Lord of the Rings Mafia - Page 5

On September 24 2011 00:48 chaoser wrote:


BTW, I find it odd that you posted this claim hours after the day post. Why not immediately after, when both you and I were active in the thread?

On September 24 2011 00:54 supersoft wrote:
we can lynch both after all evil was killed.

On September 24 2011 01:35 Palmar wrote:


DIE SCUM DIE

On September 24 2011 01:56 Palmar wrote:
Sometimes it's just so hard to convince people to do the right thing, because for some reason no one ever realizes what the right action is. Given the situation we're in where we allowed scum to wiggle out of a lynch on day 2 because despite the win condition we all have clearly saying we need to clear all evil out of midgard, yet we let a balrog live when the lore clearly states he's pretty damn evil. I can't believe it's even up for discussion going after a vigilante/SK that decided to kill mafia last night without anyone counterclaiming him. There is just no chance in a game with fake-claims that Boromir the SK is more evil than Balrog the neutral peace-loving fire demon guy. But Kita in his almighty knowledge decided that chaoser must be eliminated immediately yet it's fine to allow iGrok to shuffle by another day. I want to remind you that iGrok was supposed by Kita's own terms to actively scumhunt and not just back away from the game, and yet he's done exactly that. Kita doesn't actually give a shit for obvious reasons. Once again I beg you to go back and read everything posted by both Syllogism and Sandroba because they are the best players that are dead in this game. But hey, why should you listen to me, I'm sometimes a dick! Syllogism pointed out how stupidly heist believes claims randomly (lol, pacific ocean), and jcarl doesn't want to trust me because he's way too busy being thick. Cheesekid is scum though, not even him can be this dumb. It's ok though we just need to lynch iGrok and everything suddenly becomes alright again. Note how fast Kita claimed chaoser was an SK, he knows he's not scum etc. Also he earlier in the game said "Chaoser for SK" because he knows mafia hit chaoser, then corrects himself and says that maybe he could be scum. Kita is just crazy scummy right now. But apparently me changing my mind is more scummy, because you know... it's not cool giving things second thoughts, we should always just go with whatever we first think of right? I'm actually just going to leave the thread for a while, maybe town will not suck so hard when I'm back in some hours.

On September 24 2011 02:26 Drazerk wrote:


Jack of all trades role.

Calling it now.

On September 24 2011 02:29 jcarlsoniv wrote:
Here's a thought: suppose chaoser's claim is true. Let's say he's Boromir who has a kill condition. What if his kill condition is that he can kill any time the Ring moves. This makes sense because Boromir wants the Ring in his lore. It's speculation, so take it with a handful of salt, but it somewhat fits.

And didn't he claim as 3rd party? Why do you keep saying people believe he is town aligned?

On September 24 2011 02:44 raynpelikoneet wrote:


We already made a very stupid choise yesterday. Now just hang iGrok.
-Pros over chaoser;
1) chaoser could very well shoot another scum in the face. iGrok failed in it last night.
2) We basically confirm Drazerk when iGrok flips.

Ppl really should do what Palmar says and check syllo&sandroba posts.

##Vote iGrok

On September 24 2011 22:35 Archon_Toilet wrote:
I HATE YOU KITAMAN

On September 24 2011 22:55 Archon_Toilet wrote:
Ye s kitaman, you will die. I will ride my horsie and kill you hahahahahahaha

On September 24 2011 22:49 chaoser wrote:


What's your take on ON?

On September 25 2011 07:02 prplhz wrote:
well i could add that i very much doubt that chaoser is scum even though he tried to hit me day1 but maybe it's not a good idea to give the ring to boromir .. but this last thing is purely speculation based on how boromir reacted to the ring (and frodo) in lotr

On September 25 2011 07:43 chaoser wrote:


lolol ok kitascum. Either way the ring should be kept safe and not given away so whomever has it, just keep it safe.

On September 26 2011 08:26 Palmar wrote:
I need to re-read them all again to decide that.

Initially I think Kita is the safest lynch. His ability is very... weird, it's a version of tracker that's very seldom in play, and generally the blue roles have been much more notable characters than that elf he claimed.

On September 26 2011 23:07 raynpelikoneet wrote:


Now, what do we know about chaoser? He claimed Boromir. He shot mafia. He was RB last night (or lying). That makes his certainly not mafia right?

Then Palmar claimed Faramir. So here are following scenarios:
chaoser SK / Palmar town given the claims they made i don't think this would be possible
chaoser SK / Palmar mafia why would mafia protect SK?
chaoser SK / Palmar SK (working together) could be, altough i still believe boromir&faramir are both in the game, and not as safeclaims
chaoser town / Palmar mafia no need to Palmar fakeclaim and defend chaoser
chaoser town / Palmar town most likely answer
chaoser town / Palmar SK could be, altough i don't see a reason for Palmar to fakeclaim, again

If chaoser was in fact mafia, they would need to have an extremely brave strategy in bussing/killing nearly all their teammates, and it would all fall apart just if ppl didn't believe chaoser in a first place.

Also, kitaman you could be some kinda mafia stalker role.

Also, i think you are wise enough to figure out chaosers requirements for killing. If I'm right about it, it fits into his claim fairly well.

BTW. Who did you check last night and what's the result?

On September 26 2011 23:52 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I'd vote GGQ for gollum, just becouse of his "i'm not saying anything useful this game besides i want to lynch iGrok".

On September 26 2011 23:53 Palmar wrote:
Actually fuck it

Kita needs to claim all his tracking targets and what actions they performed.

##Vote Kitaman27

On September 27 2011 00:15 Palmar wrote:
Well here is a thing.

If it was day 2, and you actually looked like a townie, I would never ask you. But it's day 4, you put in some ridiculous restrictions on iGrok instead of just wanting to lynch him on day 2.

On September 27 2011 00:15 Palmar wrote:
And excuse me, but you're a veteran, and I can't believe you'd be so incredibly dumb as to let him live on day 2, and then try it AGAIN on day 3 without being scum. I just think you're smarter than that. Newbies are excused because they don't realize how ridiculous the claim is, and they don't know me/syllo/sandroba well enough to just assume that when we all agree that we're right.

Greymist - newbie
chaoser - SK (he's not this stupid as town, and his claim makes no sense)
Radfield - Scum
Drazerk - newbie
raynpelikoneet - newbie
jcarlsoniv - ???? (but to be fair he thought I was scum because I trolled him)
TranceStorm - newbie
OriginalName - ????
kitaman - ????

You see. there are two names on this list of people who should really not have fallen for this bullshit, it's you and ON.

On September 27 2011 00:15 Palmar wrote:
List all the players you have tracked so far in the game. Don't tell us if they had a night action or not, just list them.

On September 27 2011 00:59 jcarlsoniv wrote:
Right now, you're intentionally holding information from town. Town is not in a very good position right now. Not terrible, but not great. We got screwed over first two days by radfield on last minute lynches that shouldn't have happened (hindsight 20/20 and all that).

We need information. Who did you track night 1?

I also want to know more about chaoser's target last night. But I can somewhat understand why he wouldn't reveal that. If you are town, you need to help town, Kita.

On September 27 2011 00:30 GreYMisT wrote:
Is palmar actually claiming golum? I know to a sane person that doesn't make any sense but I read WaW2 and he also claimed conspirator right off the bat in that as well.