My Little Pony Mafia - Page 4

Post a Reply

Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next All

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 18 2011 23:06 GMT

#815

LaL usally refers to Lynch all liars.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 18 2011 23:45 GMT

#827

I still don't see why a scum player would give tntked their piece of harmony, especially when the mechanic for retreiving it is unknown.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 18 2011 23:47 GMT

#831

On September 19 2011 08:46 TheFerryman wrote:

Didnt this happen once before?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 18 2011 23:51 GMT

#833

Wait a minute, why would you ask him to do it then if it wouldn't absolve him?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 18 2011 23:57 GMT

#841

I know how to solve this mess of a day we have created.
## Unvote
## Vote Jackal58

You said earlier that you are ok with us killing you to confirm the alignment of tntked. I feel that is nessesary now more than ever.

I forget the game, but we know that you have done crazy scum gambits before, like when you bussed jee jee day1ish. So far all analysis we have done today is WIFOM assuming that you and tntked are confirmed town. Looking back I now realize it is imperitave that we confirm tntked, the holder of the items.
Or has your opinion changed jackal? are you no longer ok with supplying us with a 500% confirmed town at your expense?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 00:01 GMT

#847

When does the day end?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 00:07 GMT

#851

What do you guys feel about my plan on the top of the page (43)? I think its the only way we can clear up the events of the day.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 00:15 GMT

#854

On September 19 2011 09:10 Jackal58 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Nope. Have not changed a thing. If my lynch helps to secure a town victory I'm all for it.
Of Forumite, WBG, and Lucidity at least 1 is definitely scum if not 2 of them. I personally see it as most likely 1 atm. If WBG flips town I don't know yet which of the other two is going to flip scum but one of them will.

Alright, and I agree with your assessment ON Forumite, WBG and lucidity.
To clarify things for everyone, This was not a pressure vote to see if jackal would change his opinion, but I glad to see he hasn't. I actually think we cannot move forward in this game at all without confirming tntked.
We need to see Jackal flip in order to make sense of anything at all that has happened today, our own feelings about his alignment aside.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 00:30 GMT

#861

On September 19 2011 09:21 tnkted wrote:
Ugh that clears up a lot. Rereading thread.

FTR I'd rather not lynch jackal because he's the only other townie I feel 100% on

Unfortunately We don't know your alignment, so saying you feel he is 100% town doesn't mean much to us.
There are 3 senarios as I see it:
1) you are both green and everything you said is true
2) you are both red and performing the most epic gambit of all time
3) jackal is red and you are green, he is gambiting to make you believe he is green.

Of all the senarios I dont feel 3 is nearly as likely as the other 2, because jackal gave you his piece, as did WBG.

On that note you believe jackal because he gave you his piece, but you dont believe WBG even though he gave you his piece? maybe I'm missing something, enlighten me.

Anyway we need to confirm that #1 is definatly the senario we have here. the only way I can see to do that is to lynch jackal today. a DT check on him tonight would be unreliable because of the possiblity of insanity, framer, godfather, and whatever the hell else is lurking in ponyville that we dont know about.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 00:38 GMT

#865

Well mother of God

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 00:39 GMT

#866

You are right, tntked gave his piece to Jackal who then gave the completed piece to tntked. This completely eliminates the 3rd possibility in my eyes, however the 1st and 2nd are still viable options.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 00:53 GMT

#874

I'm uncomfortable with just assuming we have 2 confirmed townies, but I suppose you are right, we need to lynch for scum. option 1 (both being town) makes more sense with the explanation you linked of jackal's.

I still feel that Lucidity is our best lynch for day2, his day1 play set off some alarm bells in my head, and tntked you posted some analysis of him day1 as well.

##Unvote

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 01:01 GMT

#880

Let us not forget, when lucidity came under attack he began posting like a madman, attacking WBG, then attacking forumite when you pointed out the fact that WBG gave up his piece without knowing what it would be. He also attacked jackal around that time as well.

The trouble with today is I strongly believe that one or more of Cyber, Nisani, Sevryn, dream, and curu are scum. But unless we all want to go for a random lurker lynch we dont have enough to go on for any of them.

actually does anyone know why we stopped voting for nisani? things got chaotic a few pages back. did he have a piece or was it because he was in a PM circle?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 01:21 GMT

#889

On September 19 2011 08:33 Lucidity wrote:
Ok I need to go to sleep now.

If I end up being lynched it should be easy to find the scum on me.

tnkted has refused to respond to my defense of his analysis on me. He has called me "very town" but still thinks I should be lynched. If he is considered a good player, his play has been very bad this game. Since Day 2 I have operated under the assumption that he was just a derping townie, but if he is actually pushing an agenda and I get lynched I don't think we should discount the possibility that he gambited by giving his element to Jackal.

If Forumite ends up on my lynch he is easily scum. Please look at my posts regarding him in the early game and chaos' case against him. Since Night 1 Forumite has only posted Fluff and talked about the elements. His only attempt at scum hunting was an extremely weak case against me. He has now stated that he doesn't believe I'm scum anymore so that's self explanatory...

I guess WBG will just put his vote wherever he can avoid his own death.

DONT LET A NO LYNCH OCCUR. Even if that means I have to die. At least we find scum if I die.

Jackal, why are you diverting the lynch away from WBG to Sevryn? You didn't even provide a case on him. That's really troubling me. I had thought you were very town before you did that. If a no lynch occurs because Jackal pushed a Lurker lynch make sure to look in to him more thoroughly.

I've been looking over posts from lucidity and reevaluating my case on him, because thats pretty much what it has come down to. Lucidity or WBG.
I came across this post, a "see ya later post" that mafia would definatly NOT make. Mafia post something like this in an effort to stop a lynch from happening, they do not post something in order to help town after a lynch.

Looking back at nisani I feel he is scum, look at this post here

On September 17 2011 04:01 Nisani201 wrote:
##Unvote

I'm going to trust you on this one, only because this is a closed setup and I have no idea what could be going on behind the scenes.

Who are our other lynch suspects?

Long you confirmed things for us, he says this. Would a townie be this accepting of someone just claiming out of the blue? remember, only scum know who is town.

Unfortunatly we cannot get a nessesary vote on nisani even if i could get everyone to vote for him.

Some things WBG have said are scummy, but I dont have the best read on him right now. That being said, we cannot have a no lynch today. Because I dont think it is possible to change everyone's vote in such a short amount of time:
##Vote Wherebugsgo
Forumite you are in a similar position I am voting for someone who wont get lynched. who do you want to go for today?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 01:22 GMT

#890

EBWOP: the phrase under Nisani201's qoute is supposed to read: Long before you confirmed things for us...

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

September 19 2011 01:52 GMT

#912

So we have a choice, No-lynch or WBG.
The problem with a no-lynch is we pretty much get to do today all over again, but with the absence of a town member due to nighttime. Of course, if some blues come forth with info on day3 that would be great, but not likely. On the other hand killing a townie just for the sake of killing someone is not a good idea, and if we all feel pretty good about WBG being town we shouldn't kill him.
What do you guys think about a no-lynch