I don't feel like you should claim, unless there is a growing wagon on you, or if you are the utmost vote getter when it is nearing the end of the day. Unnecessary claiming is generally bad for the town. If you're a good player, it will only get you killed, and if you are just a vanilla townie, it will isolate you from the scum having to spend KP on you when they might not have been able to dismiss you being a power role.

I will take a harder look at Aidnai this cycle, and this is mainly in part because of an initial town read on him, but I'm going to give him a second chance through not voting him right now. Instead, I am going to vote for SiNiquity. He has been lurking, yet active, so my first reason is active lurking. My second reason is that he has not been pro-town. If someone could point me to something beneficial he has done, by all means, I missed it.

vote: Siniquity

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 16 2011 11:07 GMT

#706

On February 16 2011 16:42 beefy187 wrote:
Spread out the votes. We need to pressure other peoples.

what is the point of this post?

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 16 2011 11:09 GMT

#707

oh, he can only cast OMGUS

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 16 2011 14:25 GMT

#718

now i see why jonn looked so scummy. doctors always look scummy. i was really considering him to be mafia, but that just shows how off my reads are this game :\

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 17 2011 10:40 GMT

#800

The modkill sucks, but thefluffyone93 is likely scum, so we should actually be happy. Hats off on catching scum. Vote appropriately, medics protect me, etc.

If there is a vigilante out there, please hit Believer. Thx.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 18 2011 18:19 GMT

#904

I've been really ill, apologies. I'll catch up tonight.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 19 2011 11:46 GMT

#928

Yet again another attempted wagon on me. Not surprising. Do you all feel these are town wagons or scum wagons? I'm leaning towards the latter.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 19 2011 12:11 GMT

#929

I'm not going to look into any exact votes, or cast any OMGUS votes in the next phase. It is nearing time where we need to massclaim roles for the good of the town, to sort all of this out. Pretty sure Deconduo is town, and Siniquity is scum, if I had to throw out some reads from my reading. In terms of "who is actually scum" based upon an obvious slip, well that would be Insanious. His pm is obviously fake to me. I will be voting him tomorrow.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 19 2011 23:15 GMT

#987

Insanious is obviously mafia with the italicization mixup
vote: Insanious
I know we're in a bad spot, but this is an easy one, guys.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 20 2011 02:20 GMT

#1010

Chaoser is pretty convincing

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 20 2011 10:11 GMT

#1046

I just can't get over Insanious slipping up on that PM
Can you explain that?

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 04:16 GMT

#1070

I'd like to see an actual case brought up on me, because there can't be one. It is really impossible, and the fabrication would be laughable.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 04:35 GMT

#1073

skewed, and not even funny. I really wish I had something to do tonight, but I have to sit here and wait on them to pick who they are killing.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 05:48 GMT

#1081

The fact that I've been relatively inactive does not take away from me being town, try again.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 06:52 GMT

#1083

We can't worry about uselessness when it is possibly LYLO, and barring the way this resolves tonight, I wouldn't be surprised if we had lost. We need to be worried about who isn't town, not who is "useful". You aren't really being useful either, with your unfounded accusations which are not only misleading but falsities and lies.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 09:43 GMT

#1085

My contribution lies through the fact that I am voting people properly, based upon them messing up illogically where it would be logical for town to not mess up. I feel as if your unfounded accusations lie through the likelihood that you, yourself, flipped scum, and are trying to derail a thread in which you're dead in.

You then begin to attack me as opposed to my words, calling me "jumpy", when I am in fact not jumpy whatsoever. You say I exhibited the same information I did Day 1? Probably because I'm the same role, with the same information.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 11:19 GMT

#1089

So, from my perspective, GMarshal is my town read.
Considering there were only 2 kills, I'm guessing the SK is dead.
That means either SiNiquity or Beefy is town, and the one who isn't is the Godfather.
If it's 3v1, like I expect, the proper play is to no lynch as it is MYLO
if it is 2v1v1, with the mafia and the SK still left, having cross-killed, we are fucked
In that scenario, it would be best to no lynch hoping they try to kill each other, leaving us in proper-LYLO tomorrow.

This shouldn't even really be a discussion, because we can't no lynch, so look at my aforementioned points that GMarshal is pretty clear through my eyes via his behavior towards me in PMs. I am not familiar with Beefy's play, but I have to say that I have not really seen SiNiquity ever try this hard, and it has me up in arms. I really feel like he is the most likely to be the last scum.

Vote: SiNiquity

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 22 2011 01:50 GMT

#1133

I hadn't claimed because I'm just a vanilla townie, and I didn't want to out all the power roles through deductive reasoning. SiNiquity is feeling more town lately, and seems to be genuinely scumhunting. I really wish we could No Lynch, as that would be the better play.

GMarshall's post by post analysis on Beefy is pretty good.
unvote

On February 21 2011 23:02 beefy187 wrote:
Vote: gryffindor

gryffindor has lived for too long. I believe he is the last surviving baddy and he must be lynched.

I also don't like this post. He says I'm "the last baddy", without any reasoning.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 22 2011 01:51 GMT

#1134

I need to talk to the moderator about something.

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 22 2011 06:52 GMT

#1151

vote: SiNiquity
I don't believe you're scum;
I believe Beefy is
I'm sorry for re-voting you, but I have a more town-sided read on GMarshal than you, so I believe it is more likely you might stack with me on him than him stacking on you. I fully expect Beefy to come in, vote you, and split the votes (if you put a 2nd vote on him) because he is the last scum

That could go to No Lynch, though I doubt it will. We have to assume we are in MYLO since there were only two kills last night.

Beefy is the last scum, please vote him SiNiquity