My Little Pony Mafia - Page 29

On September 17 2011 06:41 Lucidity wrote:
If you are town you've basically let scum know that you've got some special powerz. There's no point in trying to hide that now, is there?

On September 17 2011 05:38 tnkted wrote:
Just tell them jackal, the info is pro-town and if you're killed it confirms my alignment anyway which mafia does not want. Vice versa if you're killed.

On September 17 2011 11:01 wherebugsgo wrote:


Why don't you tell us?

This sudden claim stuff is hella shady to me. It came at a really strange time of day, and it's not making any sense yet other than Jackal "confirming" tnkted as town.

I find it weird that it's been put out there that tnkted is town but there's almost no explanation as for why or how. If you actually are town you'll get shot for sure (which is just dumb to me, idk why you would do that) and if you're not it makes sense as a gambit to get another mislynch today and get us closer to mylo.

On September 17 2011 11:11 GreYMisT wrote:


I think this lowers their suspicion level to me. here is why:

Note when Jackal posted his assertion that tntked was town for the first time. Before the night post. Before that point a lot of us were talking about tntked and his behavior the previous day. The best reason I can see of this is that jackal thought the chances were good that he was going to die that night, so he posted information he had somehow obtain that tntked was town, in hopes that his death, flipping green/blue, and his post would prevent another mislynch on tntked today. The more complicated explination is that he is mafia, he fabricates a post about his scumbuddie tntked being town, and posts it in hopes the above argument is assumed, and a vig doesnt hit him or tnkted making him look guilty, or tntked isnt lynched anyway, exposing jackal as a liar, and now the scum is down by 2. I do not see any senario that would occur if only one of tntked or jackal was scum. in my eyes both have to either be town, or scum. Occam's Razor dictates that the first senario (with them both being town) is more simple, and therefore more likely. However, I await your explanation as to what in the hell is going on.

On September 17 2011 11:16 wherebugsgo wrote:


I don't think you can tell either way.

Either they're both townies, and Jackal knows something about tnkted so he's trying to prevent him from getting lynched. Or they're both mafia making a gambit to gain towncred. Look how fast half the town believed tnkted.

What's weird to me is that tnkted seems to know how Jackal knows he is town. This makes very little sense to me, since certainly tnkted would back up Jackal when Jackal is defending him, but then why would tnkted push Jackal to explain it, in a way that seems as if tnkted already knows HOW Jackal knows?

It just doesn't add up to me.

On September 17 2011 11:25 wherebugsgo wrote:
yeah, that's the last bit. They've "claimed" but it's not clear at all. If you're going to claim as town (and draw mafia attention) you might as well claim in full. Only they and the mafia right now know their alignment, and that's not really helping the rest of us.

On September 17 2011 14:13 Jackal58 wrote:

Scum really hate when two townies know they are both townies don't you?
Scum really hate when townies have knowledge that is denied to scum don't you?

PM abilities in a non PM game are great. As I said before if you guys feel compelled to lynch me to verify my alignment I'm ok with that. But keep your dick beaters off of Twinkles.

Sorry Curu. I didn't realize you were running LOTR when I posted that.

My vote is going on Bugs. If you're town you can trust me or lynch me. But you damn sure aren't getting all the details.

##VOTE: wherebugsgo