Lord of the Rings Mafia - Page 2

Post a Reply

Prev 1 2 All

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 20 2011 17:04 GMT

#915

Also until you figure something out about the cypher there is no point talking about what it is not in the thread.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 20 2011 17:23 GMT

#917

Mafia is going to shoot townies regardless GGQ. I don't think you need to comment on everyone in the game, but you need to give your opinion on those people being discussed so we can get a read on you. As town it's extremelly advantageous to both you and the rest of town that you establish your innocence. As scum it's understandable that you want to hide. So please, fuck the cypher I want to know what you think about jackal.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 21 2011 05:27 GMT

#1009

iGrok can you post the whole text of your role and of your safe claim if you have it.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 21 2011 05:29 GMT

#1011

And my proposition to you is the following: You shoot GGQ in the face and we don't lynch you.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 21 2011 16:13 GMT

#1093

Ok, I just thought about this some more and igrok's claim is clearly bullshit:
1) He lied about his role, since he took a hit and survived.
2) His claimed wincondition is too easy, based on his abilities. He has infinite checks to find a person, he can play however he wants, he has an extra life and all he need to do is survive? Also his claim that he was playing scummy day1 to avoid a mafia hit no longer holds, since he just survived a hit.
3) Gandalf's role has no mention of Balrog. Isn't that weird?

So he clearly is not a survivor, but wtf is he? To me it seems more likely he is an assassin/sk type, but really there is no way to tell. He did claim this shit with only 3 votes on him and I really don't know why he would do that, but I've seen stranger things before.
I'm keeping my vote where it is, unless igrok can actually shoot during the day and hits scum on his own.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 21 2011 16:20 GMT

#1100

Even if he is what he claims (which he is not) we have no choice but kill him before he uses his hit. There is 7 town and 1 mafia dead. If you were survivor would you side with mafia or town in this situation? He is just going to save his shot and use in on a townie close to lylo when we cannot chance lynching him.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 21 2011 21:51 GMT

#1251

Man here is the deal. Let's assume igrok is telling the truth. We don't lynch him and we tell him to shoot X person tonight. Obviously if that person is mafia he will be roleblocked. If the person is town they will either let the shot go through or roleblock him and create a fucking mess and possibly waste more lynches. He can withold his shot indefinitely and claim rb. He can claim he found saruman at any time and possibly make us mislynch. We can't deal with him later in the game close to lylo. So even if he is actually telling the truth I don't see how we can trust this and trust he won't do pro-mafia actions. There is currently 7 townies and 1 mafia dead, so I know who I would side with if I was what he claims to be. Mafia is never going to get rid of him for us. We can either lynch him now or have a copy of this day at a later date, so I don't think we have much of a choice besides lynching him now.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 22 2011 02:58 GMT

#1293

Okay got info from the host himself. Town win con is to eliminte all evil and that includes ALL third party. iGrok's claim is impossible.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

September 23 2011 02:19 GMT

#1492

Good luck everyone!

Prev 1 2 All

Please or register to reply.