|
On March 27 2011 03:06 Tackster wrote:
Ok i've searched and searched and searched and I cannot find the post I'm looking for - someone help me!!
I was certain I read that Jackal had said something along the lines of:
...and then we shoot someone **with coags item**...
But I can't find it in your posts - or anyone else
And i definitely remember something along those lines..
Can anyone point me to the post im talking about?
I wrote that there will be a lot of KPs in day one. At one point I said there might even be a vig-night-kill (*cough* Coag's weapon *cough*). Jackal had nothing to do with it.
Now, as for the arguing: people in the IG have no idea what anyone else in the IG is. Not even the red/black. So the fact that you all decided on someone (tack) doesn't mean much. It's obvious that everyone would be ok with anyone but themselves being lynched. The one person that isn't (Coag, defending Jackal) strikes me as scum, because I also urge people to not lynch a townie, when I know for sure that townie is green/blue (i.e. when I am mafia). But of course, that's too little of a clue to make me think coag is town.
The reasoning for lynching someone, no matter if it came from figuring out PMs or whatever, should be decided by town.
But again, I fear that we HAVE to lynch, and if we miss-lynch there's a huge opportunity for the item game to end tonight (yes, I think that there CAN be 5KPs -or more- total tonight, one way or another, it just depends on who hits who and who stacks what. So if we get rid of one, then one team will only need to kill 4 more people).
So yeah, you can turn this thing on all sides, but the only other alternative would be to lynch outside IG and hope neither team has enough brawn to try and wipe out all the others.
IF we hit the item game, I predict a slaughter. But I could be wrong because, as I said, both teams may fear the other team too much to make a move.
okaaaaaaaay.
so who would I pick from item game? Coag, but that's based purely on that little thing I posted regarding his defense of Jackal.
I like Jackal, but I don't like the "spam contest" in this thread so far, so I'm not placing him as town in my mind. I don't know Tackster, but he seems to be trying hard to be pro-town, so I say, let him keep trying for now. Annul, as I said, 50-50 on him, but at least he's posting.
Darmousseh, no clue, since he's been many afks, and I didn't get any vibes from his postings (i liked the mayor campaign though, even though it was in vain).
That leaves LW. I dunno what to say, the gut feeling was lurking mafia, but if he IS rather new to the game as he's claiming, then it's a bit too of a complicated strategy to adopt for a newbie (keep posting silly things at the start to make people think you're active, when you intend to slip under the radar), plus he reacted pretty well when confronted.
So yeah, that's all based on a 20minute read of the thread. I won't cast a vote, I'll go with whatever Bum chooses (because, after all it's his choice alone), and I trust his judgement. Even if we don't get a scum, I hope we kill a less-than-helpful player. I fear that the fact we have 80 pages so far only makes it harder to do post-analysis, because too many things can slip through the cracks.
|
*i meant "to make me thing coag is red" at the end of the first paragraph. And night one instead of day one in the first paragraph.
|
|
|
"Basically I'm giving people the opportunity to pick their roles right now if they want to play the item game." o_o
so their role = no role?
|
I'm still suspicious of the IG ending in one night scenario that is happening in my head.
If you use one medic protection, and everyone else dies, then you could be sacrificing yourself for your faction by getting all the items and giving them to your friends before you get lynched.
I'm not saying that you are, but you know. It's like a 10% possibility. Based on the number I just pulled out of my tooshie.
|
On March 27 2011 10:11 chaoser wrote:Show nested quote +So yeah, you can turn this thing on all sides, but the only other alternative would be to lynch outside IG and hope neither team has enough brawn to try and wipe out all the others.
IF we hit the item game, I predict a slaughter. But I could be wrong because, as I said, both teams may fear the other team too much to make a move.
okaaaaaaaay.
so who would I pick from item game? Coag, but that's based purely on that little thing I posted regarding his defense of Jackal. So you talk about how it's bad to hit the item game cause it'll lead to a "slaughter" by your predictions and insinuate that we should lynch someone outside it but then go on to talk about lynching coag when we've already established why his logic and defense of Jackal makes sense? Yeah...ok.... No, I said we have only one alternative: not hitting IG and hoping nobody else does either (or that only 1-2 ppl die to make it easy for us). I didn't say we should pick said alternative. I didn't say it's bad to hit IG. I want to hit IG, that's why I went on talking about it. You established it makes sense, I gave your reasons why it might not be as straight-forward as you think. Feel free to ignore me and lynch one of the other four, with 50:50 chances I'm all for that. It just seems TOO good to be true IMO.
|
umm, starting from "No, I said..." that's my post. I placed it before [/quote]. Sorry.
|
That's reserved for the cool posters.
|
|
|
Lol I was about to yell bad words towards bum. Then I was like "Heretic"?!
|
GEE GEE.
Bum for mayor!!
Oh wait...
Bum for GOD!
|
|
|
landmark post
you guys write too much.
what if coag is lying and after we lynch tack mafia kills jackal and lemon. are you two guys willing to take that risk?
|
i'm just asking though, I'm not saying he is, but it seems... well.. too easy.
|
On March 28 2011 12:24 Lanaia wrote:
I really don't think coag is scum. CubEd, do you think he is?
no i don't, but it's not my life on the line. if jackal and lemon are willing to wing it, that's good enough for me to vote for tackster.
|
@Insaneous, fair enough, but why did Tack not die then? If he were vet he'd have claimed so by now.
|
While I disagree with the "couldn't be that stupid" statement, it's a good point.
Most likely it deflected back to whomever checked the guy.
However, you don't know:
a) If only the GF/Miller has the power to come up as something else when checked
b) If mafia got to choose what GF comes up as
See, we're not 100% sure that mafia got to choose what GF would come up as, since they wouldn't really know the powers in the game to begin with.
|
So, what are you saying then? That he was framed blue? That he is GF and mafia picked a blue role just to screw with town DTs? For someone in the mafia game who was bound to be either killed by blacks or hanged, or checked by towns while the other blues were most certainly still alive.
|
That kinda makes sense. Coag would be "visiting" whoever he was shooting. If they switched Annul with Tack, then Coag would have visited Annul to shoot him (unknowingly) and could have gone out with a bang.
|
Yeah, no.
I do believe that you're the bus driver and have switched bum and lemon, otherwise the lemon check wouldn't have made sense in a LOT of scenarios.
Now, we still need to figure out why Tack didn't die. Two bus drivers might be a bit much indeed.
The only thing is, mafia thought Jackal would hit, not Coag, so whatever happened, couldn't have been a spell cast on Coag.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
