT

#1706

On November 22 2011 09:36 wherebugsgo wrote:
also I don't think any competent medic would ever protect prpl, so him actually truly claiming medic is thrown out the window. DCLXVI should die.

protect prplhz?

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 01:39 GMT

#1728

On November 22 2011 10:35 Nisani201 wrote:

Show nested quote +

I am inclined to believe this. His vote on both me and Palmar shows that he has an indifferent perspective on our conflicts. And as we all know, and indifferent perspective is a scum perspective.

##Vote: DCLXVI

The more you try to separate yourself from Palmar like this the more inclined I am to believe that you are both scum. I am not indifferent to your 'conflict', it is part of why I am voting for both of you.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 01:47 GMT

#1731

On November 22 2011 10:45 bumatlarge wrote:

Show nested quote +

You, Mr medic, please claim before night ends bro. Or at least just say there is another part to it so that you can force a shot or something.

i am not exactly a medic, but I function like one

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 02:01 GMT

#1737

Much better than a medic in some ways, but with a drawback to even it out, somewhat. I doubt Palmars claim because I don't think there is a third medic role

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 02:02 GMT

#1739

@rol
kenpachi is/was a medic, see the end of day 1 post for his full role

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 02:09 GMT

#1748

Have you read all of my posts?

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 02:10 GMT

#1750

lol you guys post fast, that was at rol

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 22 2011 02:12 GMT

#1753

On November 22 2011 11:10 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yes I have actually. I have read all the posts by several players.

then you should know that I did not protect Palmar last night

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 23 2011 02:17 GMT

#1816

I have indeed pressed that key a few times

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 23 2011 02:44 GMT

#1819

On November 23 2011 11:35 hyshes wrote:
Oh great my mate drazerk is dead.

Well i guess that 100% confirms you, if that's any condolence.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 23 2011 18:11 GMT

#1907

I'm not sure why voting fro drazerk was such a bad thing at the time. He admitted in the thread that he was purposely playing badly in order to bait reactions out of people. While I question his tactics I certainly cannot condemn anyone for voting for someone who tried to look as bad as possible.

On November 24 2011 00:42 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:

At the end of the day you can't ignore what mafia aganda is. Their goal is to kill as many of us as possible and while avoiding a suspect list is good if it means not killing people its a choice they probably won't make. To be honest I don't like the weird way you are trying to use this list. Why would you vote Chaoser/Bum when they aren't high in the +3 area. Seems strange. I can almost guarantee you among those 5 I mentioned there are a couple of scum. I would happily kill them all because its a good trade.

Anyone else want to contribute?
Zephirdd, Nisani, DCLXVI, Greymist, Cyber_cheese, Lanaia, Forumite
These 7, kill them all. I welcome analysis on them if anyone wants to do it.

I don't think voting off at least 3 people with power roles, likely blues, would be anything other than a mafia agenda: "Their goal is to kill off as many of us as possible." Is this really your best plan, to slaughter the remaining power roles? Neither of the lynches were hard for the mafia to push, I highly doubt each mafia needed to jump on both bandwagons.

##Vote RebirthOfLeGenD
##Vote Nisani201

I will hold off voting Palmar for now as I reconsider given last nights kills.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 24 2011 07:00 GMT

#1965

@lanaia
Well, we aren't doing so great now. Everyone wants to see some progress, if we can at least find one or two mafia we can try to gather the rest based on that. Slowly getting picked off while lynching blues isn't working, so we need to try something different. I don't advocate lynching that many people, but we should consider lynching more than 2 today as an option. I think that one or two of the biggest lurkers that voted on one of the day one bandwagons and prplhz should go along with the scummiest outspoken players, I will need to look over suspects for that tomorrow (from the subset of players below).

@RoL
Why are you voting for all 7 if you narrowed the list to 4? I think it's likely that 1, maybe 2 mafia are in the list, but I really don't think the mafia needed to assist the town much to lynch day one. Myself, I was over eager to vote for bad town play rather than scummy play, and I think other players did that. I realized that by day 2, but not everyone caught on and we lynched prplhz, but with more help from mafia that time I believe. It's much more likely that you will find mafia on one vote and not the other day 1, and on prplhz.

@bumatlarge
You can't forget the possibility that palmar might have been protected by another unclaimed medic, and I am not lying. Not something that I imagine happened, but people can explain not voting for either of us that way.

##Vote Palmar

Happy TG to those that celebrate it.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 25 2011 06:30 GMT

#2078

On November 25 2011 10:06 Forumite wrote:

Show nested quote +

I´m tired now, I´ll talk tomorrow.

@WBG
Yeah, I don´t trust my scumsenses right now. I saw yours and Tyrrans reaction to my fakevote on Palmar and immediately thought chainsaw defence. That´s should tell you a bit about how confident I am of finding scum right now.

What is wrong with suspecting Palmar? That seems to be how WBG plays, he attacked chaoser day 1 in response to the Palmar/chaoser argument.

I honestly do not see a reason for Nisani to attack Palmar if Palmar isn't scum. If nisani is town, he probably thinks Palmar is scum because the way he was treated and ignored by Palmar/WBG. If nisani is scum and he knows Palmar is town, he would not want to make Palmar look so pro town. However, if he knew Palmar was also scum, distancing himself from Palmar would be a good idea. Considering the way nisani has played so far I do not believe he thought deeper into this, leaving me still convinced Palmar is scum.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 26 2011 08:46 GMT

#2305

Why wouldn't you put lanaia as pretty much confirmed town? We have seen what her role can do and its seems to be the perfect town aligned counterpart to Coag's role. I cannot imagine there being 2 mafia magicians or whatever.

I think I will finish claiming in the morning. There is no point doing so now. I will advise detectives to not waste a check on me, I am a miller.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 26 2011 19:16 GMT

#2317

Why must you assume that every role works the same in this game as it does in others. I know I am a miller because that is part of my role. I would not claim miller if I was scum because of this response, I felt it was necessary to make the best out of our dts since their time is short.

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 26 2011 21:54 GMT

#2320

On November 27 2011 04:48 hyshes wrote:

Show nested quote +

Easy to say after you made the mistake..

I told you before there was a drawback to my role, this is it.

@WBG
Are you seriously still considering lynching lanaia tomorrow?

DCLXVI

United States729 Posts

November 27 2011 04:22 GMT

#2355

Both of the masons were frail? Sorry hyshes, I tried to save you.

I am a Town Miller Bodyguard, I take hits for one target person, I have 1 extra night life that can regenerate every third day.

Prev 1 2 3 Next All

Please or register to reply.

Steamship Liquidia (TL Mafia 46) - Page 2

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming