On August 18 2011 23:37 Palmar wrote: It is, what does it bring to the table except for the fact that you could in theory be right or wrong? What do we stand to gain by trying to figure out who mafia is going to shoot? It's a guessing game with no content in it.
The only thing it does is give you an excuse to add something to the thread without actually contributing, and then allow you to wifom depending on how your team decides to spread their hits tonight. "Look, I was wrong on all the kills, I can't be mafia" or "Look, mafia killed exactly my targets, they're trying to set me up!".
Seriously, it's non-content, it's useless for town, and I'm pretty sure you're scum.
Lol? Manufactured outrage much?
Go read the post you originally called scummy. 90% of it was me analyzing who died the night before, not who was going to be killed. You don't think its weird that they killed foolishness, who was entirely useless, but haven't bothered killing BC or any of the other vets? Vet sniping is a logical strategy for mafia, and it appears to be the strat they're going for. How is that non-content and useless to town?
What you're doing in this post is attempting to accuse me of future wifom, which is entirely ridiculous. SCUMMY MOVE BRO
On August 18 2011 20:01 Curu wrote: Explain then. Why did you do nothing but beg for Pandain to ban you? Why have you contributed absolutely nothing? Explain why you wanted to vote for Pandain after asking for Medic prot for him.
Pandain's reaction to being "killed" was to reveal a link to Mig. This struck me as something no scum would do unless Pandain is scum and Mig a townie. That scenario was unlikely in my opinion.
However, Pandain continues to use his ban power in terrible ways. Not to mention he hasn't really done much else. So I want to see what the power does and I offered myself up for the consideration. I voted for Pandain because I said I would if he didn't ban me and he flat out ignored me. You say he ignored me because he thinks I'm scum. Well besides you putting words in his mouth if he thinks that he can say as much.
As for contributing absolutely nothing, you confuse "contributing" with "posting a lot". If I had truly contributed nothing, you wouldn't have a case like that would you? I was wrong about Bum and as such I need to take a step back and refocus. However your insistence that I'm 100 percent scum is disturbing.
I'm not confusing anything. You haven't said a single relevant thing this game. How was he "still" using it terribly? bum was obvious scum and bum said himself he was nuking Pandain. Instead of contributing on why you think bum is not scum or why you think Pandain is scum or why you think LSB is scum, you park your vote on Pandain uselessly on Pandain because "lol he isn't listening to me." You just said again you don't think Pandain is scum. Yet you wanted to vote him for the shittiest reason I have ever seen, right when it was a counterwagon against scumatlarge.
Why didn't you give your analysis on Pandain earlier? Mig asked you a couple times what Pandain's reaction showed you, you ignored it. Continued to be useless. The wagons attempted to be started to divert scumatlarge's were LSB and Pandain. Somehow they're still your "top" scumreads but you can't give any reasons besides "Pandain is ignoring me" lol. Still useless. Give me your opinion on BC, syllo, Node, redFF. I couldn't care less what you think about two likely Townies.
On August 18 2011 21:13 Jackal58 wrote: I actually agree with some of them Curu but damn this is funny shit. + Show Spoiler +
On August 17 2011 21:48 Jackal58 wrote: My vote was on Pandain before you voted Pandain and then moved it to Bum. I didn't jump on anything. I think both are gong to end up being town. I think I'd rather see one of the 7 lurkers get lynched.
On August 17 2011 06:20 Palmar wrote: screw it, there's a hole in the logic.
##Unvote ##Vote Bumatlarge
Pandain's defending of Bumatlarge does not make any sense whatsoever if Pandain is red and Bumatlarge green.
If Pandain is red and Bumatlarge green, what's the motivation behind trying to actively push a lynch away from town that was almost surely going to be lynched? Why on earth would he put his neck out to try to stop a lynch on town?
What I think is happening here is that they're both red, but they realized that if Pandain gets lynched now, Bumatlarge looks really good. If Bumatlarge gets lynched now, Pandain is still under heavy suspicion.
Voila, make a scummy defense post, give Bumatlarge a fuckton of town-credit, bus one scum, and you're good to go. Losing Pandain at this point for the scumteam is the optimal play since Bumatlarge was going to get lynched.
On August 17 2011 08:48 VisceraEyes wrote: I'm curious as to how Node could confirm that I'm Coagulation. Is anyone else curious? I did PM Jackal and Palmar, who said as much when THEY confirmed that I'm Coagulation...but Node just said 'I can confirm it' and voted for me. I never PM'd Node, and I never role-claimed to Node.
##Vote: Node
...until an explanation is received.
How did you PM Jackal and Palmar when no PMs are allowed?
Role.
Bullshit.
Node is scum.
On August 18 2011 12:45 Curu wrote: Syllo needs to die too. He's 100% scum.
On August 18 2011 12:43 Curu wrote: Actually we are fixing this atmosphere. All the people refusing to contribute go.
BC, Node, Scamp must all die. Anyone that's a Vig, fire away. Any alive, tomorrow's lynch.
On August 18 2011 01:59 tnkted wrote: Hey if, hypothetically, we were to have a list checker, and I'm not crazy about lynching bum, would it make sense for me to vote pandain so that the list checker can have a better list of people to check, depending on bum's flip? Or should I vote bum to make it easier?
tnkted is scum.
I'm town dude. Forgive me for thinking scum wouldn't have a day vig that outs himself.
Well I don't think both you and redFF can be scum together and thus far I'm more convinced redFF is scum. Look at the list, he is 7% higher. Also if I'm not Town then you might as well just roll over and give up cause I'm one of the only few that actually cares enough about this game to push my reads and contribute. Read Day 2 again and find someone more determined than me to get bum lynched.
On August 18 2011 12:45 sandroba wrote: Second LSB is mafia. If you remember my question day 1 about personalities=alignment he was very oposed to this idea.
Explain Chez/BM as Town then since personalitywize they are obviously anti-town
The only reason it makes sense for bum to have nuked kav is if scum knew he was the inventor and was willing to make the 1:1 trade. Sandroba, did you tell anyone else about his invention that he intended to give you?
No, the reason for bum to nuke Kav was because everyone knew bum was scum and that he was going to die anyways. But he still almost wiggled out of the lynch.
On August 17 2011 21:48 Jackal58 wrote: My vote was on Pandain before you voted Pandain and then moved it to Bum. I didn't jump on anything. I think both are gong to end up being town. I think I'd rather see one of the 7 lurkers get lynched.
On August 17 2011 06:20 Palmar wrote: screw it, there's a hole in the logic.
##Unvote ##Vote Bumatlarge
Pandain's defending of Bumatlarge does not make any sense whatsoever if Pandain is red and Bumatlarge green.
If Pandain is red and Bumatlarge green, what's the motivation behind trying to actively push a lynch away from town that was almost surely going to be lynched? Why on earth would he put his neck out to try to stop a lynch on town?
What I think is happening here is that they're both red, but they realized that if Pandain gets lynched now, Bumatlarge looks really good. If Bumatlarge gets lynched now, Pandain is still under heavy suspicion.
Voila, make a scummy defense post, give Bumatlarge a fuckton of town-credit, bus one scum, and you're good to go. Losing Pandain at this point for the scumteam is the optimal play since Bumatlarge was going to get lynched.
On August 17 2011 08:48 VisceraEyes wrote: I'm curious as to how Node could confirm that I'm Coagulation. Is anyone else curious? I did PM Jackal and Palmar, who said as much when THEY confirmed that I'm Coagulation...but Node just said 'I can confirm it' and voted for me. I never PM'd Node, and I never role-claimed to Node.
##Vote: Node
...until an explanation is received.
How did you PM Jackal and Palmar when no PMs are allowed?
Role.
Bullshit.
Node is scum.
On August 18 2011 12:45 Curu wrote: Syllo needs to die too. He's 100% scum.
On August 18 2011 12:43 Curu wrote: Actually we are fixing this atmosphere. All the people refusing to contribute go.
BC, Node, Scamp must all die. Anyone that's a Vig, fire away. Any alive, tomorrow's lynch.
On August 18 2011 01:59 tnkted wrote: Hey if, hypothetically, we were to have a list checker, and I'm not crazy about lynching bum, would it make sense for me to vote pandain so that the list checker can have a better list of people to check, depending on bum's flip? Or should I vote bum to make it easier?
Jackal had to get a town player lynched, why would a town player have to do that? Curu's list is bs and he's just talking out his ass with no evidence to back it up. The only case I get at this stage is LSB and I agree he is likely mafia. Node is suspicious too, wouldn't mind a shot on him.
On August 19 2011 02:40 redFF wrote: Jackal had to get a town player lynched, why would a town player have to do that? Curu's list is bs and he's just talking out his ass with no evidence to back it up. The only case I get at this stage is LSB and I agree he is likely mafia. Node is suspicious too, wouldn't mind a shot on him.
VOTE ME FOR MAYOR BECAUSE I AM FUCKING TOWN.
Listen up dummy. This is the last time I'm going to explain this to you. I DID NOT HAVE TO GET KURUMI/BILL MURRAY LYNCHED. I had to post my desire for his death when it became apparent who he was "no matter what". Method did not matter. I received no benefit from him dying. I stated this numerous times. It would make no difference to me one way or another if he were still in the game. But you guys would still be getting a constant barrage of "Kill Kurumi/BM" posts from me. Got it yet? Good.
On August 19 2011 00:44 Curu wrote: I'm not confusing anything. You haven't said a single relevant thing this game. How was he "still" using it terribly? bum was obvious scum and bum said himself he was nuking Pandain. Instead of contributing on why you think bum is not scum or why you think Pandain is scum or why you think LSB is scum, you park your vote on Pandain uselessly on Pandain because "lol he isn't listening to me." You just said again you don't think Pandain is scum. Yet you wanted to vote him for the shittiest reason I have ever seen, right when it was a counterwagon against scumatlarge.
Why didn't you give your analysis on Pandain earlier? Mig asked you a couple times what Pandain's reaction showed you, you ignored it. Continued to be useless. The wagons attempted to be started to divert scumatlarge's were LSB and Pandain. Somehow they're still your "top" scumreads but you can't give any reasons besides "Pandain is ignoring me" lol. Still useless. Give me your opinion on BC, syllo, Node, redFF. I couldn't care less what you think about two likely Townies.
You're mistaking a vote as a permanent thing. I thought I made it pretty clear that I was basically joining the LSB wagon and the vote on Pandain was more of a formality. Why I think LSB was scum is pretty obvious IMO but with the Bum flip he looks miles better.
I didn't ignore Mig, it's just that when I was ready to answer him he was already going off on other topics. He never followed up, and neither did anyone else. I didn't see the need to bring up old stuff when no one seemed to care.
I'm not interested in cluttering up the thread with miles of opinions. But, since this seems to be the only thing that matters to you I'll just throw out any and all opinions during the next day that you'd like. I'll start with those four if you give the word, let's just see what the night brings first.
EPT
![[image loading]](http://onlypositive.net/image.axd?picture=2010%2F7%2Fsleeping-kitten.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_hVlWKGgjOIE/StUFndEePPI/AAAAAAAAACo/mTLpd1njmhk/s320/vizzini.jpg)
