EPT
Pick Your Power Mafia 3! - Page 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Barundar
Denmark1582 Posts
| ||
|
Barundar
Denmark1582 Posts
The difference between jimbos and bc's argument against deconduo was what they tried to nail him on. Bc speculated that deconduo could be fake claiming sk, and through the thread became more certain of himself. Jimbo simply analysed. Arguing that deconduo was scum beceause he fake claimed sk would of course give away how he knew. | ||
|
Barundar
Denmark1582 Posts
On January 24 2011 17:16 JimboSilvers wrote: That's pretty cool reasoning but it's clearly something you made in hindsight: i posted my analysis of deconduo before he ever said a word about his cc or sk claim. After that I didn't really post until like 50 hours later and talked about other people lol. And after fishball was lynched it was obvious decon had to be scum so it's irrelevant at that point.Wasn't in hindsigt! Ace kept the role list hidden from me so I had to keep guessing. Guess it would then have been faulty reasoning with a lucky correct answer. On January 24 2011 17:17 Incognito wrote: Jimbo actually fingered deconduo before LSB flipped. Even so, what would SK gain by getting town to lynch the other SK? So much easier just to snipe him at night without anyone ever knowing. He wasn't trying to get an SK lynched, but a scum fake claiming SK. My theory was he just kept information he had regarding deconduo secret, while BC reasoned his way into assuming deconduo was fake claiming openly. The real SK knew deconduo was fake claiming, and had no interest in sharing this information with the town. BC would thus have had to put up a nice show in the thread to be the SK. Atleast it made sense in my head | ||
| ||
