|
Does GM's list check work retroactively? Would he be able to find a mole on a list from day one if he checks it tonight?
If we're gonna have GM use his power on earlier lists we might as well make sure it works GM I think you should check the KillerSOS vote from day two. It has Eiii, me, Radfield, and Kita. I think we can all agree that Bum and Chaoser will be cleared barring Caller flipping town. Foolishness isn't checked using this list so Chaoser should check him. Am I leaving anyone out?
|
On May 27 2011 08:28 Radfield wrote: Either the KillerSOS list: Eiii, Meapak, Radfield, Kitaman
Or the Barundar Day 1 list: Radfield, Bumatlarge, Meapak, Kitaman
I think I like the second list better because Bum is mostly confirmed non-mole at this point, and will probably be targeted by the mafia/mole. That means we can narrow it a bit further right off the bat.
Mind you, GM isn't confirmed either, so any list check is somewhat suspect until he is cleared. On that note, it would be best for Chaoser to check GM and any protective roles to protect either Chaoser or GM(heavier emphasis on Chaoser). That leaves Bum on his own, but better that then lose our dt roles. Wow Radfield was that your 1000? Gratz. Anyway I guess the list check is up to GM, I don't see why we would want to include Bum in it when he is pretty much confirmed but either way the list check will get you, me, and Kita who all need to be checked. The reason I favor the first list over the second list is because it gets Eiii as well. And yeah, medics really need to be on Chaoser.
|
Better just tackle the elephant in the room. Foolishness, kita and I are really the only unconfirmed people left at this point. The only thing I know is that I'm neither mole nor mafia so that leaves the other two. My gut says kita. There's really not much else to say. Foolishness you've played a subpar game then what I know you're capable of. However you've acted odd but never down right scummy. Kita on the other hand has acted fairly scummy and lurkerish throughout the portion of the game I've been in. I know kita knows what scummy behavior looks like so there's really no excuse. Tomorrow I have some free time and I'll do analysis of kita to solidify my point, after all I don't expect you all to take my word as a potential suspect without proof.
|
Oh and @Chaoser, rolechecks of the NRA member return vanilla.
|
I'll wait for GM to post before I talk about kita, my read is back to inconclusive and I'm a little suspicious of Eiii again. Could someone tell me exactly why Eiii is cleared?
|
On May 28 2011 05:39 Foolishness wrote: Assuming nothing strange happens, we should have 3 lynches to find the remaining member. I just wanted to bring this to front as well. If we have too we can just carpet lynch kita foolishness and myself. Also, with their 1 KP, mafia can't kill Radfield at night so I think the town is gonna win this regardless of what happens.
|
I posted last night saying that I had doubts about kita being scum and I thought it might be Eiii instead. I'm on my itouch and don't have the doc so I'll try an condense my argument. Kita didn't have a suspicious switch when day three happened. He's played consistent throughout and while he may not have played the greatest he didn't have any indication of suspicious activity. Eiii on the otherhand has gone from lurking soft core to lurking hard core, he's barely been here in the last couple of days.
I also see foolishness is voting for me so I think it's time to claim. I am the meth man, and I breafcrumbed this way back when I was arguing with Incog. I'll get the post when I'm back on my computer but what this means is that mafia can't win. Assumig radfeild isn't the mole then theres no way for the mafia can kill us. The reason I haven't claimed sooner is because I've tried to get the mafia to hit me but I haven't been active enough I guess.
Anyway gonna vote Eiii
|
Oh hi foolishness :D I see you call for me to claim while I'm writing this.
|
Town wins the game. Just leave radfeild and I alive. Eventually one of us will have to night kill the other if we are scum. He kills me he dies. I can't kill him. It's brilliant. Even if one of us is scum we can't kill eachother. GG mafia you guys tried.
|
Wait so if it's day and there's 1 mafia and one town left the mafia wins? The townie can't try and ninja vote the mafia?
|
Here's my breadcrumb
On May 21 2011 10:51 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:Show nested quote +On May 21 2011 10:42 Incognito wrote:On May 21 2011 10:41 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:On May 21 2011 10:37 Incognito wrote: Shooting into the list is not 2/5. Its only 2/5 if Chezinu is town. If Chezinu is mafia, its 1/5, which is worse than randomly shooting into the entire player list. Considering that you're already lynching me, its ridiculous to be shooting Node too. Wake up and stop sheeping Ace/Foolishness/Caller. Incog are you claiming mafia? If you are town you should be want more shots going into that group not less. Why is it foolish to shoot node even if we're lynching you? You should know you're town and want to hurt the mafia as much as possible. False. I don't trust the list check. I think someone was framed. Are you on meth? Man why should we kill you then? If you think someone was framed and you think Chez is mafia then why should we kill you? If someone was framed then that means there is only one mafia in that group. You think Chez is mafia QED you aren't mafia why should we kill you?
|
hey foolishness I think you should probably claim. Everyone else has.
|
Why do we believe Eiii's claim again?
|
GM at this point no townie should be defending themselves like this. I know I told incog that a townie wanting to die is stupid but at this point all townies should be willing to die. Foolishness has called for my death several times and I'd be more than happy to do so in order to prove my alignment. These last few pages have convinced me.
sorry for being afk, I was at the movies -_-
|
Foolishness I think you should claim now. Everyone has claimed and if your role is that good then Kita can just protect you. Otherwise you really have nothing to hide and by not claiming you're starting to remind me of caller.
|
On May 29 2011 12:23 GMarshal wrote:Show nested quote +On May 29 2011 12:22 Foolishness wrote: Or maybe GMarshal will tell you if you ask nicely Do you want me to? Because I'm really confused... Wait if GM knows then how is he scum?
|
I'm unvoting GM. I came home and read through the thread once and made my decision but now that I've read through it again I've changed my mind.
|
|
|
On May 29 2011 12:35 Foolishness wrote: You're not really the methman are you? Oh I am, I just need to flip town. Then if kita dies tonight town kills you. If kita lives town kills kita.
|
On May 29 2011 12:37 GMarshal wrote:Show nested quote +On May 29 2011 12:36 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:On May 29 2011 12:35 Foolishness wrote: You're not really the methman are you? Oh I am, I just need to flip town. Then if kita dies tonight town kills you. If kita lives town kills kita. What? Why are we killing foolishness? My bad, I meant Radfield. Foolishness is probably town since you didn't out him.
|
|
|
|
|
|