EPTOn September 04 2011 09:31 redFF wrote:
i assume coroner has more checks than me, but can probably also use two a day.
i assume coroner has more checks than me, but can probably also use two a day.
:/
Coroner
Can look at a corpse and determine alignment and role. May be used any time, and will instantly return the information (as soon as I get the pm).
The OP explicitly says A corpse per day. Your claim isn't looking believable.
On September 04 2011 09:36 wherebugsgo wrote:
The circular reasoning this creates should suggest to you that we should keep this guy alive for now.
Bum and ON are definitely more scummy. Bum avoided lynch, has not really contributed anything, and sandroba claimed RB (when he was one of the players who voted bum).
ON threw his vote on Kenpachi and then purposely left it there while he was STILL AROUND at the end of the day. Now again he's still pursuing Kenpachi when it's clear he's definitely not going to get lynched today.
There's too much weird shit going on with red thanks to his shitty play that I'd rather leave him alive at least till tomorrow. With ON and Bum hopefully out of action tomorrow we can lynch red and someone else.
The circular reasoning this creates should suggest to you that we should keep this guy alive for now.
Bum and ON are definitely more scummy. Bum avoided lynch, has not really contributed anything, and sandroba claimed RB (when he was one of the players who voted bum).
ON threw his vote on Kenpachi and then purposely left it there while he was STILL AROUND at the end of the day. Now again he's still pursuing Kenpachi when it's clear he's definitely not going to get lynched today.
There's too much weird shit going on with red thanks to his shitty play that I'd rather leave him alive at least till tomorrow. With ON and Bum hopefully out of action tomorrow we can lynch red and someone else.
There is no circular reasoning here - this is pretty simple to follow. Try and keep up.
redFF checks Sinani and Varp and by his own admission:
On September 04 2011 09:37 redFF wrote:
and yes ace that was the original intention to see they were scum because i figured just checking the nightkilled players would be less useful then checking the lynches.
and yes ace that was the original intention to see they were scum because i figured just checking the nightkilled players would be less useful then checking the lynches.
He checked to see if they were Scum but found them to be Town. If he outs them as being Town then he'd also have no problem checking the 3 Night Killed people.
HOWEVER, he is the BACKUP coroner right? That means he is the last one. Why the hell would he out himself just for Sinani when he just saw 3 people get Night Killed. He'll die by Day 3 and the Town will have no Coroners left. The game is essentially over at that point.
Think about this for more than 5 seconds.
As for your bolded that doesn't even make any sense. Bum avoiding a lynch doesn't make him Scummy, and it has no relation to sandroba's alleged role block. Even if sandroba voted for Bum, assuming bum is Scum why would that give him cause to RB sandroba? That doesn't add up at all. Faulty logic there.
Your second point also makes no sense. Most votes wins, not majority. ON leaving his vote anywhere when there are low vote counts to die and a role that has double voting power means this tells you nothing unless Kenpachi dies by low vote count.
If red is playing like shit (very high possibility) and weird stuff is going on it makes sense to lynch him. An unconfirmed claim that is an automatic game over if he dies? Why are you even thinking about bum and ON?
you yourself said that they probably wouldnt be a backup coroner, so if coroner died you know they would stay silent and sinani would probably be resurrected. Did you take a dead coroner into account when you made your post?
Yes, and even if I didn't why would it matter? If the Coroner dies and never says anything then we just take the chance and revive Sinani.
You still can't explain why a backup role thats pretty important to the Town in a no flip game would out himself on Day 2, knowing the original role died and saw 3 people get NK'd the previous night. Add in that there is nothing in the OP that says we have protective roles. Your claim also can't be confirmed, and you brought up some bullshit scenario about Counter Claiming that took 3 seconds of brain power to dismiss.
Every scenario I look at your claim comes off as a high risk, low reward play. Even worse your insistence on reviving Sinani OVER Varpulis, if they are both indeed Town tells me, and any Mafia with half a brain that killing you and Sinani at tonight ends the game for the Town.
You can't be THIS stupid. You are lying.
