I´m beginning to understand why Nisani201 is still alive, his ability is absolutely useless.

If anyone got any PMs from the killed players that might give us some clues, please post them.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 21 2011 11:17 GMT

#674

Okay, caught up with the thread.

Nisani201 has been up for lynching since Day 1, and looking at who´s been pushing for him each day will give a lot of information, depending on the way he flips. Unlike the lurkers, lynching Nisani201 will give us a lot of information about other players.

##Vote: Nisani201

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 21 2011 17:53 GMT

#694

This is like AvP, two scumteams fighting, whoever wins, Town is sure to loose.

This causes a big problem with scumhunting, two players can both be scum but still push to lynch eachother.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 22 2011 11:06 GMT

#701

On August 22 2011 16:52 Kurumi wrote:
Why we went dead silent today? The game isn't over, we have at least two scum left. I am voting slam500, so we get a lurker lynch, he looks like he forgot about the thread since he was a lynch candidate.

I´m not sure about this strategy, it´s basically giving up our vote doing what the rules are meant to do for us. I´d rather see modkills actually happen. As they don´t, killing off Slam500 could work if we can´t think of a better target. Might shake the other lurkers out of inactivity.

On that note, still waiting for Curu to explain why I´m scum.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 22 2011 18:21 GMT

#706

Really Curu? Tell us to expect something good, then wait 23 hours during which we are waiting for the bomb and don´t discuss anyone else? At least it´s an effective technique to get someone lynched, and enough are buying it.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 22 2011 20:40 GMT

#709

Okay, first, I disagree that not using IRC is scummy. In my opinion, using IRC kills this game, the posts are short and without depth, there is no real analysis. Ironically, the post Curu did on me is one of the few serious analysis posts so far, and it took until Day 3 to see it. You all go to Irc, post 80% irrelevant information, sometimes under false names (I think JeeJee did this), and feel like you are contributing, while the place where discussion and analysis can take place with everyone, this thread, is left empty.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 22 2011 21:04 GMT

#713

I said I was not going to use Irc because I knew people would use it as a reason to lynch me. When I said it, it had allready come up.

As for making a Fos on JeeJee after saying I dislike accusing players, I don´t consider it to have any significance, I don´t know why Curu brought it up.

As for not voting Greymist, if I was scum like Curu thinks, wouldn´t I have jumped on that bandwagon eventually, for the towncred? Of course, I could have been in the other team, except TAA did a quick FoS on me, which started the early suspicion. Either way, it doesn´t add up.

----
There are two scumteams, and scum need to take an active part in scumhunting, or risk getting killed off, because the scumteam that control the lynches, get more killpower. Scum must be active and try to lead Town, not blend in. Who do scum kill? Anyone of their own team, it doesn´t matter, they just need to get someone killed, Town or enemy Scum. At least two players look like they are good at pushing for and securing a lynch, from the first two days, and the bandwagon on me.

GreYMisT - Jackal58, Nisani201, hiro protagonist, OriginalName, DroneAllDay, Varpulis, Sevryn, Curu
Jackal58 - nisani201, snotboogie, Forumite, TheAwesomeAll, Curu, Da-Muffinman, Sevryn, hiro protagonist
Forumite - Curu, hiro protagonist, Sevryn, DroneAllDay, Varpulis

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 22 2011 22:24 GMT

#716

Missed it earlier, Sevryn has been very successfull with bandwagoning winning lynches too.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 22 2011 23:07 GMT

#717

On August 23 2011 06:28 Curu wrote:
hiro protagonist is scum, you're right. So you're on the black scum team and hiro is one the red one, right?

Hey do us a favour and use your night kill on hiro for me. I'm betting hiro was the one who killed DropBear.

On August 23 2011 06:37 hiro protagonist wrote:
ahahahaha... this game...

The silent treatment? Not even calling it out as an OMGUS? There is such a thing as taking an accusation too cool.

##Vote: Curu

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 08:44 GMT

#724

On August 23 2011 13:50 sinani206 wrote:
I don't understand this post at all but what it seems to say is that hiro is not taking the accusation seriously. However, you don't vote for him, you vote for Curu. Maybe you were giving advice to your scumbuddy?

Curu is most likely, because he got the bandwagon going, the others are secondary, they tagged along.
I added Sevryn to the list for consistency.

As for why scumhunting is scummy, I assume you didn´t read that post, so I´ll explain again. Scum has to find the enemy scumteam, so even scum like Curu will go around and try to find out who is looking scummy. The usual scumtells, like knowing in advance who is scum, and not hunting for other scum, don´t apply here. Being a successfull scumhunter doesn´t make you Town. Being aggressive with lynching doesn´t make you Town.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 12:00 GMT

#727

I say Curu should get lynched, and that´s relevant no matter what any of you think I am, and with only 48 hours per day, you should start thinking about this right now. Seriously, Curu´s way of dealing with this lynch and the counter-FoS screams scum to me. Waiting 23 hours before actually posting his analysis of me? He cost Town half the day there, a day that would have been better used to discuss this lynch, instead of rushing into it. And afterwards, I did an obvious OMGUS, and he just waved it away, hoping it wouldn´t catch on. That´s what´s scummy, not just the scumhunting, but the way he scumhunts.

One of either Curu, Hiro or possibly Sevryn is scum. Looking at nightkills, there should be only 2 scumteams. As both scumteams have lost a member each allready, killing whoever is scum between Curu, Hiro and Sevryn will destroy one of the teams. I guess it will have to wait until tomorrow, though.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 12:57 GMT

#731

Something we agree of.
If Curu survives the night, lynch him.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 13:21 GMT

#734

You make a compelling argument...

Come on Curu, you know this isn´t about me, it´s about you, and how you are scum. It doesn´t matter what I am, if I´m Town or Scum, because either way, I hunt scum like you.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 13:35 GMT

#736

On August 23 2011 22:23 Curu wrote:
I've been at the head of all three (now four) lynches, don't even try to project your scummy crap on me.

So, I assume you think that makes you Town?

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 13:41 GMT

#739

The silent treatment, seriously?

I think I´ve made my point, or rather, Curu has made it for me.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 13:45 GMT

#741

On August 23 2011 22:43 Curu wrote:
Double posting cause there's nothing between this post and my previous post. And cause I'm allowed to double post here.

Yeah, about that...

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 13:57 GMT

#744

Lead Town to victory? While Curu is quick to vote on whoever is going to get lynched, so far two of those are Blues, and only the first one, Greymist, was scum. With 1/3 accuracy, it sounds more like Curu will lead Town to an early doom.

Forumite

Sweden3280 Posts

August 23 2011 14:16 GMT

#748

True, scumhunting isn´t scummy in itself, but the way you scumhunt can be scummy. Curu is scummy for the way he scumhunts, and for the occasional scumtell (around 15) he´s made the last few pages.