On December 30 2010 07:02 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
When it comes to Annul, I was really trying to find another candidate who I could put up as a MH bomb because when I divide the player list by 3 instead of 2 it GREATLY reduces the chance of overlapping bombs. On top of that the way Annul got support is a little fishy, I need to do more analysis on it but it is still extremely strange. The bandwagon IMO should never have been so lopsided in favor of LSB even though I think LSB was suspicious, it is really hard to gather a following on a day 1 lynch UNLESS you are mafia. With that justification and an indepth analysis of Annul being very time consuming at the moment I would prefer to put a bomb on him while doing a further analysis later.

"lets kill annul but i cant really explain why"

preempting the retort: "but i did explain why!"

more than 5 or 6 or whatever players joined my wagon. this means IF your contention would be right, then at least some townies also agreed (hell, YOU did). therefore my logic was not bad.

LSB lied hardcore to save his ass. so, if the town agreed, why does that mean i am mafia?

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 30 2010 05:12 GMT

#761

On December 30 2010 11:16 bumatlarge wrote:
Annul never calls him out on this facet of being either vig or scum.

i called him out on having no possible role with which his claim would fit... close enough?

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 30 2010 05:13 GMT

#762

On December 30 2010 12:35 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
right now I would prefer to go after Annul but I feel to get the backing on that would require very hard analysis. Tonight's hits make me think Annul is likely mafia and I can explain why.

knowing you i am sure it will come, yes yes?

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 30 2010 05:18 GMT

#764

he said he could prove =beyond a shadow of a doubt= his blueness by the end of night 2, "maybe earlier".

no role exists in this game that can do that.

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 30 2010 05:30 GMT

#766

no.

"DT checks him" is not PROVEN. could be fake DT, who knows?
no GUARANTEE that mafia would hit him night 1. so, before night 2 is 100% not a guaranteed proof.

after night 2 there is no PROOF the vig would hit him. in fact no vig would blow his load on LSB to "prove" veteran status. losing the vig shot is strictly worse for us than losing a veteran.

the point is yes there were many ways he COULD show he was a veteran IF the right people acted and IF the town believed their words, but as for PROOF, there was none. he claimed he could prove it. he couldnt.

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 30 2010 07:53 GMT

#784

On December 30 2010 16:23 why wrote:
If red, we wouldn't be hurt that much by having a red in the town for a couple more days, especially since we could then analyze his behavior and voting more.

higher KP

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 31 2010 03:48 GMT

#833

you know, i like this jackal guy

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 31 2010 05:08 GMT

#845

uh

what

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 31 2010 10:37 GMT

#867

On December 31 2010 18:01 Incognito wrote:
Day has been extended and will end on Saturday at 10:00 EST.

10:00 = 10 AM?

do you mean 22:00?

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 31 2010 22:17 GMT

#880

On January 01 2011 04:12 Mr.Zergling wrote:
Ok, so I had a blue role in HP mafia (we all kind of did).

less than half the town did ;\

annul

United States2841 Posts

January 01 2011 12:33 GMT

#906

what is the difference between using IRC logs and using "PM logs?"

PM logs are just as forgeable and people accept them all the time

annul

United States2841 Posts

January 01 2011 21:49 GMT

#922

uh

i just woke up. i went to a party last night and got home at 7:30 am

im a flat green. i got LSB wrong, yeah. sorry about that, i tried. but so did a bunch of other people so its not really all my bad. i sort of expected retribution but apparently i wake up to see a wagon on my ass despite like everybody saying they were on my side regardless. i guess they arent now.