I've been trying to analyze this post for the last hour or so, and I have come up with basically nothing. Based on extraneous evidence of Torte, I think that read is a bus. I think Kurumi is a serial killer, because Wiggles seems genuinely confused over him. I think bumatlarge is scum, but again, that is based on other evidence, as well as that I think redFF is town. Chances are 1-2 of his "town" or "no read" players are scum.
As for the rest, I have no clue. It's time for a more experienced player to take this over. I have no idea what sort of thing mafia will tend to do in this situation, or what Mr. Wiggles is likely to do.
On June 04 2011 04:59 Mr. Wiggles wrote:Here's the first part of my reads: # Torte de Lini: Scum+ Show Spoiler +He has contributed literally nothing to the town. Most of his posts have been asking questions, and playing the noob card. I see this as an attempt at thread derailment, as well as trying to find an excuse to lurk without needing to give his thoughts. He was also fingered as mafia, several times in the thread, most notably by deskcaress, at the end of the night. On June 03 2011 03:18 deskscaress wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2011 09:46 deskscaress wrote:hey deconduo, assuming sinani is telling the truth and he will try to revive BC, what will happen to BC is he is revived AFTER bum is killed? is his "retirement" clause then null since he had nothing to do with bum's death?my idea: don't kill sinani tonight lynch bum tomorrow resurrect BC tomorrow night via killing sinani boom, BC is back with no clauses to put him away either way i think we should lynch bum tomorrow because he is not town. sorry bum  quoting this because if deconduo answered it, i missed it, and i honestly think this is a better course of action then bringing back BC if that means we need to keep a CONFIRMED NON-TOWN alive also, as an update on Torte De Lini who claimed last night that he couldn't post any more (i hypothesized that this was likely a soft-claim on a posting restriction, kurumi adamantly stated it was just IRL obligations), he has posted 13 times on TL.net since then, with 0 in this thread. DING DING DING SCUMBELL IS RINGING, I WANT AN EXPLANATION This, combined with the fact that my shot on sinani was redirected to deskscaress, lead me to conclude, that Torte de Lini, is most likely scum. # Kurumi: Serial Killer+ Show Spoiler +He claimed it, so I see no reason for him to be lying. It was a bad claim, and I don't see why he did it, but I’m inclined to believe him. Call out his hits for him, and if he doesn’t follow through, you lynch him dead. If he refuses or shows any resistance to following town directives, kill him. Besides that, he’s useless due to his alignment. # Amber[LighT]: Town+ Show Spoiler +He’s a dog. He’s also a dog who looks like he’s trying to help town. It’s hard to actually get a read on him when his communication is so restricted, but I get the feeling he’s town. Check him with a detective to be sure. # Jackal58 : Town+ Show Spoiler +His big post during the night is probably the single best thing that’s been posted this entire game. He’s trying to get the town back on track, and knock some sense into the 90% of town that made day 1 useless. He’s green. # DropBear: Town+ Show Spoiler +He’s been one of the only people I’ve seen who’s actually been contributing in a meaningful way. He’s not afraid to speak his mind, and from what I’ve seen, has actually done a bit of analysis, and not much name calling. # Barundar: No Read+ Show Spoiler +He has like 4 posts, seriously. Get more active. # sinani206: Town+ Show Spoiler +I personally believe his claim that he’ll bring back BC. Also, his posting smells of unsure green to me. If he were scum, he’d have a lot more direction and focus. This leads me to believe he’s green. # Mataza: Town+ Show Spoiler +Maybe I’m biased here, but he feels like one of the only people who’s using his head and actually realizes there’s (since you guys love throwing this word around) confirmed anti-town, one of whom is scum, just traipsing around. He’s actually using his head, and not jumping on a bandwagon. Actually looks the greenest to me right now. # redFF: Scum+ Show Spoiler +From his nonsensical claim Day 1, to pushing bad lynches, tunneling, and worthlessly arguing, redFF has done more harm than good to town, from what I can see. Now, on Day 2, he is one of the staunchest proponents for my lynch, and I’ll bet you right now, that he’s doing it to look pro-town, and will bring it up that way later in the game that he fought so hard for a DT check, even if it was wrong. There’s also another point to be made. He constantly calls out for town to analyze, yet does no work himself. You judge people by their actions, not by their intents, and redFF has only taken actions which harm the town, leading me to label him as scum. If he’s town, he might as well stop posting, because he’s not doing anything to help. # bumatlarge: Scum+ Show Spoiler +He’s scum. no ifs, ands, or buts.
|
EPT
