|
On November 26 2011 11:07 xsksc wrote:
Wait a sec, didn't Cyber_cheese claim town tracker?
Yes
On November 26 2011 11:10 wherebugsgo wrote:
aww man I liked the DT better. Oh well.
He did. He's a liar. Let's kill him tomorrow.
Zephirdd and Sabin should also die tomorrow.
It wasn't a lie.
On November 26 2011 11:24 xsksc wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:12 GreYMisT wrote:On November 26 2011 11:07 xsksc wrote:
Wait a sec, didn't Cyber_cheese claim town tracker? why so he did. He called it something different though, "town obsessive stalker" I think he has some sort of mafia tracker role. Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:03 Zona wrote:
Town Tracker
You were obsessed with a certain actor during your childhood, and ended up stalking this person whenever you could.
Kibibit's role sounds a lot like obsessive stalker, no? I'm guessing Cyber got a similar role pm, but as scum. His night 1 visit would make a LOT more sense if he is. I could totally be wrong here, I'm extremely tired. I'll give him a proper look tomorow morning.
Suffice it to say that the only things our role PM's had in common were town in the name and the tracker ability.
On November 26 2011 11:27 wherebugsgo wrote:
yep!
There's only 6 players who didn't vote Coag. One of them is hyshes, who is confirmed town. Another one is Lanaia, who voted Sabin. A third is xsksc, who claimed a doctor role,
This means the scumteam is most likely to be GreYMisT, Sabin010, DCLXVI, with some fourth person we need to figure out.
So are you claiming that DCLXVI and I as scum buddies both had reason to visit Tyrran night 1?
|
Coagulation was the only scum there? Really? We should have lynched more! Maybe mafia only has 2 KP left. Assuming that, lylo is at least in at most 4 days, if we only lynch one per day and hit no scum.
Looking at coagulation's filter, there is really hardly much there. This one post
On November 19 2011 12:31 Coagulation wrote:
Well looks like we lost the one voice of reason in a giant screaming derp fest.
wasnt LSB taking bets that he would be killed night 1?
Should probably go back and see who responded to that and how.
indicates that mafia probably was trying to use LSB dying as a method of lynching people. Something tells me that this makes palmar much more likely to be town.
We should probably glance at people who voted coag before day 3. Day 3, mafia probably suspected coag would get modkilled, so later votes shouldn't hold any water.
+ Show Spoiler +
Day 1
Consistent votes: Forumite, Kenpachi, Lemonwalrus, Drazerk
Temp votes: Palmar, wherebugsgo, chaoser
Day 2
Cyber_Cheese, RebirthOfLeGenD, bumatlarge, Tyrran
I think the most notable thing is how few people voted him, when he was pretty open about about not helping the town. Worth knowing.
|
On November 26 2011 11:38 Cyber_Cheese wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:07 xsksc wrote:
Wait a sec, didn't Cyber_cheese claim town tracker? Yes Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:10 wherebugsgo wrote:
aww man I liked the DT better. Oh well.
He did. He's a liar. Let's kill him tomorrow.
Zephirdd and Sabin should also die tomorrow. It wasn't a lie. Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:24 xsksc wrote:On November 26 2011 11:12 GreYMisT wrote:On November 26 2011 11:07 xsksc wrote:
Wait a sec, didn't Cyber_cheese claim town tracker? why so he did. He called it something different though, "town obsessive stalker" I think he has some sort of mafia tracker role. On November 26 2011 11:03 Zona wrote:
Town Tracker
You were obsessed with a certain actor during your childhood, and ended up stalking this person whenever you could.
Kibibit's role sounds a lot like obsessive stalker, no? I'm guessing Cyber got a similar role pm, but as scum. His night 1 visit would make a LOT more sense if he is. I could totally be wrong here, I'm extremely tired. I'll give him a proper look tomorow morning. Suffice it to say that the only things our role PM's had in common were town in the name and the tracker ability. Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:27 wherebugsgo wrote:
yep!
There's only 6 players who didn't vote Coag. One of them is hyshes, who is confirmed town. Another one is Lanaia, who voted Sabin. A third is xsksc, who claimed a doctor role,
This means the scumteam is most likely to be GreYMisT, Sabin010, DCLXVI, with some fourth person we need to figure out. So are you claiming that DCLXVI and I as scum buddies both had reason to visit Tyrran night 1?
Okay, you're not a liar.
You're still scum though!
Do you think DCLXVI and Sabin010 are scum?
|
On November 26 2011 11:38 bumatlarge wrote:Coagulation was the only scum there? Really? We should have lynched more! Maybe mafia only has 2 KP left. Assuming that, lylo is at least in at most 4 days, if we only lynch one per day and hit no scum. Looking at coagulation's filter, there is really hardly much there. This one post Show nested quote +On November 19 2011 12:31 Coagulation wrote:
Well looks like we lost the one voice of reason in a giant screaming derp fest.
wasnt LSB taking bets that he would be killed night 1?
Should probably go back and see who responded to that and how. indicates that mafia probably was trying to use LSB dying as a method of lynching people. Something tells me that this makes palmar much more likely to be town. We should probably glance at people who voted coag before day 3. Day 3, mafia probably suspected coag would get modkilled, so later votes shouldn't hold any water. + Show Spoiler +
Day 1
Consistent votes: Forumite, Kenpachi, Lemonwalrus, Drazerk
Temp votes: Palmar, wherebugsgo, chaoser
Day 2
Cyber_Cheese, RebirthOfLeGenD, bumatlarge, Tyrran
I think the most notable thing is how few people voted him, when he was pretty open about about not helping the town. Worth knowing.
I'm like 90% sure all the people who ever voted Coag are town.
It leaves 6 playes who didn't vote him. 1 is confirmed town, 1 is a doctor claim and the remaining 4 are all scummy as fuck.
We lynch five people tomorrow. DCLXVI, Sabin010, GreYMisT, Cyber_Cheese, Lanaia.
I'm 95% confident least three of them are scum. If I'm right, all four of the remaining scum should be there.
|
On November 26 2011 11:35 wherebugsgo wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:29 GreYMisT wrote:
I already stated my reasons for not voting coag, and they were also supported by you actually. Right, but you think it's just a matter of convenience that you have been on every bandwagon this game, you have had no real assertiveness nor original opinions, and you were one of the 6 people who did not vote a person who just flipped scum like two minutes ago? Yeah, I'm not gonna chalk that up to coincidence. At least half of the 6 who didn't vote Coag are scum. If Cyber is not scum then it's possible Lanaia could be.
If i recall correctly forumite was also on numerous bandwagons and took his vote off coag (granted to prevent a hammer, but still), and yet also flipped vanilla town. So it isnt apparently out of the question.
The three bandwagons im going to assume you are talking about are the sinani, kenpachi, and prphlz bandwagons.
I dont really count the sinani bandwagon. the kenpachi one seemed like the correct play at the time, as he was already acting a bit scummy+it was the only way for us to make sense of the lanaia fiasco. plus that one could have been avoided if he had claimed before he died. prphlz also could have saved himself by doing that, but also chose not to. That bandwagon i will admit being off, however even you could see how his behaviour that I pointed out (posting in all caps, elicting emotional responses, ect..) were all valid reasons.
|
On November 26 2011 11:44 GreYMisT wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:35 wherebugsgo wrote:On November 26 2011 11:29 GreYMisT wrote:
I already stated my reasons for not voting coag, and they were also supported by you actually. Right, but you think it's just a matter of convenience that you have been on every bandwagon this game, you have had no real assertiveness nor original opinions, and you were one of the 6 people who did not vote a person who just flipped scum like two minutes ago? Yeah, I'm not gonna chalk that up to coincidence. At least half of the 6 who didn't vote Coag are scum. If Cyber is not scum then it's possible Lanaia could be. If i recall correctly forumite was also on numerous bandwagons and took his vote off coag (granted to prevent a hammer, but still), and yet also flipped vanilla town. So it isnt apparently out of the question. The three bandwagons im going to assume you are talking about are the sinani, kenpachi, and prphlz bandwagons. I dont really count the sinani bandwagon. the kenpachi one seemed like the correct play at the time, as he was already acting a bit scummy+it was the only way for us to make sense of the lanaia fiasco. plus that one could have been avoided if he had claimed before he died. prphlz also could have saved himself by doing that, but also chose not to. That bandwagon i will admit being off, however even you could see how his behaviour that I pointed out (posting in all caps, elicting emotional responses, ect..) were all valid reasons.
actually I'm talking about today's bandwagons too.
If you're scum you know all of these players are town. We lynched Forumite because he was on all of them. We'll lynch you for the same reason.
And no, they were not valid reasons and I repeated myself plenty of times trying to get people to understand that. Half the people in this game don't know how to scumhunt, the rest are just twiddling their thumbs.
|
+ Show Spoiler [Claimed Roles] +Players Alive:
Cyber_Cheese - Town Obsessive Stalker(Tracker)
DCLXVI - soft claimed doctor
GreYMisT - Vanilla
RebirthOfLeGenD - Town Alignment
Lanaia - Town Elder(Double Voter/Double Anti-Voter)
Lemonwalrus - Town Rolecop(gets roles, not alignment)
Palmar - Town Records Cop(can only check people he voted on)
Sabin010 - unclaimed
Tyrran - Vanilla
Zephirdd - Town Restraining Doctor(protect+roleblock)
bumatlarge - unclaimed
hyshes - Town Mason
wherebugsgo - Vanilla
xsksc - Town Doctor(Protects as many targets as the day had lynches)
The Dead:
Kenpachi, the Town Newbie Watchful Doc, lynched Day 1
sinani206, the Town Roleblocker, lynched Day 1
LSB, the Town Vanilla, killed Night 1
prplhz, the Town Corpse Jack, lynched Day 2
HarbingerOfDoom, the Town Vanilla, killed Night 2
risk.nuke, the Town Vanilla, killed Night 2
Drazerk, the Town Frail Mason, killed Night 2
Nisani201, the Town Vanilla, lynched Day 3
Forumite, the Town Vanilla, lynched Day 3
MrZentor, the Town Vanilla, lynched Day 3
Kibibit, the Town Tracker, modkilled Day 3
Coagulation, the Mafia Magician, modkilled Day 3
What made almost no one vote on Coag was his reputation iirc.
|
On November 26 2011 11:41 wherebugsgo wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:38 Cyber_Cheese wrote:On November 26 2011 11:07 xsksc wrote:
Wait a sec, didn't Cyber_cheese claim town tracker? Yes On November 26 2011 11:10 wherebugsgo wrote:
aww man I liked the DT better. Oh well.
He did. He's a liar. Let's kill him tomorrow.
Zephirdd and Sabin should also die tomorrow. It wasn't a lie. On November 26 2011 11:24 xsksc wrote:On November 26 2011 11:12 GreYMisT wrote:On November 26 2011 11:07 xsksc wrote:
Wait a sec, didn't Cyber_cheese claim town tracker? why so he did. He called it something different though, "town obsessive stalker" I think he has some sort of mafia tracker role. On November 26 2011 11:03 Zona wrote:
Town Tracker
You were obsessed with a certain actor during your childhood, and ended up stalking this person whenever you could.
Kibibit's role sounds a lot like obsessive stalker, no? I'm guessing Cyber got a similar role pm, but as scum. His night 1 visit would make a LOT more sense if he is. I could totally be wrong here, I'm extremely tired. I'll give him a proper look tomorow morning. Suffice it to say that the only things our role PM's had in common were town in the name and the tracker ability. On November 26 2011 11:27 wherebugsgo wrote:
yep!
There's only 6 players who didn't vote Coag. One of them is hyshes, who is confirmed town. Another one is Lanaia, who voted Sabin. A third is xsksc, who claimed a doctor role,
This means the scumteam is most likely to be GreYMisT, Sabin010, DCLXVI, with some fourth person we need to figure out. So are you claiming that DCLXVI and I as scum buddies both had reason to visit Tyrran night 1? Okay, you're not a liar. You're still scum though! Do you think DCLXVI and Sabin010 are scum?
If you believe I am, believing DCLXVI is scum too seems stupid.
Sabin is lurking pretty hardcore, do you have a link to his filter?
On November 26 2011 11:44 wherebugsgo wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:38 bumatlarge wrote:Coagulation was the only scum there? Really? We should have lynched more! Maybe mafia only has 2 KP left. Assuming that, lylo is at least in at most 4 days, if we only lynch one per day and hit no scum. Looking at coagulation's filter, there is really hardly much there. This one post On November 19 2011 12:31 Coagulation wrote:
Well looks like we lost the one voice of reason in a giant screaming derp fest.
wasnt LSB taking bets that he would be killed night 1?
Should probably go back and see who responded to that and how. indicates that mafia probably was trying to use LSB dying as a method of lynching people. Something tells me that this makes palmar much more likely to be town. We should probably glance at people who voted coag before day 3. Day 3, mafia probably suspected coag would get modkilled, so later votes shouldn't hold any water. + Show Spoiler +
Day 1
Consistent votes: Forumite, Kenpachi, Lemonwalrus, Drazerk
Temp votes: Palmar, wherebugsgo, chaoser
Day 2
Cyber_Cheese, RebirthOfLeGenD, bumatlarge, Tyrran
I think the most notable thing is how few people voted him, when he was pretty open about about not helping the town. Worth knowing. I'm like 90% sure all the people who ever voted Coag are town. It leaves 6 playes who didn't vote him. 1 is confirmed town, 1 is a doctor claim and the remaining 4 are all scummy as fuck. We lynch five people tomorrow. DCLXVI, Sabin010, GreYMisT, Cyber_Cheese, Lanaia. I'm 95% confident least three of them are scum. If I'm right, all four of the remaining scum should be there.
5 lynches in one day? Are you serious?
|
Damn, wrong thread, sorry guys.
|
zomg dont edit ur posts u getting modkilled bro
|
On November 26 2011 11:47 wherebugsgo wrote:Show nested quote +On November 26 2011 11:44 GreYMisT wrote:On November 26 2011 11:35 wherebugsgo wrote:On November 26 2011 11:29 GreYMisT wrote:
I already stated my reasons for not voting coag, and they were also supported by you actually. Right, but you think it's just a matter of convenience that you have been on every bandwagon this game, you have had no real assertiveness nor original opinions, and you were one of the 6 people who did not vote a person who just flipped scum like two minutes ago? Yeah, I'm not gonna chalk that up to coincidence. At least half of the 6 who didn't vote Coag are scum. If Cyber is not scum then it's possible Lanaia could be. If i recall correctly forumite was also on numerous bandwagons and took his vote off coag (granted to prevent a hammer, but still), and yet also flipped vanilla town. So it isnt apparently out of the question. The three bandwagons im going to assume you are talking about are the sinani, kenpachi, and prphlz bandwagons. I dont really count the sinani bandwagon. the kenpachi one seemed like the correct play at the time, as he was already acting a bit scummy+it was the only way for us to make sense of the lanaia fiasco. plus that one could have been avoided if he had claimed before he died. prphlz also could have saved himself by doing that, but also chose not to. That bandwagon i will admit being off, however even you could see how his behaviour that I pointed out (posting in all caps, elicting emotional responses, ect..) were all valid reasons. actually I'm talking about today's bandwagons too. If you're scum you know all of these players are town. We lynched Forumite because he was on all of them. We'll lynch you for the same reason. And no, they were not valid reasons and I repeated myself plenty of times trying to get people to understand that. Half the people in this game don't know how to scumhunt, the rest are just twiddling their thumbs.
That policy lynch worked out really well for forumite.
In any case, aside from me being on your list of scum( DCLXVI, Sabin010, Cyber_Cheese, Lanaia), it looks pretty good. I'm only hesitant about DCLXVI because he has softclaimed medic, and i would at least like to see him come up with a full roleclaim before we go further with him. I'm confused about your reasoning about lanaia as well. I thought with kenpanchi flipping green it pretty much made us all think she was a misguided townie, rather than a red.
|
I don't give a shit what DCLXVI claimed. I don't care. He's scum.
|
On November 26 2011 12:53 wherebugsgo wrote:
I don't give a shit what DCLXVI claimed. I don't care. He's scum.
I'm getting increasingly convinced that you are scum buddying up to Palmar.
|
I'm getting increasingly convinced I will never see you think logically.
|
you know, since me and Palmar being scumbuddies would mean we both decided to bus Coag and all.
jesus.
|
I still doubt cyber as scum. The other 4 seem legit WBG, thinking at least 2 of them, with DCL at the top of the list.
|
by the other 4, are you including Lanaia?
|
On November 26 2011 14:58 wherebugsgo wrote:
by the other 4, are you including Lanaia?
Yes.
|
Did we really just lynch three vanilla townies?
Are you kidding me?
Maybe I shouldn't've unvoted Coag. Maybe I should have just forced his lynch.
Everyone who is still alive and hasn't claimed needs to hurry the heck up and claim.
|
Lanaia you're dying tomorrow, just fyi.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
